Decent replacement for a Focus ST?
Decent replacement for a Focus ST?
Author
Discussion

ben_h100

Original Poster:

1,550 posts

210 months

Sunday 14th March 2010
quotequote all
Hi all, bit of a 'what car?' thread, please bear with me smile

Basically I'm fed up of throwing money at petrol, what with the combination of poor fuel economy the ST suffers with, and the ever increasing costs of fuel.

Can anyone recommend a reliable, reasonably economical (diesel?), comfy and fairly quick car? I'm considering the Mondeo ST turbo diesel, Civic Tdci and Beemer 320d (assuming they can be remapped?). Not sure if there are any petrol warm/hot hatches about that produce 40-50 mpg. Oh and I have a budget of around 10k smile

As for performance, I'm planning on finally putting my bike license to use smile

Any replies much appreciated..!

300bhp/ton

41,030 posts

221 months

Sunday 14th March 2010
quotequote all
how many seats do you need?

Something like an R56 MINI Cooper S should be quite economical, as would a smart Brabus Roadster. Both in budget.

duckson

1,319 posts

213 months

Sunday 14th March 2010
quotequote all
The R56 Cooper S (and even more so the later ones with the auto stop-start) are very good on fuel (only needs 95RON).
I have an 09 Cooper S (with stop-start) which does around 40mpg on a mixed 26 mile round trip to work, this is some A road, DC and through the middle of Preston during busy periods of the day (stop start alot!). I would guess on M-way trips it should easily achieve 50-60mpg providing your not doing stupid mph!
Tax on the stop-start Cooper S is £125 a year and most should have the TLC pack which is 5 years free servicing.

All in all for a 7s to 60 car and great handling its a cheap car to run!

Mines for sale as well, slight plug there....lol....but not for £10k! Still you could get an older R56 without stop-start maybe, still good on the mpg.

http://www.duckworth.myzen.co.uk/Mini/1.JPG



Edited by duckson on Sunday 14th March 18:53

spanna123

3,737 posts

207 months

Sunday 14th March 2010
quotequote all
http://pistonheads.com/sales/976673.htm

Ibiza Cupra Tdi, 160 bhp standard. The one in the advert is remapped. Should see 40-50 mpg combined even with remap I would have thought.


ben_h100

Original Poster:

1,550 posts

210 months

Sunday 14th March 2010
quotequote all
Haven't considered a mini; will have a look though. As far as overall space goes I think that would be the smallest I could go. Unfortunately the smart would be just too small.

Flanders.

6,442 posts

239 months

Sunday 14th March 2010
quotequote all
spanna123 said:
http://pistonheads.com/sales/976673.htm

Ibiza Cupra Tdi, 160 bhp standard. The one in the advert is remapped. Should see 40-50 mpg combined even with remap I would have thought.




Why can't people be botherd to clean their cars when they go to sell them.

anonymous-user

85 months

Sunday 14th March 2010
quotequote all
Have you considered the Skoda Fabia VRS?

dave_s13

14,032 posts

300 months

Sunday 14th March 2010
quotequote all
What about buying my 2005 Alfa 156 2.4JTDm Sportwagon?

175bhp 42-45mpg.

Much less than your 10k budget too.



Edited by dave_s13 on Sunday 14th March 19:10

KierenGG

1,749 posts

205 months

Sunday 14th March 2010
quotequote all
Go for the Mondeo ST Diesel!
I was sat behind one the other day and when the bloke planted his foot, boy did it move!

Wiz

2,474 posts

245 months

Sunday 14th March 2010
quotequote all
Seat leon cupra/FR tdi, saying that was looking into these and started considering an ST170 myself.

mft

1,752 posts

253 months

Sunday 14th March 2010
quotequote all
ben_h100 said:
Beemer 320d
I'm always pleasantly surprised --impressed, even-- when I drive a colleague's 320d. Comfortable yet decent enough handling to be fun, and a nice linear engine delivery which, for a diesel, is quite revvy and isn't as obviously turbo-charged as the VAG equivalents. smile

