Recommend me a car for £2.5k
Recommend me a car for £2.5k
Author
Discussion

blindmaninchains

Original Poster:

388 posts

206 months

Saturday 13th March 2010
quotequote all
I currently have a 2001 Focus 2.0, which serves as our family car and does so very well. However, it's fuel consumption of 29mpg and the niggling feeling that for the money I could get something more PH-ish, means I'm looking to change it for something else.

Requirements:

Be more PH worthy than my current car (2001 Focus 2.0 Ghia Estate)

Average at least 35mpg

4 seats (2 small kids in the back), boot space for a small foldable pushchair

Cost no more than £2500

Currently thinking Alfa 147 1.6 or BMW 316/318.

Thanks in advance.




KierenGG

1,749 posts

205 months

Saturday 13th March 2010
quotequote all
scratchchin
Can you fit a pushchair in a 944?

Not too sure about the MPG either...

DP83

372 posts

211 months

Saturday 13th March 2010
quotequote all
blindmaninchains said:
get something more PH-ish
blindmaninchains said:
BMW 316/318
NO!

ETA - This http://pistonheads.com/sales/1525208.htm

screw the fuel economy smile



Edited by DP83 on Saturday 13th March 20:47

jamiebae

6,245 posts

242 months

Saturday 13th March 2010
quotequote all
Park the 147 idea if you do above average miles, they need a cam belt every 36k miles, which is the reason I don't have one!

You should be able to get an E46 323i for that money, which will hit your MPG target if you drive carefully. You might even manage a 328i which would be my choice.

The Focus isn't a bad car though, I'm not a massive fan but I think it's the most 'PH worthy' car in its class, especially the 2.0 smile

blindmaninchains

Original Poster:

388 posts

206 months

Saturday 13th March 2010
quotequote all
DP83 said:
blindmaninchains said:
get something more PH-ish
blindmaninchains said:
BMW 316/318
NO!
Rear wheel drive got to be worth a few points on the PH-ometer, surely?

blindmaninchains

Original Poster:

388 posts

206 months

Saturday 13th March 2010
quotequote all
jamiebae said:
Park the 147 idea if you do above average miles, they need a cam belt every 36k miles, which is the reason I don't have one!

You should be able to get an E46 323i for that money, which will hit your MPG target if you drive carefully. You might even manage a 328i which would be my choice.

The Focus isn't a bad car though, I'm not a massive fan but I think it's the most 'PH worthy' car in its class, especially the 2.0 smile
Wow, didn't know that about the 147, thanks for the info. I do maybe 15k a year.

I really like the Focus, but it's MPG is terrible. I could maybe live with it if it had a few more bhp, it just seems terribly inefficient.

Like the idea of a 6 cylinder E46, but not sure they'd be any better than the Focus on fuel.

jamiebae

6,245 posts

242 months

Saturday 13th March 2010
quotequote all
An E46 won't be any better on fuel, but it will be a nicer car than the Focus. You could get a leggy Golf 4 2.8 4motion for £2.5k but again it would struggle to do 35mpg, even ig you removed half the spark plugs and drove like a granny!

Alfa changed the cam belt intervals for the twin spark engines a while ago due to problems with tensioners failing so they're 36k or 3 years now.

DP83

372 posts

211 months

Saturday 13th March 2010
quotequote all
blindmaninchains said:
DP83 said:
blindmaninchains said:
get something more PH-ish
blindmaninchains said:
BMW 316/318
NO!
Rear wheel drive got to be worth a few points on the PH-ometer, surely?
Maybe, but can you even get the back end out with something that slow?

I'd see it as a down-grade from a 2.0 Focus

0-60's on the beemers would be around 10.5 for the 318, even slower for the 316. Focus would be around 9.0?

I'd take a 2.0 Focus over a dog slow estate agent spec beemer any day

Edited by DP83 on Saturday 13th March 21:01

Arese

21,405 posts

218 months

Saturday 13th March 2010
quotequote all
DP83 said:
blindmaninchains said:
get something more PH-ish
blindmaninchains said:
BMW 316/318
NO!

ETA - This http://pistonheads.com/sales/1525208.htm

screw the fuel economy smile



Edited by DP83 on Saturday 13th March 20:47
That looks like a cracking car.

ian_touring

585 posts

236 months

Saturday 13th March 2010
quotequote all
toyota celica 1.8 vvti, about 2001ish, mate had one, v reliable, kids loved it.
It was quick and not a money pit.

blindmaninchains

Original Poster:

388 posts

206 months

Saturday 13th March 2010
quotequote all
ian_touring said:
toyota celica 1.8 vvti, about 2001ish, mate had one, v reliable, kids loved it.
It was quick and not a money pit.
My Dad had one of these a few years ago, had a few drives in it, liked it a lot. Decent MPG, quite a big boot and back seats big enough for my needs. Definitely in the running.

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 13th March 2010
quotequote all
I have just made an pretty much identical change to what you are thinking about.
I had a 2001 1.6 focus, until a few months ago I changed it for a e46 BMW 318I. I dont regret the change in the slightest. The BMW isn't going to set the world alight in terms of performance, but in my opinion you get a lot of (what feels like) quality car for your money.
Do not get a 316i, they are very slow and underpowered for the size of car.

Edit: the fuel economy isnt great, my commute to uni is about 4 miles with quite a lot of braking / acceleration and i average about 27mpg. But on a motorway run sticking to about 80mph it will easily do 40mpg. Note though that I do have a slightly heavy foot so you may be able to get a few more mpg out of it.


