What Car? Insurance group 3, max. £5000
What Car? Insurance group 3, max. £5000
Author
Discussion

.blue

Original Poster:

726 posts

211 months

Monday 15th March 2010
quotequote all
Hey everyone,
I'm looking for a new car but am limited by insurance group (3 or below) and value (sub-£5000).

I know the usual (Corsa, C2, Clio, Panda/Punto etc.) and in all honesty will most likely end up going for one of these, but just thought I'd get some suggestions from PHers before admitting defeat to the constraints of being a teenage male governed by car insurance companies.

The classics route has been considered and while it's a great idea on paper, I don't have the skills nor time to be working on it every now and then.

There must be something that doesn't fall into the above categories but still falls within the group/price criteria.

All ideas welcome smile

inman999

34,954 posts

204 months

Monday 15th March 2010
quotequote all
Aygo/C1/107 are all good fun to drive. Wheel at each corner, go-cart handling, decent warble from the three cylinder etc etc.

paoloh

8,617 posts

235 months

Monday 15th March 2010
quotequote all
Aygo would get my vote.

You won't get an IQ for £5k

300bhp/ton

41,030 posts

221 months

Monday 15th March 2010
quotequote all
why group 3?

Insurance groups don't really mean much, and I seriously doubt anyone who says they are limited to 'x' group, especially one so low.

.blue

Original Poster:

726 posts

211 months

Monday 15th March 2010
quotequote all
Hmm, I'd never really thought about the Aygo (tend to block out tall cars)... just looking into it now and they come with the VVT-i engine... are they really effective on a 1l engine and how do they compare to Honda's (i)VTEC?

Found a bit about that here (http://www.billzilla.org/vvtvtec.htm) for anyone else who might be interested.

@300bhp/ton - those are the limitations imposed by insurer if i want to stay on current policy. not staying on current policy = bye bye 1st year of NCB.

Edited by .blue on Monday 15th March 10:41

300bhp/ton

41,030 posts

221 months

Monday 15th March 2010
quotequote all
.blue said:
@300bhp/ton - those are the limitations imposed by insurer if i want to stay on current policy. not staying on current policy = bye bye 1st year of NCB.

Edited by .blue on Monday 15th March 10:41
Doesn't make sense to me, if you've accrued NCB, then you can apply it with another insurer.

I say look around and insure with someone else, there's no shortage of insurance companies.

Also remember "renewal" prices are ALWAYS higher than new business. Even if you want to stick with the same company, get a quote as a new customer, it'll be cheaper than the renewal notice they'll have sent you.

smile

300bhp/ton

41,030 posts

221 months

Monday 15th March 2010
quotequote all
brickwall said:
300bhp/ton said:
.blue said:
@300bhp/ton - those are the limitations imposed by insurer if i want to stay on current policy. not staying on current policy = bye bye 1st year of NCB.

Edited by .blue on Monday 15th March 10:41
Doesn't make sense to me, if you've accrued NCB, then you can apply it with another insurer.

I say look around and insure with someone else, there's no shortage of insurance companies.

Also remember "renewal" prices are ALWAYS higher than new business. Even if you want to stick with the same company, get a quote as a new customer, it'll be cheaper than the renewal notice they'll have sent you.

smile
Is it an 'NCB' accrued as a named driver on another policy with that insurer? In which case you can't transfer it.
Even if it is, you've still got to get your own insurance at some point.

GreatGranny

9,519 posts

257 months

Monday 15th March 2010
quotequote all

.blue

Original Poster:

726 posts

211 months

Monday 15th March 2010
quotequote all
300bhp/ton said:
brickwall said:
300bhp/ton said:
.blue said:
@300bhp/ton - those are the limitations imposed by insurer if i want to stay on current policy. not staying on current policy = bye bye 1st year of NCB.

Edited by .blue on Monday 15th March 10:41
Doesn't make sense to me, if you've accrued NCB, then you can apply it with another insurer.

I say look around and insure with someone else, there's no shortage of insurance companies.

