they don't build them like they used to....do they?
they don't build them like they used to....do they?
Author
Discussion

E21_Ross

Original Poster:

36,729 posts

243 months

Thursday 11th March 2010
quotequote all
Would you say this is true for most manufacturers? I see so many modern cars broken down on the side of the roads, and you hear of so many things like electrical gremlins which new cars suffer with that old cars obviously don't. will there be many of todays modern cars on the road in 20+ years time? my car is about 28 years old now and is still pretty much fully functioning. the only build quality issue is just 1 button in the interior went. my friend has a 20 year old merc which is also fine, everything works on it. sure they may be a little rough around the edges or whatever, but they still keep going without much fuss. you hear of so many cars having to go back to the dealers for various issues (one person i know has a '58 plate leon which wouldn't turn off, even with the key out of the ignition! had to stall it each time to turn it off).

modern merc's (particularly around the year 2000) are absolutely dreadful, i hear so many horror stories. my father had a 2006 (bought it brand new) CLK350 cab, and in 60k miles over 3 years it needed over £7k of warranty work doing to it, and it was at the dealers at least once every month or so. once, he broke down in it, and there was me in my little ancient car having to give him a lift back.

what you reckon? or is it just me? hehe

Herman Toothrot

6,702 posts

229 months

Thursday 11th March 2010
quotequote all
Un-necessary over complication will always cause problems.

dugt

1,657 posts

238 months

Thursday 11th March 2010
quotequote all
When ever you speak to someone about their (modern) car, if its broken down, id say its 7/10 chance its electrical.

Cars are more reliable, but when they do go wrong, they go wrong big time. And its not something you will be fixing by the sid of the road, or even at home.


RobM77

35,349 posts

265 months

Thursday 11th March 2010
quotequote all
The Mercedes issue was due to the Chrysler take-over, and Toyota have admitted to a recent dip in quality as they've expanded (but given their incredible reliability record, Toyota getting 20% worse is still better than most cars!). So those things aside, I don't think build quality has got worse on the whole, it's just that cars are an awful lot more complicated than they used to be, and in that respect cars have probably got better to retain the same level of reliability. Back in the 1980s cars were practically the same as they were in the 60s - under the bonnet was a simple bringing together of a number of recognisable and user serviceable parts; cars looked like they did in my childhood books of "how things work". smile Now cars have a myriad of technological wizardry; the new Fiesta has gadgets that were only just appearing on the S class 20 years ago!

Looking back at my recent car history and the cars that my family have owned (5 BMWs, a Lotus, 4 Toyotas and 1 Audi) I can't actually recall any notable problems. The odd sensor's gone here and there, but really nothing major.

The only evidence I have to the contrary is for two makes in particular. Firstly, I know plenty of people with Fords that have gone wrong a fair bit (recently I can recall one head gasket failure at 80k miles, one big end bearing failure at 60k miles and one exhaust failure at 30k miles) or Vauxhalls (our company cars were all Vauxhalls and their lack of reliability was legendary!), but I think Ford and Vauxhall have always been a bit like that, so I don't think things have changed really.

durbster

12,147 posts

253 months

Thursday 11th March 2010
quotequote all
The old cars that are still going are still going because they are reliable, not because they're old cars. If you see what I mean smile

In the years that 20 year old Merc has been running, there are hundreds of thousands of cars from that era that weren't built well enough to last and have long since rotted, failed or blown themselves to bits.

However, I was chatting to a mate about this recently. Assuming no great revolution in auto-engineering, what on earth are people going to be driving in 30 years time? What about the people who live in remote areas? There are a lot of places in the world where bush-mechanics keep people alive - what will happen there? Who's going to want to cross a desert in a vehicle that can only be fixed by plugging it into the nearest Mitsubishi dealership?

What will be the workhorses of the future?

LuS1fer

43,572 posts

276 months

Thursday 11th March 2010
quotequote all
Cars are so much faster now, they are more stressed and spend more of their lives at higher speeds. Cars in the 70's all rusted away, you rarely see 80's cars now and that leaves the 90's really and my 1996 Golf GTi isn't particularly reliable, believe me. In my 30-odd years driving, there have always been cars broken down at the side of the road but now there are twice as many of them!

jbi

12,700 posts

235 months

Thursday 11th March 2010
quotequote all
as a former owner of an austin maestro I can say hand on heart...

THANK GOD they don't build them like they used to.




E21_Ross

Original Poster:

36,729 posts

243 months

Thursday 11th March 2010
quotequote all
durbster said:
What will be the workhorses of the future?
mercs and beemers which are already over 20 years old which have a lot of welding on them hehe

28 years and, touch wood, mine's pretty much rot free at the moment smile

jbi

12,700 posts

235 months

Thursday 11th March 2010
quotequote all
durbster said:
What will be the workhorses of the future?
Body on frame vehicles

E21_Ross

Original Poster:

36,729 posts

243 months

Thursday 11th March 2010
quotequote all
LuS1fer said:
Cars are so much faster now, they are more stressed and spend more of their lives at higher speeds......

........there have always been cars broken down at the side of the road but now there are twice as many of them!
2 very valid points actually

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 11th March 2010
quotequote all
durbster said:
What about the people who live in remote areas? There are a lot of places in the world where bush-mechanics keep people alive - what will happen there? Who's going to want to cross a desert in a vehicle that can only be fixed by plugging it into the nearest Mitsubishi dealership?

