Something fun for £1500 ??
Something fun for £1500 ??
Author
Discussion

seismic22

Original Poster:

662 posts

200 months

Tuesday 16th March 2010
quotequote all
Hi there,

Currently drive a 2002 406 hdi. I drive this because im in my final year of uni, really skint and it does excellent mpg only had 43,000 miles on it and has proved very reliable and it was mega mega mega cheap and i expect to make a reasonable profit on it.
The car i had prior to the 406 was a Mk3 golf gti 16v. Pickced it up for £800 quid with 97,000 on it and everysingle old mot etc etc. Yes it liked to roll quite a bit but, drive it hard and it went like stink and when i wanted to cruise about up the motorway it was comfortable easy etc. I bought it because it was what i could afford and proved very reliable over 12,000 miles. I had to sell it because i couldnt cope with the average 27mpg i was getting (have a lead foot).

Crux of the matter: Im finishing uni at end of may and the petrol in my veins is calling out for something fun.
Finishing uni and having a bit more money im going to be in a better position to handle lower mpg and work on a car when it does go wrong. This however does not mean i want anything unreliable or barely gets near 30mpg.

Got a budget of £1500 ish +/- . I know whatever i get will be older, may need some work, wont do great mpg and wont be a rocket ship but you dont need to have 200 odd bhp to have fun, and the last time i went in my mates leon cupra r, it felt pretty dull compared to thrashing the nuts of my old squishy 16V!

Heres a very long list of cars i am pondering over and would be really grateful of any opinions. My criteria : must be able to afford something aroound or below the 100,000 miles mark that has history, must be quick, return 30mpg plus if i drive granny like. Not bothered too much about looks as i want to have fun not pose! Am happy to hunt for a while to get something in my price range. Cheers

Seat leon cupra (with a bit of hunting possible)
Citroen xsara vts (electrical probs?, 167bhp, subtle, handles well, seems very underated)
Primera GT (bombproof, handle better than alot of hot hatches, very subtle)
Nissan almera gti (reliable, handling, not following the crowd, mpg)
Golf gti 16, again, (reliable, parts cheap, good forum following, nice revy reliable engine)
Golf 16v mk2 (bit out my price for a tidy one?, proper hot hatch fun!)
Golf 8v mk2 (whatever people say the 8v is slower than 16v but mpg better, more affordable? still lotsa fun)
Scirroco gtx 8v (hard to find a 8v injection one,)
Astra 2.2 (Cheap parts, subtle, quick, handle relatively well, reasonable mpg)
Alfa 145 cloverleaf (beautiful engine, really different, lots of fun, reliability issue, poor mpg)
Alfa 156 2.0 (looks, engine, cheap, reliability issues? mpg?)
205 1.9 gti (hard pushed to find decent one in my budget, bit tiring on the motorway?, reliability?)
Ibiza gti 16v (a more modern mk2 golf 16v?? reliable, on budget, handles well, bit chavy?)
BMW e36 coupe 323i ( hard to find a standard one, meant to handle well and quite easily achieve 30's mpg, looks nice, reliability good, straight six!!)
Civic 1.8 vti 5 door (quick, revy, very understated esp aerodeck, drinks fuel, soft ride?)
Gen 6 Celica 2.0 GT (i like the looks, plenty hp, odd gear ratios?, not quite as sporting as should be, RELIABILITY)
Nissan 200sx (would love one but think the mpg is just a little too low)

My opinions on the cars come from years of reading evo magazine, car magazine, autocar, pistonheads, honest john and many other websites,more than i have been reading for my college, uni degree etc etc etc

I know its a comprimise, im asking alot, etc etc etc. People might say shouldnt think about mpg if your into performance etc etc. Well its all i can afford and i cant put up with a go slow diesel anymore! Cheers for any help and sorry for the mega long first post!

TEKNOPUG

20,502 posts

236 months

Tuesday 16th March 2010
quotequote all
M...

sniff diesel

13,128 posts

243 months

Tuesday 16th March 2010
quotequote all
328i sport

CaptainSlow

13,179 posts

243 months

Tuesday 16th March 2010
quotequote all
TEKNOPUG said:
M...
X

seismic22

Original Poster:

662 posts

200 months

Tuesday 16th March 2010
quotequote all
forgot the mx5 and mr2 but rekn they will be pushing the price range a little for something decent.

TEKNOPUG

20,502 posts

236 months

Tuesday 16th March 2010
quotequote all
I was actually suggesting an Opel Manta...

CaptainSlow

13,179 posts

243 months

Tuesday 16th March 2010
quotequote all
I meant the MX-6

tomwoodis

570 posts

215 months

Tuesday 16th March 2010
quotequote all
Would you consider any of these?

Mx5 - someone will say it if I don't and for good reason, it will be great fun to own

106 gti/ Saxo VTS - should still be able to get one for around £1500 that hasn't passed the 100,000 mile mark (actually you definately want it to have less miles than that I would suspect. probably nearing the end of its useful life by then)

MK2 Mr2 2.0na version?

RobM77

35,349 posts

265 months

Tuesday 16th March 2010
quotequote all
106Gti is worth a look if you can find a straight unmolested one for that money. It's one of the best handling front wheel drive hatchbacks ever made.

MR2 mk1s are getting on a bit now, but they really are fantastic cars. MX5s are good too, but for this money you may struggle to find a decent one (as you stated above).

Edited by RobM77 on Tuesday 16th March 15:31

JB!