Somnophore

1,364 posts

207 months

Sunday 14th March 2010
quotequote all
Shaid GTB said:
Have you considered the Skoda Fabia VRS?
if you're looking for fast VAG disel hatches the Ibiza Cupra tdi is much faster and reportedly a better drive than the Vrs

pitbull turbo

663 posts

212 months

Sunday 14th March 2010
quotequote all
after driving a focus st last weekend and a civic type r last weekend and today i have test driven a seat leon cupra with k1 kit and a seat leon fr i would say the seat was the best drive out of all of them, the focus torque steered and wasn't nice to drive really and a nasty iterior with the st-2 interior. the civic was a very nice car inside and out and was playful and felt much better than the focus and when wound up felt much more planted and drive focsed over the st. the cupra was even better than the civic and there is serious powedr upgrades avaliable for the cuppra which the civic lacks. i must admit i didn't feel much advantage from the cupra over the fr but the main differance was the brakes which where magic in the cupra!
i ended up buy a ibiza fr as i just found out im going to be a dad the day i test drove all the cars and i now need a car the girlfriend can drive and something cheap rather than a weekend toy but i felt the leon followed by the civic where much better alround over the focus so worth a look

oobster

7,717 posts

242 months

Sunday 14th March 2010
quotequote all
How about a Focus 2.0TDCI?

Shop around for the right spec and you could get one with all the toys, 130-odd BHP standard and capable of being chipped. Mine is standard engine-wise but has heated electric leather seats, 6-speed box, cruise control etc.

Have you got rid of the Focus ST yet?

ben_h100

Original Poster:

1,550 posts

210 months

Sunday 14th March 2010
quotequote all
Cheers, I'm looking at the mini cooper s - if 40Mpg is acheivable with normal driving I am going to book a test drive. As for the r56 I'm unable to find a review - any links?

To the owner above, how much would an example like yours cost (looks good!)?

I love my Focus ST-3 but am only acheiving high 20s, even on the motorway, when an engine sounds that good it's hard not to put your foot down. The leather interior and toys make it quite luxurious as well.

DrainTheSpuds

368 posts

212 months

Sunday 14th March 2010
quotequote all
Garlick used to run an R56 Cooper S - Thread here

typer0612

624 posts

201 months

Sunday 14th March 2010
quotequote all
considered astra diesel? cdti i think they look pretty swish!

oobster

7,717 posts

242 months

Sunday 14th March 2010
quotequote all
ben_h100 said:
Cheers, I'm looking at the mini cooper s - if 40Mpg is acheivable with normal driving I am going to book a test drive. As for the r56 I'm unable to find a review - any links?

To the owner above, how much would an example like yours cost (looks good!)?

I love my Focus ST-3 but am only acheiving high 20s, even on the motorway, when an engine sounds that good it's hard not to put your foot down. The leather interior and toys make it quite luxurious as well.
Cost me £10K about 17 months ago. Was a Ford employee's car before I bought it - he chose a Ghia but specced it up to Titanium level.

What age/colour/spec of ST do you have?

ben_h100

Original Poster:

1,550 posts

210 months

Sunday 14th March 2010
quotequote all
My apologies, wasn't referring to the Focus but to the Mini owner... smile

FYI, my ST is a 59 plate with 3000 miles on the clock.

Is a 2010 spec in Perf Blue, privacy glass, vis pack, DEATC climate control, tyre deflation detection, 6cd DAB, auto lights and wipers etc. I'll give you a shout when I'm selling if you are interested. smile

duckson

1,319 posts

213 months

Sunday 14th March 2010
quotequote all
ben_h100 said:
Cheers, I'm looking at the mini cooper s - if 40Mpg is acheivable with normal driving I am going to book a test drive. As for the r56 I'm unable to find a review - any links?

To the owner above, how much would an example like yours cost (looks good!)?

I love my Focus ST-3 but am only acheiving high 20s, even on the motorway, when an engine sounds that good it's hard not to put your foot down. The leather interior and toys make it quite luxurious as well.
Mines being advertised at £16495 ono on the Mini forums, will be up on Pistonheads next week sometime.
I've also had an ST and tbh didnt like it so much, prefered the VXR Nurburgring i replaced it with.