Sorry - What Car... £3k-£5k, Room for kids, Reliable etc.
Discussion
Hello,
Apologies for posting another What Car thread but I'm just stumped as to what to get.
I'm "down-sizing" from the X5 and want to spend £3k-£5k (+- £500) on a car for the missus. Our main priority is safety for the kids, then space for them and their stuff (push-chairs etc.).
We'd like good fuel economy and reliability - so age and mileage is "important".
Then, we'd like as much comfort as possible (air-con a must) for the money.
Then - and here's the rub - we live in a fairly rural area and our X5 was invaluable during the recent inclement weather. Now, notwithstanding that this happens perhaps 2-3 weeks out of the year, 4-wheel drive would be "useful".
Any suggestions anyone?
Thanks,
Phil.
Apologies for posting another What Car thread but I'm just stumped as to what to get.
I'm "down-sizing" from the X5 and want to spend £3k-£5k (+- £500) on a car for the missus. Our main priority is safety for the kids, then space for them and their stuff (push-chairs etc.).
We'd like good fuel economy and reliability - so age and mileage is "important".
Then, we'd like as much comfort as possible (air-con a must) for the money.
Then - and here's the rub - we live in a fairly rural area and our X5 was invaluable during the recent inclement weather. Now, notwithstanding that this happens perhaps 2-3 weeks out of the year, 4-wheel drive would be "useful".
Any suggestions anyone?
Thanks,
Phil.
Landlord said:
We'd like good fuel economy and reliability - so age and mileage is "important".
Hi there.I'm not sure age and mileage will truly reflect fuel economy and reliability, although I think I know what you mean.
Do you have any idea what level of mpg you are looking at?
I'm rather a fan of these of the Subaru Legacy and Forrester, but mpg won't be great as they will be petrol only at this age.
£5k should also see you in a Disco II TD5. These are a mixed bag, but I know of lots of people who have run them without issue. The are comfy, drive well, usually well specced and should do over 30mpg.
A diesel Freelander would also be on the cards for me. Not the quickest, although a remap does make a big difference to how they drive. Try and get one with HDC and TSC.
The Jeep Cherokee is a great alternative to the Freelander and a little bit different.
Sure there are some other AWD cars, although not sure what falls in your price bracket and mpg range.
300bhp/ton said:
Landlord said:
We'd like good fuel economy and reliability - so age and mileage is "important".
Hi there.I'm not sure age and mileage will truly reflect fuel economy and reliability, although I think I know what you mean.
Do you have any idea what level of mpg you are looking at?
I'm rather a fan of these of the Subaru Legacy and Forrester, but mpg won't be great as they will be petrol only at this age.
£5k should also see you in a Disco II TD5. These are a mixed bag, but I know of lots of people who have run them without issue. The are comfy, drive well, usually well specced and should do over 30mpg.
A diesel Freelander would also be on the cards for me. Not the quickest, although a remap does make a big difference to how they drive. Try and get one with HDC and TSC.
The Jeep Cherokee is a great alternative to the Freelander and a little bit different.
Sure there are some other AWD cars, although not sure what falls in your price bracket and mpg range.
Thanks for the reply. Is the Cherokee any good WRT MPG? In terms of what we're after, to be honest, anything that doesn't cost £120 per tank and return < 18 mpg would be an improvement at the moment! I'd like, I guess, something in the 30's. Any higher, obviously, would be better.
What are the freelanders like for space, do you know?
I too like the Subaru's - not sure of their economy though, as you say.
Landlord said:
300bhp/ton said:
Landlord said:
We'd like good fuel economy and reliability - so age and mileage is "important".
Hi there.I'm not sure age and mileage will truly reflect fuel economy and reliability, although I think I know what you mean.
Do you have any idea what level of mpg you are looking at?
I'm rather a fan of these of the Subaru Legacy and Forrester, but mpg won't be great as they will be petrol only at this age.
£5k should also see you in a Disco II TD5. These are a mixed bag, but I know of lots of people who have run them without issue. The are comfy, drive well, usually well specced and should do over 30mpg.
A diesel Freelander would also be on the cards for me. Not the quickest, although a remap does make a big difference to how they drive. Try and get one with HDC and TSC.
The Jeep Cherokee is a great alternative to the Freelander and a little bit different.
Sure there are some other AWD cars, although not sure what falls in your price bracket and mpg range.
Thanks for the reply. Is the Cherokee any good WRT MPG? In terms of what we're after, to be honest, anything that doesn't cost £120 per tank and return < 18 mpg would be an improvement at the moment! I'd like, I guess, something in the 30's. Any higher, obviously, would be better.
What are the freelanders like for space, do you know?
I too like the Subaru's - not sure of their economy though, as you say.
One of these:

Your budget should get you a ~2003 model with the 2.8 CRD in (some where 2.5). The 2.8 is a really good engine, quite powerful and should see mid 30's mpg fairly easily. Most are well specced and quite a nice drive that's not so run of the mill.
auto one on autotrade, but there are manuals and others:
http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2009...
Freelander isn't bad. It's not as big inside as it looks outside though, think slightly more space than a Ford Focus, but with higher up driving position and more head room.
Both 4x4's will feel more open and airy compared to a regular car.
Subaru's are nice, but I would suspect mpg to me mid high 20's by comparison. If you look at a turbo then low 20's is quite likely.
As for reliability, well it's 6 of one and half a dozen of the other. Subaru's can break with the best of them, yet they can also be very reliable.