Also remember "renewal" prices are ALWAYS higher than new business. Even if you want to stick with the same company, get a quote as a new customer, it'll be cheaper than the renewal notice they'll have sent you.

smile
Is it an 'NCB' accrued as a named driver on another policy with that insurer? In which case you can't transfer it.
Even if it is, you've still got to get your own insurance at some point.
It is my own - I haven't fully accrued 1 year NCB yet, but it's what I will get if I stay on the same policy until the end of the contract term in a few months. If I change to a different policy I will have to wait another 12 months (from now) to get my 1yr NCB.

I'm also looking at the Almera 5-7 yrs old 1.5l - views/opinions?

GreatGranny

9,519 posts

257 months

Tuesday 16th March 2010
quotequote all
.blue said:
300bhp/ton said:
brickwall said:
300bhp/ton said:
.blue said:
@300bhp/ton - those are the limitations imposed by insurer if i want to stay on current policy. not staying on current policy = bye bye 1st year of NCB.

Edited by .blue on Monday 15th March 10:41
Doesn't make sense to me, if you've accrued NCB, then you can apply it with another insurer.

I say look around and insure with someone else, there's no shortage of insurance companies.

Also remember "renewal" prices are ALWAYS higher than new business. Even if you want to stick with the same company, get a quote as a new customer, it'll be cheaper than the renewal notice they'll have sent you.

smile
Is it an 'NCB' accrued as a named driver on another policy with that insurer? In which case you can't transfer it.
Even if it is, you've still got to get your own insurance at some point.
It is my own - I haven't fully accrued 1 year NCB yet, but it's what I will get if I stay on the same policy until the end of the contract term in a few months. If I change to a different policy I will have to wait another 12 months (from now) to get my 1yr NCB.

I'm also looking at the Almera 5-7 yrs old 1.5l - views/opinions?
A bit uninspiring but also underrated.

Typical Nissan interior, very black!

Colleague had one, nothing went wrong for 3 years then loads of things went wrong and he got shut.

You could get a 3/4 year old one for your budget though.

JB!

5,255 posts

211 months

Tuesday 16th March 2010
quotequote all
if you can live with the build quality, siecento sportings are a proper giggle!

v1paul

723 posts

207 months

Tuesday 16th March 2010
quotequote all
Mitsubishi colt? A bit too bland maybe?

.blue

Original Poster:

726 posts

211 months

Tuesday 16th March 2010
quotequote all
Quick update - insurer said no to entry level Toyota Corolla 1.4 VVT-i worth around £3k. Same story with (used) entry level Mazda 3. Both these are according to several guides, group 3.

Then saw this interesting looking car. It...umm, it was a *whisper* Proton Satria Neo...
Got a quote - success! I'd still be paying half the car price in insurance but it's something they're willing to insure! cool

Turns out it's Group 6 insurance...

I don't think I've seen (m)any on the roads which automatically makes it a cool car, merits test driving.

Also considering a Swift (will try my luck with the 1.5 but probably end up settling for the 1.3) and the Almera's still on the cards smile

Oh and even though I'm not a huge fan, given the number of people rooting for the Aygo, I'll have to check that out to see what all the fuss is about!

@JB - Ideally looking for something bigger than that, should be able to lug stuff to/from uni! Any ideas how the handling/funness compares to the Swift?
@Paul - Having seen a friend's Colt, Im not a big fan! Keep the suggestions coming though smile

Edited by .blue on Tuesday 16th March 15:20

JB!

5,255 posts

211 months

Tuesday 16th March 2010
quotequote all
.blue said:
Quick update - insurer said no to entry level Toyota Corolla 1.4 VVT-i worth around £3k. Same story with (used) entry level Mazda 3. Both these are according to several guides, group 3.

Then saw this interesting looking car. It...umm, it was a *whisper* Proton Satria Neo...
Got a quote - success! I'd still be paying half the car price in insurance but it's something they're willing to insure! cool

Turns out it's Group 6 insurance...

I don't think I've seen (m)any on the roads which automatically makes it a cool car, merits test driving.

Also considering a Swift (will try my luck with the 1.5 but probably end up settling for the 1.3) and the Almera's still on the cards smile

Oh and even though I'm not a huge fan, given the number of people rooting for the Aygo, I'll have to check that out to see what all the fuss is about!

