Decisions decisons
Discussion
Hey chaps,
Well my finance on my current car is drawing to a close and be it that I am coming up to the ripe age of 22, I feel I deserve something rather special after spending 5 years in french tin cans. So today whilst pottering around I noticed a rather clean looking Astra Vxr on a 58 plate in a local Vauxhall garrage. It is up for £15k, but I have another car to trade in and I am sure I could knock some money off (I hope). The price doesn't bother me as I have wanted that car for a while. What is holding me back slightly is my urge for an Impreza. I know they are totally different platforms (driven wheels, engine type etc), but on an every day basis what would be the better car?
I cover about 50 miles a day for 4 days and the occasional blast up to Wales to go riding.
It will be good to hear your opinions on both. Up until now I have only driven the VXR and wow it was absalutely fantastic in a straight line and surprisingly good around the twisties, but I wasn't pushing it.
'Enzo
Well my finance on my current car is drawing to a close and be it that I am coming up to the ripe age of 22, I feel I deserve something rather special after spending 5 years in french tin cans. So today whilst pottering around I noticed a rather clean looking Astra Vxr on a 58 plate in a local Vauxhall garrage. It is up for £15k, but I have another car to trade in and I am sure I could knock some money off (I hope). The price doesn't bother me as I have wanted that car for a while. What is holding me back slightly is my urge for an Impreza. I know they are totally different platforms (driven wheels, engine type etc), but on an every day basis what would be the better car?
I cover about 50 miles a day for 4 days and the occasional blast up to Wales to go riding.
It will be good to hear your opinions on both. Up until now I have only driven the VXR and wow it was absalutely fantastic in a straight line and surprisingly good around the twisties, but I wasn't pushing it.
'Enzo
Hi,
i have driven my mates VXR and it is brutal! Never driven an Impreza but again they are awsome machines.
Out of the two the Scooby would be the better car no doubt about it but that perfomance comes at a price. I think servicing is very regular (i think its 6kmiles similar to the Evo but not 100% sure)
The VXR is a bit more subtle with its performance, IMO, as it doesnt have massive spoilers etc...
It depends in what your after in a car really. Both are good but the Impreza wins hand down on the performance side of things.
HTH?
i have driven my mates VXR and it is brutal! Never driven an Impreza but again they are awsome machines.
Out of the two the Scooby would be the better car no doubt about it but that perfomance comes at a price. I think servicing is very regular (i think its 6kmiles similar to the Evo but not 100% sure)
The VXR is a bit more subtle with its performance, IMO, as it doesnt have massive spoilers etc...
It depends in what your after in a car really. Both are good but the Impreza wins hand down on the performance side of things.
HTH?
There are definitely other cars in that sector to consider if you're looking at the VXR
Focus ST - Great alrounder, good spec, comfortable, and looks ok - Fantastic engine note from the 5 cylinder lump.
Mazda3 MPS - Good value for money, quicker, handles better and better built the VXR - Go for an Aero Kitted car though. Late old shape ones had leather/alcantara trim.
Civic Type R - Down on power, but still an entertaining drive (The older shape was definitely a better car though) Needs to be thrashed to get the best out of it though.
All similar money, but definitely wouldn't buy the VXR without driving the others first. I've driven all 4 quite a bit, and the Astra would be bottom of the list for me
Focus ST - Great alrounder, good spec, comfortable, and looks ok - Fantastic engine note from the 5 cylinder lump.
Mazda3 MPS - Good value for money, quicker, handles better and better built the VXR - Go for an Aero Kitted car though. Late old shape ones had leather/alcantara trim.
Civic Type R - Down on power, but still an entertaining drive (The older shape was definitely a better car though) Needs to be thrashed to get the best out of it though.
All similar money, but definitely wouldn't buy the VXR without driving the others first. I've driven all 4 quite a bit, and the Astra would be bottom of the list for me
Diablos-666 said:
Hi,
i have driven my mates VXR and it is brutal! Never driven an Impreza but again they are awsome machines.