300bhp/ton said:
Subaru's are nice, but I would suspect mpg to me mid high 20's by comparison. If you look at a turbo then low 20's is quite likely.
I average around 26mpg from my 280bhp twin-turbo Legacy, 30+ mpg isn't hard to achieve on a longer run. NA cars are a bit more economical - best I ever got from my old 2.0NA (155bhp) Legacy was 37mpg average over a tank, which was mostly open road but 5-up and well loaded with luggage.GravelBen said:
300bhp/ton said:
Subaru's are nice, but I would suspect mpg to me mid high 20's by comparison. If you look at a turbo then low 20's is quite likely.
I average around 26mpg from my 280bhp twin-turbo Legacy, 30+ mpg isn't hard to achieve on a longer run. NA cars are a bit more economical - best I ever got from my old 2.0NA (155bhp) Legacy was 37mpg average over a tank, which was mostly open road but 5-up and well loaded with luggage.Landlord said:
How reliable are the Cherokee's? I tested one before I bought the X5 and found it "under-powered"... but then again, I did go for the 4.4V8 X5!
I'm now not so fussed about performance, though I'd like to be able to pull out of junctions without panicking!
We ran an earlier Cherokee with no bothers. They also sell HUGE numbers of them in the US, so that should say something about them, as they don't like unreliable stuff.I'm now not so fussed about performance, though I'd like to be able to pull out of junctions without panicking!
But I think a lot of it is down to perception, Jeep, like Land Rover tend not to do very well in surveys like the JD Power and similar. However I think this doesn't always reflect the truth about running such vehicles.
1. Is that in reality all new vehicles are pretty good, and in such surveys even last place is only usually a few points behind 1st, but the surveys force them in to an order with a top and a bottom.
2. Many use these vehicles to their fullest, towing, hauling and off road, so possible break stuff more easily on them compared to only driving a different car on tarmac.
3. Perception, if someone buys something that is meant to be reliable, yet still needs work, they often won't complain, because they think, "thank god we didn't get something unreliable, it'd be much worse". Even though it probably wouldn't be.
I can't guarantee one wouldn't be hassle free, but then I wouldn't claim that about any make of car.

If turbo Subarus do go wrong it can be expensive to fix (relative to the cost of the car) - however this is much more common with abused and/or badly modified cars, if kept standard and looked after they're fine IME. I've had my 2002 GTB for a year and a half with no problems whatsoever, had 3 NA Subarus before that and the biggest problem was an airflow meter failure.
Edited by GravelBen on Wednesday 17th March 09:42
Leftfield suggestion
Saab 9-5 Estate
Safe - Check Ncap 5*
Lots of Room - Check
Comfortable - Check
Aircon - Full Climate Control - Check
Economical - more so than a 4x4 - mine averaged 32mpg between services and it was an auto
Reliable - Mine was over 221k miles!
And add a set of winter Mud and Snow tyres on another set of wheels for the winter
davidy
Saab 9-5 Estate
Safe - Check Ncap 5*
Lots of Room - Check
Comfortable - Check
Aircon - Full Climate Control - Check
Economical - more so than a 4x4 - mine averaged 32mpg between services and it was an auto
Reliable - Mine was over 221k miles!
And add a set of winter Mud and Snow tyres on another set of wheels for the winter
davidy
Went through similar excercise about a year ago. Looked at Volvo v70r (all wheel drive jobby), Xc70, Audi allroad and Saab 9-5 estate. Ended up in a legacy 3 litre spec b estate, which I love. Saab apart you will get more Subaru for your money than Volvo/Audi thanks to depreciation, fuel on the 3 litre is between 23-24 for me but that's fairly urban use with short journeys, on longer trips I Can get high twenties to thirty (just) - Still not great but will deffo beat what you are coming from.
touching cloth said:
Went through similar excercise about a year ago. Looked at Volvo v70r (all wheel drive jobby), Xc70, Audi allroad and Saab 9-5 estate. Ended up in a legacy 3 litre spec b estate, which I love. Saab apart you will get more Subaru for your money than Volvo/Audi thanks to depreciation, fuel on the 3 litre is between 23-24 for me but that's fairly urban use with short journeys, on longer trips I Can get high twenties to thirty (just) - Still not great but will deffo beat what you are coming from.
Hmmm... I was all set on a Cherokee/XC70 but now...To be honest, I thought about a Spec B ages ago because it seemed to fit everything but I heard these rumours. I guess it's because they're "ripe" for modding that things go wrong.
Saab - a friend has recommended them. How much would the extra set of tyres & fitting work out to do you reckon?
Landlord said:
touching cloth said:
Went through similar excercise about a year ago. Looked at Volvo v70r (all wheel drive jobby), Xc70, Audi allroad and Saab 9-5 estate. Ended up in a legacy 3 litre spec b estate, which I love. Saab apart you will get more Subaru for your money than Volvo/Audi thanks to depreciation, fuel on the 3 litre is between 23-24 for me but that's fairly urban use with short journeys, on longer trips I Can get high twenties to thirty (just) - Still not great but will deffo beat what you are coming from.
Hmmm... I was all set on a Cherokee/XC70 but now...To be honest, I thought about a Spec B ages ago because it seemed to fit everything but I heard these rumours. I guess it's because they're "ripe" for modding that things go wrong.
Saab - a friend has recommended them. How much would the extra set of tyres & fitting work out to do you reckon?
£190 at the moment, day and a bit to go;
http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/saab-alu-wheels-16in-with-ty...
Gassing Station | General Gassing [Archive] | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



