Silly question - Engine Reinforcement ?
Silly question - Engine Reinforcement ?
Author
Discussion

steve singh

Original Poster:

3,995 posts

204 months

Friday 12th March 2010
quotequote all
No doubt a silly question but I'll ask anyway (gulp!)...

Take two cars - say a Golf GTI and a standard Golf. Would the GTI be engineered in a way that recognises that it will be most likely driven towards the top end of the rev range? Would the engine be reinforced in a way to cater for this over and above the standard golf?

Reason I ask: My mate has a 325 which I noticed at lunchtime he takes to the red line quite often when accelerating and whilst I do this in my performance cars without thinking twice about it (once up to temp, safe to do etc etc), I was wondering whether he was risking damaging his engine ?

I guess my underlying thought process is, yes the car will let you rev up to the top end of its rev range but it wasn't really built to cater for this - which would not be the case for a performance car?

Hope that makes sense - please don't be too harsh on my lack of mechanical understanding !

mmm-five

12,403 posts

315 months

Friday 12th March 2010
quotequote all
You'll probably find the non-sports car will have a lower rev limit to take into account the lower specification of materials/tolerances.

Compare the rev limit in a 5L BMW e60 550 and a 5L BMW e60 M5.

OllieC

3,816 posts

245 months

Friday 12th March 2010
quotequote all
I would have thought that the vast majority of modern engines would have no problems in being regularly taken to the red line, assuming everything is up to temperature and that the unit is regularly serviced with the correct oils etc

I would think there is a large safety margin built into any mass produced engine regarding rev limits, as long as it is treated correctly in use.

Herman Toothrot

6,702 posts

229 months

Friday 12th March 2010
quotequote all
It its not in the red then its fine, its in the black as such.

Some cars are happy to go much higher as stock, the 1994 - 1998 toyota 3sge engine in Japan for example is regularly chipped to take the revlimit to 8100rpm from 7250rpm.

300bhp/ton

41,030 posts

221 months

Friday 12th March 2010
quotequote all
When did the Golf GTI no become not a standard Golf.... confused

dylan0451

1,040 posts

222 months

Friday 12th March 2010
quotequote all
is the 325 not a performance engine? the late ones were only slightly undersquare, 11 or 12:1 CR direct injection etc.

infact the e30s were oversquare and 10:1 ish?!

sure taking a car to the redline all the time will wear it out faster than driving like miss daisy, but thats why manufacturers sell cars with their engines slightly detuned for longevity so as treatment of the engine can be rougher

larger concerns would be how well the cooling and lubrication systems last over time - vibration damage to oil pump, corrosion/leaking water pumps etc.

MarJay

2,181 posts

206 months

Friday 12th March 2010
quotequote all
Car manufacturers test their cars by bouncing them off of the limiter for a long period of time (24hrs in the case of some jap manufacturers) so I don't think the odd bit of redline action is going to do any harm

The car makes peak power at about 5,500 rpm anyway so if you aren't thrashing it you aren't making full use of the engine.

Engines don't need structural reinforcement to handle revs, they need things like stronger valve springs to push away valve flutter and to prevent piston/valve contact... but if the car is revving fine to that RPM and the engine hasn't blown already it isn't suddenly going to change its mind unless something disastrous happens (like oil starvation).

Petrol engines are generally designed to be thrashed, and the M50 engine in my 325i is pretty rev happy. I like to oblige it. What helps is that I've ridden motorcycles for 11 years and 6000rpm is nothing when you've ridden a Yamaha R6 at 15,000 rpm, or even a CBR250 at 18,000 rpm!!

If you DON't thrash the car occasionally you're more likely to get carbon buildup on the valves and in the exhaust, hence why an 'italian tune-up' is sometimes advocated for cars that have been grannied.

I also slightly resent the implication that somehow a Golf GTI is more 'performance orientated' than a 325i. At the end of the day the Golf is a FWD hatch shopping cart with a bit of go. The beemer is a RWD straight 6 wearing a metaphorical saville row suit.

If you don't thrash your car, why not buy one that makes less power? You aren't using it anyway so why do you need it? wink

bazking69

8,620 posts

221 months

Friday 12th March 2010
quotequote all
You'd be amazed how robust a modern engine actually is.

I've seen a BMW 325i given 100k plus of savage abuse and it didn't suffer one single mechanical failure.

Ultimately it will shorten the life, but it is not a life you can definatively quantity anyway as there are more important factors than how hard it is run like quality of the oil, regular servicing etc.