@JB - Ideally looking for something bigger than that, should be able to lug stuff to/from uni! Any ideas how the handling/funness compares to the Swift?
@Paul - Having seen a friend's Colt, Im not a big fan! Keep the suggestions coming though smile

Edited by .blue on Tuesday 16th March 15:20
very chuckable with decent tyres on, the new swift 1.3 is also very good, especially some of the "sporty" special eds.

test drive a good used siecento sporting, swift 1.3 and a proton ad decide which you like, altho i'll wager on the swift coming tops.

tim2100

6,288 posts

288 months

Tuesday 16th March 2010
quotequote all
.blue said:
Quick update - insurer said no to entry level Toyota Corolla 1.4 VVT-i worth around £3k. Same story with (used) entry level Mazda 3. Both these are according to several guides, group 3.

Then saw this interesting looking car. It...umm, it was a *whisper* Proton Satria Neo...
Got a quote - success! I'd still be paying half the car price in insurance but it's something they're willing to insure! cool

Turns out it's Group 6 insurance...

I don't think I've seen (m)any on the roads which automatically makes it a cool car, merits test driving.

Also considering a Swift (will try my luck with the 1.5 but probably end up settling for the 1.3) and the Almera's still on the cards smile

Oh and even though I'm not a huge fan, given the number of people rooting for the Aygo, I'll have to check that out to see what all the fuss is about!

@JB - Ideally looking for something bigger than that, should be able to lug stuff to/from uni! Any ideas how the handling/funness compares to the Swift?
@Paul - Having seen a friend's Colt, Im not a big fan! Keep the suggestions coming though smile

Edited by .blue on Tuesday 16th March 15:20
Why not wait until the end of the 1st year. get your NCB and then go to another insurance company who are not so anal?

tomwoodis

570 posts

215 months

Tuesday 16th March 2010
quotequote all
Don't overlook the Skoda fabia, will be towards the top end of your budget but there are a few models that re within insurance group 3 - good cars too.

In fact according to Parkers, the 1.2 is in insurance group 1!!

alfabadass

1,852 posts

230 months

Tuesday 16th March 2010
quotequote all
Grande Punto.

Looks the best and most stylish out of that lot.

Jayho

2,441 posts

201 months

Tuesday 16th March 2010
quotequote all
Could try the suzuki alto, they're alright, or the suzuki ignis, maybe not the 1.5 though... They're really fun great handling cars to put round corners, not too expensive so what you've got left you could save for your next car... really light so always feels faster than you're actually going.

renault twingo? they seem fun.

Older micra's?? dont be put off, they're fun round bends same with your for ka's ect...

dpbird90

5,535 posts

221 months

Tuesday 16th March 2010
quotequote all
The Suzuki Swift may be a great car, but it'll never get my vote seeing as one totally demolished the front of my poor old Seicento last year. Therefore I will always hate the Swift. The Seicento has been suggested, can be had for a hell of a lot less than your budget, is insurance group 3, and is a right hoot (hand on heart, I had more fun driving mine on the twisty B roads from Bruntingthorpe than I did while I was there in a Ferrari 360) just so long as you go for the Sporting version. The grandma special with its 0.9l engine accelerates from 0-60 slower than I do. Another point about the Seicento, if you crash it above 20mph, say goodbye to your legs. And arms, and penis. 1* according to NCAP. But otherwise a right laugh. Or just buy a Panda, I had a few people laugh at me at college when I turned up in one, but compared to some of their steboxes it was fantastic. In fact, having been in my best mate's Fiat 500, although its a great car I prefer the Panda. You can get more in the boot, its easier to get in the back (when you're a young lad thats very important!) despite the 1.2 engine its relatively quick, feels solid as a rock (unlike most Fiats I've driven) and is so cheap to insure (group 2); I'm 20 now and my renewal quote for fully comp is £350. Its the only logical choice.

.blue

Original Poster:

726 posts

211 months

Tuesday 16th March 2010
quotequote all
Jayho said:
Older micra's?? dont be put off, they're fun round bends same with your for ka's ect...
Even the 1 litre ones? biggrin