Out of the two the Scooby would be the better car no doubt about it but that perfomance comes at a price. I think servicing is very regular (i think its 6kmiles similar to the Evo but not 100% sure)
The VXR is a bit more subtle with its performance, IMO, as it doesnt have massive spoilers etc...
It depends in what your after in a car really. Both are good but the Impreza wins hand down on the performance side of things.
HTH?
Sorry what does HTH mean? I am new to this forum you see.i have driven my mates VXR and it is brutal! Never driven an Impreza but again they are awsome machines.
Out of the two the Scooby would be the better car no doubt about it but that perfomance comes at a price. I think servicing is very regular (i think its 6kmiles similar to the Evo but not 100% sure)
The VXR is a bit more subtle with its performance, IMO, as it doesnt have massive spoilers etc...
It depends in what your after in a car really. Both are good but the Impreza wins hand down on the performance side of things.
HTH?
Oh yes the Astra is rather brutal. The one that I test drove had a courtney exhaust and a remus remap, so you can imagine the pace of the car and WOW the noise from that exhaust. In particular on over run... God I am getting excited again lol.
I was under the impression that servicing on Impreza's is every 10k, or this no longer the case? As for what I am looking from a car is, an every day car which can take my bike, all of my crap that I carry around with me, be able to get my friends into the car without too much discomfort (try doing that in a c2, it is impossible) and then when I fancy it for the car to blow my (pardon the cheesyness) socks off.
Insurance wise, this isn't a massive issue. I know you don't buy either of these cars for mpg, but out of interest what do they do? My driving style is not that fast to be honest, but I do really enjoy going to north Wales for a quick blast shall we say. Oh and I want some extra power (mainly torque and no I don't want a diesel) to overtake the typical sunday motorist with ease.
The Astra had 19" wheels, which to me seem really quite excessive and also they must be rather expensive to replace the tyres on lol. So how much would tyres be for said size alloy?

Thanks chaps
Edited by Vincenzo2010 on Friday 12th March 15:44
Superhoop said:
There are definitely other cars in that sector to consider if you're looking at the VXR
Focus ST - Great alrounder, good spec, comfortable, and looks ok - Fantastic engine note from the 5 cylinder lump.
Mazda3 MPS - Good value for money, quicker, handles better and better built the VXR - Go for an Aero Kitted car though. Late old shape ones had leather/alcantara trim.
Civic Type R - Down on power, but still an entertaining drive (The older shape was definitely a better car though) Needs to be thrashed to get the best out of it though.
All similar money, but definitely wouldn't buy the VXR without driving the others first. I've driven all 4 quite a bit, and the Astra would be bottom of the list for me
I did go to look at a Focus ST today, but most of the Ford garrages I go to these days have nothing but the mundane fiesta's and focus's. But I shall keep my eyes pealed. I would have never thought of the Mazda as I know nothing of them. I will do a little research into the mps I think, thanks for the heads up on that car. As for the Civic, a friend had the anniversary now that was a great car and that engine... WOW, it is quite raw. But I want a car with torque, just for when I want to cruise and not have to drop it down a few cogs all the time to make the car make decent progress. So for me the Civic is a no no. Focus ST - Great alrounder, good spec, comfortable, and looks ok - Fantastic engine note from the 5 cylinder lump.
Mazda3 MPS - Good value for money, quicker, handles better and better built the VXR - Go for an Aero Kitted car though. Late old shape ones had leather/alcantara trim.
Civic Type R - Down on power, but still an entertaining drive (The older shape was definitely a better car though) Needs to be thrashed to get the best out of it though.
All similar money, but definitely wouldn't buy the VXR without driving the others first. I've driven all 4 quite a bit, and the Astra would be bottom of the list for me
Edited by Vincenzo2010 on Friday 12th March 15:51
HTH - Hope This Helps
Well as i said it is my mate that owns the VXR - He has the 19" Alloys and these do look much better than the standard 18"
He had to replace an alloy the other day as a pot hole cracked the wheel. Think he paid £350 for the wheel but he did go to the main stealer!
Tyre costs vary, if you want a good quality tyre on any size wheel then you will pay premium and on a VXR i would recommend a good tyre to get all that power on the road.