Marquis_Rex

7,377 posts

270 months

Friday 12th March 2010
quotequote all
dylan0451 said:
is the 325 not a performance engine? the late ones were only slightly undersquare, 11 or 12:1 CR direct injection etc.

infact the e30s were oversquare and 10:1 ish?!

sure taking a car to the redline all the time will wear it out faster than driving like miss daisy, but thats why manufacturers sell cars with their engines slightly detuned for longevity so as treatment of the engine can be rougher

larger concerns would be how well the cooling and lubrication systems last over time - vibration damage to oil pump, corrosion/leaking water pumps etc.
Take the under square/over square arguments with a pinch of salt these days: The S54 M3 engine is very under square with a whopping 89.6 mm stroke and yet revs to 8000 rpm plus.

GavinPearson

5,715 posts

282 months

Saturday 13th March 2010
quotequote all
steve singh said:
No doubt a silly question but I'll ask anyway (gulp!)...

Take two cars - say a Golf GTI and a standard Golf. Would the GTI be engineered in a way that recognises that it will be most likely driven towards the top end of the rev range? Would the engine be reinforced in a way to cater for this over and above the standard golf?
The vehicles will most likely be run on a driving cycle that refects the target demographic, if the base parts require uprating then the changes would be made. But against that manufacturing plants hate derivitisation so most likely all the engines would get the same parts, whether they need it or not.

steve singh said:
Reason I ask: My mate has a 325 which I noticed at lunchtime he takes to the red line quite often when accelerating and whilst I do this in my performance cars without thinking twice about it (once up to temp, safe to do etc etc), I was wondering whether he was risking damaging his engine ?
Yes, he is, but the level of wear he is inducing may not be concerning. If he shortens the life of the engine from 150,000 miles to 100,000 miles then would many people notice? Possibly not, they might explain it away as being down to a variety of reasons. And is the engine life of 100,000 miles acceptable to many people? Maybe.

steve singh said:
I guess my underlying thought process is, yes the car will let you rev up to the top end of its rev range but it wasn't really built to cater for this - which would not be the case for a performance car?
It's the same for any car, not just a performance one. The assumption that you make with a performance car is that it still uses the same roads as everybody else, even if those are in Germany. Ultimately very few people will use all the performance all of the time.

steve singh said:
Hope that makes sense - please don't be too harsh on my lack of mechanical understanding !
I am sure my view may be contentious to some but reality of engineering is you make an engine do it's job to fulfil the needs of a customer - any more than that is non-added value.

Scuffers

20,887 posts

305 months

Saturday 13th March 2010
quotequote all
Marquis_Rex said:
Take the under square/over square arguments with a pinch of salt these days: The S54 M3 engine is very under square with a whopping 89.6 mm stroke and yet revs to 8000 rpm plus.
S2000 engine is (was) 90.1mm stroke, 9K rev limit...

as said, it's all relative, pistons have move on a long way these days....

ZeeTacoe

5,444 posts

253 months

Sunday 14th March 2010
quotequote all
Scuffers said:
Marquis_Rex said:
Take the under square/over square arguments with a pinch of salt these days: The S54 M3 engine is very under square with a whopping 89.6 mm stroke and yet revs to 8000 rpm plus.
S2000 engine is (was) 90.1mm stroke, 9K rev limit...

as said, it's all relative, pistons have move on a long way these days....
er wiki and honda reckon it was 87mm bore with a 84mm stroke which makes it slightly over square

The Black Flash

13,735 posts

229 months

Sunday 14th March 2010
quotequote all
MarJay said:
Car manufacturers test their cars by bouncing them off of the limiter for a long period of time (24hrs in the case of some jap manufacturers) so I don't think the odd bit of redline action is going to do any harm
240 hours (i.e. 10 days) at max rpm so a JLR type tells me.
I stopped worrying after I heard that.

Daston

6,154 posts

234 months

Sunday 14th March 2010
quotequote all
Used to bounce my supra off the rev limitor quite often (when at drag strips and things)

Never missed a beat.

steve singh

Original Poster:

3,995 posts

204 months

Monday 15th March 2010
quotequote all
Thanks for the responses guys - so sounds like it's reasonable to push the car hard without short/medium term fatel consequences to the engine.


anonymous-user

85 months

Monday 15th March 2010
quotequote all
For a genuine example of engine reinforcement the Corvette LS engine is a good place to look. The aluminium block (half the weight of its cast-iron predecessor) has deep skirts extending approximately 40 mm beneath the crankshaft centerline. This "deep-skirt" design adds strength to the block. The lower skirt makes the flat oil pan quite shallow. It is made from cast aluminum and does double duty as an engine structural member.

Generally speaking revs don't hurt an engine. It's happier to rev than it is to lug, and it's lugging which causes most wear. For this reason the engines in automatic transmission cars tend to last longer than in a manual. The auto box always changes down to make life easier for the engine where the driver of a manual might not bother.

dugt

1,657 posts

238 months

Monday 15th March 2010
quotequote all
The rev limiter is there for a reason, If VW/BMW/Whoever thought it would be bad at that rpm, the limiter would be lower.