5,255 posts

211 months

Tuesday 16th March 2010
quotequote all
wouldnt touch the leaon cupra in that budget.

mk2 8v is a good shout, a 16v is possible with soem hunting about.

mk2 ibiza cupra is a good idea too, mk3 golf powered 2.0 16v is the best one to get.

tomwoodis

570 posts

215 months

Tuesday 16th March 2010
quotequote all
seismic22 said:
forgot the mx5 and mr2 but rekn they will be pushing the price range a little for something decent.
Nah, I reckon you could get either of these for close to your budget if you bide your time.

Suspect the MX5 will be better in the twisties, a bit slower than the Mr2 but less likely to stick you backwards into a hedge.

Not sure what the NA mr2 is like but certainly my turbo one wanted me dead!

TEKNOPUG

20,502 posts

236 months

Tuesday 16th March 2010
quotequote all
CaptainSlow said:
I meant the MX-6
Touché wink

TEKNOPUG

20,502 posts

236 months

Tuesday 16th March 2010
quotequote all
I'd get the Xsara VTS/306 GTi-6 out of the ones suggested. Anything interesting for £1500 is going to be relatively sheddy. At least if it's 90's French it will be cheap and easy to fix.

motoroller

657 posts

204 months

Tuesday 16th March 2010
quotequote all
CaptainSlow said:
TEKNOPUG said:
M...
X
5

tomwoodis

570 posts

215 months

Tuesday 16th March 2010
quotequote all
motoroller said:
CaptainSlow said:
TEKNOPUG said:
M...
X
5
Like what you've done there smile

seismic22

Original Poster:

662 posts

200 months

Tuesday 16th March 2010
quotequote all
though i dont care that much what people think of my car etc etc ( i drive a 406 diesel) and i do quite admire the saxo vts for being cheap yet quick im not quite sure i would be totally happy driving a car normally found being driven with dustbin lid exhausts around the centre of town.

the 106 gti is out of my price range really,

the mx5 i would love and wouldnt care looking like a hair dresser but think a reasonable one is again out of range, and from what i have read early mk2 mr2s can be a bit of a handful and the N/A one a bit underpowered.

The mx-6 i know very little about other than its based on a probe/mazda 626 and people i have know who have owned have thought they were poor handling and boring. ill read up

The ibiza does sound good and yes the one with the 16v mk3 golf gti ABF engine out my old golf would be quick and reliable.

The gti-6 is out of my price really for one that hasnt been thrashed or chav'd.

The vts the gti-6's ugly cousin is an absolute bargain for the performance but the electrical gremlins do worry me, i hate modern day cars and would prefer if all modern cars were as involving and as simple as the mk2 golf gti

whats the mpg like on a 328i like then? i mentioned the 323i cos its RWD! and meant to be comparatively good on fuel.

might have to do some hunting on the mx5 front.

i havnt mentioned a mgf or tf cos i cant be arse with headgasket issues really, seems too common to be true.

300bhp/ton

41,030 posts

221 months

Tuesday 16th March 2010
quotequote all
seismic22 said:
forgot the mx5 and mr2 but rekn they will be pushing the price range a little for something decent.
Ford Puma
Mazda MX-3


But drive these right and mpg will be down to around 30mpg or lower.

tomwoodis

570 posts

215 months

Tuesday 16th March 2010
quotequote all
seismic22 said:
though i dont care that much what people think of my car etc etc ( i drive a 406 diesel) and i do quite admire the saxo vts for being cheap yet quick im not quite sure i would be totally happy driving a car normally found being driven with dustbin lid exhausts around the centre of town.

the 106 gti is out of my price range really,

the mx5 i would love and wouldnt care looking like a hair dresser but think a reasonable one is again out of range, and from what i have read early mk2 mr2s can be a bit of a handful and the N/A one a bit underpowered.

The mx-6 i know very little about other than its based on a probe/mazda 626 and people i have know who have owned have thought they were poor handling and boring. ill read up

The ibiza does sound good and yes the one with the 16v mk3 golf gti ABF engine out my old golf would be quick and reliable.

The gti-6 is out of my price really for one that hasnt been thrashed or chav'd.

The vts the gti-6's ugly cousin is an absolute bargain for the performance but the electrical gremlins do worry me, i hate modern day cars and would prefer if all modern cars were as involving and as simple as the mk2 golf gti

whats the mpg like on a 328i like then? i mentioned the 323i cos its RWD! and meant to be comparatively good on fuel.

might have to do some hunting on the mx5 front.

i havnt mentioned a mgf or tf cos i cant be arse with headgasket issues really, seems too common to be true.
try and overlook the bad image than the saxo and to a degree 106 has because as rob said early, one of the best handling cars ever. I had one many moons ago and if i'm being honest, despite being slower it was more fun to drive on todays roads than my current z4 and a lot easier to live with day to day than the mr2 I had.

Can't say I have driven the Mx5 but so many people can't be wrong so worth a look which you seem to be doing.

seismic22

Original Poster:

662 posts

200 months

Tuesday 16th March 2010
quotequote all
That last comment is very valid i think. cheers

Ford puma - have looked at these (i def would look like a girl but who cares!) couple probs, they seem to rust like hell round the rear arches and a decent one is bit tough on the price range, im still keeping an eye out though. I would absolutely love a racing puma, id sell a kidney to have one.

mx-3 i have always like them but feel their a little long in the tooth (i say this whilst talking about golf mk2's!) without and though i have not looked at parts myself have been told by a previous owner a couple years back parts were bit expensive and i expect getting hard to find now. I expect the same cpould be said for a maza 323f with the v6 in it, that was a highly praised car on release.

ill keep a look out on those too though. being able to get parts and cheaply is quite important at this price i think.



Edited by seismic22 on Tuesday 16th March 16:03

louismchuge

1,644 posts

215 months

Tuesday 16th March 2010
quotequote all
A Jag?! wink