Main Dealer Service History Scam
Discussion
Yet another scam with used cars it seems, you can now buy fully stamped up main dealer service histories from eBay, complete with a choice of dealer stamp and mileage. The sellers pretend that these are replacement for lost or stolen histories, but seems clear to me what they really get used for.
Couple of examples (from the same person) http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&am... and http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&am...
Anyone been caught out by this? I should imagine its quite easy to buy a car with supposdely full main dealer service history, when its actually faked. Of course this is fraud as the history has an impact on a cars value and whether or not you buy it.
PS - Hope this isn't a repeat of any other recent threads, but its the first I've come accross of this on eBay
Couple of examples (from the same person) http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&am... and http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&am...
ebay seller said:
RENAULT SERVICE HISTORY
SUITABLE FOR: ANY MODEL
-A SERVICE BOOK STAMPED WITH HOWEVER MANY STAMPS YOU NEED
choice of 2 stamps, Stourbridge or Hemel Hempstead
As usual the good people of eBay are not prepared to take any action as they don't see whats wrong with such listings...SUITABLE FOR: ANY MODEL
-A SERVICE BOOK STAMPED WITH HOWEVER MANY STAMPS YOU NEED
choice of 2 stamps, Stourbridge or Hemel Hempstead
Anyone been caught out by this? I should imagine its quite easy to buy a car with supposdely full main dealer service history, when its actually faked. Of course this is fraud as the history has an impact on a cars value and whether or not you buy it.
PS - Hope this isn't a repeat of any other recent threads, but its the first I've come accross of this on eBay
Mojooo said:
It would be fraud if you could prove he knew what he was selling them for -i.e their final use.
It would be tough as he does give a seemingly valid reason as to why you might want one.
The point I was trying to make is the fact these are so easily and openly available is inviting people to commit fraud. It would be tough as he does give a seemingly valid reason as to why you might want one.
I don't understand how the sellers get access to the blank books and main dealer stamps, usually if you lose your service book you can't just go to a dealer and ask them to stamp up a new one for you without giving any proof or whatever.
Edited by V on Saturday 13th March 20:27
Its not the selling of the books or the stamps thats illegal its using them to convince a buyer a car has a full history when it doesnt
This scam has been going on for years, one of the members of this site was caught and prosecuted in 2003 for advertising and selling cars as having FSH, yet the service book had been stamped with a stamp knicked from his fathers GP surgery!
This scam has been going on for years, one of the members of this site was caught and prosecuted in 2003 for advertising and selling cars as having FSH, yet the service book had been stamped with a stamp knicked from his fathers GP surgery!
V said:
Mojooo said:
It would be fraud if you could prove he knew what he was selling them for -i.e their final use.
It would be tough as he does give a seemingly valid reason as to why you might want one.
The point I was trying to make is the fact these are so easily and openly available is inviting people to commit fraud. It would be tough as he does give a seemingly valid reason as to why you might want one.
I don't understand how the sellers get access to the blank books and main dealer stamps, usually if you lose your service book you can't just go to a dealer and ask them to stamp up a new one for you without giving any proof or whatever.
Edited by V on Saturday 13th IMarch 20:27
This was on Broken Britain or whatever it was with Dom Littlewood a few days ago. The outcome was just to ring the garage and confirm whether the work's been carried out. Tedious and annoying, but hey.
Although my dad's Mercedes says how many services it's had through it's life. It says "service H due in 7751 miles" on one of the VDU pages - maybe if manufacturers started logging service history in the cars themselves it might nix some discrepancies with the books?
Although my dad's Mercedes says how many services it's had through it's life. It says "service H due in 7751 miles" on one of the VDU pages - maybe if manufacturers started logging service history in the cars themselves it might nix some discrepancies with the books?
sebhaque said:
This was on Broken Britain or whatever it was with Dom Littlewood a few days ago. The outcome was just to ring the garage and confirm whether the work's been carried out. Tedious and annoying, but hey.
Problem with that approach is what if the garage closes or dosent hold the records.sebhaque said:
Although my dad's Mercedes says how many services it's had through it's life. It says "service H due in 7751 miles" on one of the VDU pages - maybe if manufacturers started logging service history in the cars themselves it might nix some discrepancies with the books?
Good point. Mercedes hold all the service info centrally, so its very easy just to email or ring up and get a print out of what services have been done. However, I'm not aware of any other manufacturers having a central service database.jamiebae said:
I bet the 2 dealerships you can chose from are now closed down so there is no way of checking the accuracy.
Anyone could do this, you just need someone who is prepared to make you a stamp up with whatever details and logos you want on it.
The Renault dealer in Stourbridge has gone...Anyone could do this, you just need someone who is prepared to make you a stamp up with whatever details and logos you want on it.
V said:
Good point. Mercedes hold all the service info centrally, so its very easy just to email or ring up and get a print out of what services have been done. However, I'm not aware of any other manufacturers having a central service database.
Mazda do it, but if the car is serviced outside the dealer network these things often don't get updated.Gassing Station | General Gassing [Archive] | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