As for mpg - for the performance i think its very good. We both went on a 200mile round trip a few weeks ago. Him in his VXR and me in my mk1 rs, he got about 35mpg whereas i got about 25mpg. We did have a few little burts but nothing major as his mrs was in the car.
I think his 6th gear helped that, the RS only has 5 gears so at cruising speed the revs are quite high.
As for other cars to consider, i really cant think of another car that can match the VXR for the money.
Oh actually there is one... its called the VXR nuremburg
You could consider:
The clio V6 but that isnt practical
Golf r32 - Nice car but £400 per year to tax!
Focus ST - A good all rounder but not special
Mk1 Focus RS - AMAZING CAR
Civic TR - Not enough grunt
EVO / Scooby - Servicing every mile
Well as i said it is my mate that owns the VXR - He has the 19" Alloys and these do look much better than the standard 18"
He had to replace an alloy the other day as a pot hole cracked the wheel. Think he paid £350 for the wheel but he did go to the main stealer!
Tyre costs vary, if you want a good quality tyre on any size wheel then you will pay premium and on a VXR i would recommend a good tyre to get all that power on the road.
As for mpg - for the performance i think its very good. We both went on a 200mile round trip a few weeks ago. Him in his VXR and me in my mk1 rs, he got about 35mpg whereas i got about 25mpg. We did have a few little burts but nothing major as his mrs was in the car.
I think his 6th gear helped that, the RS only has 5 gears so at cruising speed the revs are quite high.
As for other cars to consider, i really cant think of another car that can match the VXR for the money.
Oh actually there is one... its called the VXR nuremburg

You could consider:
The clio V6 but that isnt practical
Golf r32 - Nice car but £400 per year to tax!
Focus ST - A good all rounder but not special
Mk1 Focus RS - AMAZING CAR

Civic TR - Not enough grunt
EVO / Scooby - Servicing every mile
Vincenzo2010 said:
Hey chaps,
Well my finance on my current car is drawing to a close and be it that I am coming up to the ripe age of 22, I feel I deserve something rather special after spending 5 years in french tin cans. So today whilst pottering around I noticed a rather clean looking Astra Vxr on a 58 plate in a local Vauxhall garrage. It is up for £15k, but I have another car to trade in and I am sure I could knock some money off (I hope). The price doesn't bother me as I have wanted that car for a while. What is holding me back slightly is my urge for an Impreza. I know they are totally different platforms (driven wheels, engine type etc), but on an every day basis what would be the better car?
I cover about 50 miles a day for 4 days and the occasional blast up to Wales to go riding.
It will be good to hear your opinions on both. Up until now I have only driven the VXR and wow it was absalutely fantastic in a straight line and surprisingly good around the twisties, but I wasn't pushing it.
'Enzo
Hi there.Well my finance on my current car is drawing to a close and be it that I am coming up to the ripe age of 22, I feel I deserve something rather special after spending 5 years in french tin cans. So today whilst pottering around I noticed a rather clean looking Astra Vxr on a 58 plate in a local Vauxhall garrage. It is up for £15k, but I have another car to trade in and I am sure I could knock some money off (I hope). The price doesn't bother me as I have wanted that car for a while. What is holding me back slightly is my urge for an Impreza. I know they are totally different platforms (driven wheels, engine type etc), but on an every day basis what would be the better car?
I cover about 50 miles a day for 4 days and the occasional blast up to Wales to go riding.
It will be good to hear your opinions on both. Up until now I have only driven the VXR and wow it was absalutely fantastic in a straight line and surprisingly good around the twisties, but I wasn't pushing it.
'Enzo
My view falls into 2 camps here.
1. The VXR is fairly fast, newish and not a bad all rounder.
2. But on the other hand it'll depreciate like a French man living next door to a brothel. And if I was 22 and had £15k to spank on a motorcar, a sodding Astra would be just about the last thing I'd ever, ever think of looking at.
This isn't to bash the VXR, just more of a general bash at that type of luke warm mass produced mainstream shopping cart.