Edited by anonymous-user on Saturday 13th March 22:54

sploosh

822 posts

239 months

Saturday 13th March 2010
quotequote all
A grand would sort the "issues" surely?

v8 rear wheel drive economic family car.

http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/1551264.htm

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 13th March 2010
quotequote all
DP83 said:
blindmaninchains said:
DP83 said:
blindmaninchains said:
get something more PH-ish
blindmaninchains said:
BMW 316/318
NO!
Rear wheel drive got to be worth a few points on the PH-ometer, surely?
Maybe, but can you even get the back end out with something that slow?
Yes, you dont have to be going very fast either. Not that I make a habbit of trying to drift my car.

Edited by anonymous-user on Saturday 13th March 22:57

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 13th March 2010
quotequote all
sploosh said:
A grand would sort the "issues" surely?

v8 rear wheel drive economic family car.

http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/1551264.htm
He must be on Crack Cocaine.

No Tax. No MOT and a Knackered Automatic Gearbox all for only £1,550. Bargain...

540I Tourings with the super rare (Less than 60 built in RHD) 6 speed manual gearbox struggle to make that sort of money unless they are absoultely mint. That bloke needs to be brought back into reality where his car is only worth what a 530i Owner will give him for the lump and what the scrap man will give for the rest.

Edited by Simps on Saturday 13th March 23:04

sploosh

822 posts

239 months

Saturday 13th March 2010
quotequote all
Simps said:
sploosh said:
A grand would sort the "issues" surely?

v8 rear wheel drive economic family car.

http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/1551264.htm
He must be on Crack Cocaine.

No Tax. No MOT and a Knackered Automatic Gearbox all for only £1,550. Bargain...

540I Tourings with the super rare (Less than 60 built in RHD) 6 speed manual gearbox struggle to make that sort of money unless they are absoultely mint. That bloke needs to be brought back into reality where his car is only worth what a 530i Owner will give him for the lump and what the scrap man will give for the rest.

Edited by Simps on Saturday 13th March 23:04
oops..... getmecoat

LPG route worth looking at if you're after something with a bit more poke without the fuel bills.

nottyash

4,671 posts

226 months

Sunday 14th March 2010
quotequote all
blindmaninchains said:
ian_touring said:
toyota celica 1.8 vvti, about 2001ish, mate had one, v reliable, kids loved it.
It was quick and not a money pit.
My Dad had one of these a few years ago, had a few drives in it, liked it a lot. Decent MPG, quite a big boot and back seats big enough for my needs. Definitely in the running.
Ive just bought a blue one, but paid £3k for it. Really nice to drive, I average 38mpg as ive only used it on motorways. That was on a 540 mile round trip, Not sure around town as not done town driving in it.
Wheels get tatty as the paint chips/ peels off, I had mine shot blasted and powder coated, and it never had a spoiler on. It has now though, and looks real good.
IMO its not that quick with only 140BHP, but handling is light and precise. My insurance is only about £200 fully comp.
Its worth paying a little more for one with the leather/ digital climate and moon roof option. They are around your budget with over 100k miles, and seem to have kept their value well the last few years.smile

EDLT

15,421 posts

237 months

Sunday 14th March 2010
quotequote all
Skoda Octavia VRS?

Mr Dave

3,233 posts

226 months

Sunday 14th March 2010
quotequote all
champ54321 said:
I have just made an pretty much identical change to what you are thinking about.
I had a 2001 1.6 focus, until a few months ago I changed it for a e46 BMW 318I. I dont regret the change in the slightest. The BMW isn't going to set the world alight in terms of performance, but in my opinion you get a lot of (what feels like) quality car for your money.
Do not get a 316i, they are very slow and underpowered for the size of car.

Edit: the fuel economy isnt great, my commute to uni is about 4 miles with quite a lot of braking / acceleration and i average about 27mpg. But on a motorway run sticking to about 80mph it will easily do 40mpg. Note though that I do have a slightly heavy foot so you may be able to get a few more mpg out of it.


Edited by champ54321 on Saturday 13th March 22:54
That is shocking, in traffic my 525i gets an average of 25-27 mpg. On the motorway I averaged 42mpg to Swansea along the M4. At "legal" speeds. Also the E39 is in my opinion better put together than the E46. 2.5k will buy you a 525tds which will get great MPG or a 523/525/528 which all get similar mpg to my one.

E39s also drive very well, very comfy, very reliable, not bad on parts etc but do eat bushes like any heavy car. Tourings are massive. Electric heated seats, steering wheel controls, dual aircon, window blinds, cd multichanger , electric sunroof etc all make it a nice place to be.

Where I would sink my 2.5k.

No LSD for the 6 cylinder cars is their biggest let down to be honest.

blindmaninchains

Original Poster:

388 posts

206 months

Sunday 14th March 2010
quotequote all
nottyash said:
blindmaninchains said:
ian_touring said:
toyota celica 1.8 vvti, about 2001ish, mate had one, v reliable, kids loved it.
It was quick and not a money pit.
My Dad had one of these a few years ago, had a few drives in it, liked it a lot. Decent MPG, quite a big boot and back seats big enough for my needs. Definitely in the running.
Wheels get tatty as the paint chips/ peels off, I had mine shot blasted and powder coated, and it never had a spoiler on. It has now though, and looks real good.
Yeah, Toyota replaced my Dad's wheels under warranty - it's a problem they know about.