Engine blows up 2 days after HG replacement. What to do?
Engine blows up 2 days after HG replacement. What to do?
Author
Discussion

Kozy

Original Poster:

3,169 posts

249 months

Monday 15th March 2010
quotequote all
Just been speaking to my brother about his car, he took his Escort into a local garage (a fairly well regarded one, used by family for a number of years) about a month ago to diagnose white smoke from the exhaust and an oil leak, and they said the HG needed replacing. They quoted £350 to do the job and he accepted.

Three weeks later after numerous excuses he got the car back, and tried to charge him more because it took so long but backed down after an argument at the front desk and accepted the original quote of £350. They said the piston rings needed replacing, but should they not have called and notified him of this while they were working to see how he wanted to proceed? It seems irresponsible of the garage to bolt the engine back together knowing that there was a fault requiring another strip down. Instead they skirted around the problem for three weeks and eventually gave it back in such a condition that the engine has now blown.

Two days after he got it back the car developed a knocking sound, the oil light came on, it lost power and evetually ground to a halt, and will now not run for more than minute or so. The garage in question accept no responsibility for this, but somewhow taking a perfectly running but slightly smoking car in for a HG and getting it back to have it blow up two days later does not seem right. There could be a problem in the fact that my brother, not beeing mechanically minded, drove the car with the oil light on for about 8 miles, which has obviously caused more damage, but this is clearly as a result of whatever the garage have done in that three weeks.

All in with loss of value on the car (he has someone offering £200 for it as is), and having to buy a new one he's nearly £1000 down. How should we approach this, they've effectively written off the car but are denying any responsibility, which may be hard to prove. Do we stand any chance of getting a refund for the work they carried out? Do we need to get trading standards involved?

All in with loss of value on the car, and having to buy a new one he's nearly £1000 down.

TASS

39,731 posts

315 months

Monday 15th March 2010
quotequote all
As with anything, if you have enough money you can fight it. Speak to Trading Standards, they will say you need an independant engineers report first.