What will be the workhorses of the future?
On a trip a few years ago to pakistan i went into an electronics store and shock horror you could still buy a brand new LG black and white TV (with a built in game!). If the market is out there then manufacturers will cater for it. Some of the basic Suzuki cars sold there had vinyl seat backing and even the option of raised suspension to cope with the roads. Engines were ridiculously small too. It's what the people and economy wanted so they got it. Over there complicated electronics aren't wanted as most servicing is carried out by small garages who have no diagnostic stuff. Hence very basic cars (some with tape players too).

x type

1,024 posts

221 months

Thursday 11th March 2010
quotequote all
jbi said:
as a former owner of an austin maestro I can say hand on heart...

THANK GOD they don't build them like they used to.
paah they were luxury ,I had an allegro , 3yrs old and holes in the floor from rust

cars are too complicated these days , my dad was a mechanic for almost 50yrs always did his own and our cars servicing , opened the bonnet of his Kalos when he bought it 3 yrs ago and promptly closed it again looking bewildered eek , and they aren't the most complicated on the road

Opened the bonnet of my Jag and he nearly fainted laugh

Ozzie Osmond

21,189 posts

277 months

Thursday 11th March 2010
quotequote all
I am firmly of the opinion that cars are much more reliable now than they used to be. Amongst other things solid state electronics are very dependable.

Cars used to be rusty as hell after 3 or 5 years and worn out at 50,000 miles. 10 years and 100,000 miles is just for starters these days.

Negative Creep

26,153 posts

258 months

Thursday 11th March 2010
quotequote all
Shaid GTB said:
durbster said:
What about the people who live in remote areas? There are a lot of places in the world where bush-mechanics keep people alive - what will happen there? Who's going to want to cross a desert in a vehicle that can only be fixed by plugging it into the nearest Mitsubishi dealership?

What will be the workhorses of the future?
On a trip a few years ago to pakistan i went into an electronics store and shock horror you could still buy a brand new LG black and white TV (with a built in game!). If the market is out there then manufacturers will cater for it. Some of the basic Suzuki cars sold there had vinyl seat backing and even the option of raised suspension to cope with the roads. Engines were ridiculously small too. It's what the people and economy wanted so they got it. Over there complicated electronics aren't wanted as most servicing is carried out by small garages who have no diagnostic stuff. Hence very basic cars (some with tape players too).
I was wondering this after watching the Top Gear South American roadtrip. How on earth would you fix a modern Range Rover if it broke in the middle of nowhere? What will people in such countries do?

iamrcb

607 posts

227 months

Thursday 11th March 2010
quotequote all
modern cars --> sensor problems

with older cars its more like time vs rust

dugt

1,657 posts

238 months

Thursday 11th March 2010
quotequote all
Negative Creep said:
Shaid GTB said:
durbster said:
What about the people who live in remote areas? There are a lot of places in the world where bush-mechanics keep people alive - what will happen there? Who's going to want to cross a desert in a vehicle that can only be fixed by plugging it into the nearest Mitsubishi dealership?

What will be the workhorses of the future?
On a trip a few years ago to pakistan i went into an electronics store and shock horror you could still buy a brand new LG black and white TV (with a built in game!). If the market is out there then manufacturers will cater for it. Some of the basic Suzuki cars sold there had vinyl seat backing and even the option of raised suspension to cope with the roads. Engines were ridiculously small too. It's what the people and economy wanted so they got it. Over there complicated electronics aren't wanted as most servicing is carried out by small garages who have no diagnostic stuff. Hence very basic cars (some with tape players too).
I was wondering this after watching the Top Gear South American roadtrip. How on earth would you fix a modern Range Rover if it broke in the middle of nowhere? What will people in such countries do?
You don't. I think theres a reason that when ever you see places like that on tv, its always landcruisers and hilux.

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 11th March 2010
quotequote all
I believe I have the best of both worlds, though many would disagree. smile A late plate model of the Mk1 Ford Ka, an '08 manufactured in Nov. 2007 to be exact, owned since new. The mechanics are so simple and have been around for so long, very easy to work on and do your own servicing on it. As for the rust issue, I've just had it completely rustproofed with Dinitrol so rust shouldn't be a problem for quite some time.

It will be interesting to see how modern cars will look in 10 years. I am suspicious of the popularity of plastic mouldings fitted to door sills from the factory on new cars. Aren't these just designed to hide rust? I know modern cars are galvanised, but its no secret that galvanised metal can end up rusting bad given enough time and due circumstances.

durbster

12,147 posts

253 months

Friday 12th March 2010
quotequote all
dugt said:
Negative Creep said:
I was wondering this after watching the Top Gear South American roadtrip. How on earth would you fix a modern Range Rover if it broke in the middle of nowhere? What will people in such countries do?
You don't. I think theres a reason that when ever you see places like that on tv, its always landcruisers and hilux.
Yes, but the point is they're old Land Cruisers and Hiluxes. The modern Land Cruiser is just as useless as a modern Range Rover in the bush, if it goes wrong.

braddo

12,432 posts

219 months

Friday 12th March 2010
quotequote all
With a few exceptions I'd say cars are generally far more reliable today. Overcomplicated electronics and a myriad of sensors seem to be the main culprit these days. If modern cars were built with the electronic simplicity of, say, E30 BMWs and 190e Mercs, with naturally aspirated petrol engines, average reliability would be astonishing.

If only all the speed cushions could be removed from our roads the suspension would last a lot longer too!

HellDiver

5,708 posts

213 months

Friday 12th March 2010
quotequote all
You are either young, or have a bad memory. The late 70's and early 80's were pretty dire with Ford, Vauxhall and British Leyland.