If you want something fast, fun and interesting - go and buy something fast, fun and interesting.
50 miles a day is not so far. And by the sounds of it you don't need anything that practical.
Would have thought anything from a Corvette to an Elise or VX220 Turbo should be more the sort of thing to look at.
Hell, even at £8k to spend there are a host of fast, fun, interesting vehicles that won't break the bank to run and maintain and aren't likely to cost any more or with any more risk to run than the VXR.
Hope this comes across how I'm meaning it. But it just reminds me of my younger days, when you say to someone what car would you get if you won the lottery and they reply a Vuaxhall Nova with a 2.0 litre and seventeeens....
If it has to be a fast Vauxhall, at least look at a Monaro.
RWD - good looks - great noise - handles well - huge fun - V8 engine - fast in stock trim - loads of tuning potential.

Wow 35 mpg that is very impressive, he must have been tickling the throttle to achieve that. At times I can barely get that in my C2 VTS, but then I guess that is because she is broken.
So servicing on the VXR, is that every 10k? I haven't had a proper performance car before so this is all new to me and I am basing it on my dads e90 M3. Again totally different cars, but would they share simular servicing costs? Different levels of servicing etc.
Coming from a motorsport background, would it be better to have the 18" wheels as do the 19" wheels effect the ride comfort and also performance whilst under hard cornering? I have always stuck to the under 16" rule.
Are Vauxhall garrages good at fixing problems? As Citroen are CRAP and also the service managers know sweet f*ck all about cars. Many times I have had to correct them. Bloodey Frenchists
Hmm I have loads more questions to ask as I am so excited about the prospect of having my first proper car
So servicing on the VXR, is that every 10k? I haven't had a proper performance car before so this is all new to me and I am basing it on my dads e90 M3. Again totally different cars, but would they share simular servicing costs? Different levels of servicing etc.
Coming from a motorsport background, would it be better to have the 18" wheels as do the 19" wheels effect the ride comfort and also performance whilst under hard cornering? I have always stuck to the under 16" rule.
Are Vauxhall garrages good at fixing problems? As Citroen are CRAP and also the service managers know sweet f*ck all about cars. Many times I have had to correct them. Bloodey Frenchists

Hmm I have loads more questions to ask as I am so excited about the prospect of having my first proper car

If it's the normal VXR going for 15k, then your stepping into VXR Nurburgring territory
http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/1558485.htm
More or less the same as a normal VXR, but atleast the nurburgring edition should'nt depreciate as much or as quickly.
http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/1558485.htm
More or less the same as a normal VXR, but atleast the nurburgring edition should'nt depreciate as much or as quickly.
Edited by Otter Smacker on Friday 12th March 16:15
theaxe said:
I have always wanted the v8 model of this car, especially in black. I would have thought this type of car though would be miles out side of my budget? Oh I am a big fan of Caterhams, vx220's both the turbo and n/a etc. Just I get put off (this doesn't apply to the Caterham as they are f*cking cool) by the mid engine in the VX, due to expensive servicing and for when something goes wrong. It all seems like it will cost a bomb. But this all seems to go away when I think of the mk 2 clio V6, now that is a awesome car.
Well I think you guys have planted my feet a bit, as I have just managed to drive a drive a car with lots of power and become rather too excited. Before I went to Vauxhall this morning I had my heart set on something rear wheel drive and in particular something that won't look ridiculous next to my dads BMW E90 M3
As others have said, be more creative with your choice.
Your criteria seem to be -
overtaking power
space for 4
reasonable boot
£15k
What about this?
http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/1537950.htm
Your criteria seem to be -
overtaking power
space for 4
reasonable boot
£15k
What about this?
http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/1537950.htm
300bhp/ton said:
2. But on the other hand it'll depreciate like a French man living next door to a brothel. And if I was 22 and had £15k to spank on a motorcar, a sodding Astra would be just about the last thing I'd ever, ever think of looking at.
This (dodgy metaphor aside
).You could get a half decent Boxster for that...
Gassing Station | General Gassing [Archive] | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



