Proton Satria Neo - Any owners?
Proton Satria Neo - Any owners?
Author
Discussion

.blue

Original Poster:

726 posts

211 months

Wednesday 17th March 2010
quotequote all
G'day folks...
Been looking at a Proton Satria Neo for my next car. 2007 model, 1.3l (can't get any bigger engine due to insurance... teenage male, tell me about it...)

Have made an offer on it! Provided that the dealer accepts, what should I look out for/check when I go?

The car is due a major service but hopefully there'll be nothing too majorly wrong with it. Condition looks good, few scuffs etc. as you would expect with a 3-4 year old car.

I'm bracing myself for some serious Proton-related banter, but if there are any current owners, I'd love to hear all about your Satria-Neo related stories wink

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 17th March 2010
quotequote all
May I ask why?

.blue

Original Poster:

726 posts

211 months

Wednesday 17th March 2010
quotequote all
Er.. where do I start? :P

Basically it was between the Swift and this.

Didn't get to take the swift to it's element (i.e. NSL proper driving roads), was more of a motorway drive. However, didn't think there was much between the two in terms of handling, though I accept it's hard to tell on motorways. However, cabin noise in the rear of Swift was horrendous. They're also more expensive by around £1,500.

I liked the Proton. Both Swift and proton have around 90bhp, though Swift feels slightly faster. However, I still enjoyed driving the Proton and think it's something I can live with.

Having read around, mechanically, Proton's seem ok. Main concern is resale value. I do plan on selling the car in 3 years or so, but in terms of absolute value, the Proton will depreciate about as much as the Swift. (Counting on resale value of £750-£1,000 for Proton after 3 years and £3000 for the Swift).

Also, the 'youf' in me has to award major respect points to that 'Handling by Lotus' badge on the back of the Proton biggrin

Edited by .blue on Wednesday 17th March 16:23

RB26DETT

2,519 posts

206 months

Wednesday 17th March 2010
quotequote all
Buy 1.4 Ford Puma also has 90BHP.

SystemParanoia

14,343 posts

229 months

Wednesday 17th March 2010
quotequote all
proton will hold its value as well as a piece of used bog roll.

go back and take the swift out onto the B roads... only taking a test drive on a motorway is not going to give you the full story TBH

take the proton out on the same B roads to if possible

Curry Burns

5,620 posts

246 months

Wednesday 17th March 2010
quotequote all
Vauxhall SXi 1.4 petrol or 1.3 CDti

Beefmeister

16,482 posts

261 months

Wednesday 17th March 2010
quotequote all
You know, i was about to post a picture of the Proton, mocking you etc



But you know what? On looks alone, it looks quite good!

BUT - the Swift is better to drive, better handling, better looking, better built, more reliable, will hold its value better, and is much much cooler.

Well worth the extra outlay IMO.

SiC2

148 posts

236 months

Wednesday 17th March 2010
quotequote all
Never driven or even looked at the Proton, however I can say that the Swift is a great little car. My brother has a 1.3 GL (base spec) It handles well, much better than my old Citroen C2. The 5 door has loads of space especially when the rear seats are folded up. (dont know if the Proton does that) and the engine is great considering it only got 90hp. I would say that I would take them both round some coutry lanes and see which one you prefer. The Proton may handle ok as they do own Lotus and I think the chassis tuned by them.

.blue

Original Poster:

726 posts

211 months

Wednesday 17th March 2010
quotequote all
Beefmeister said:
You know, i was about to post a picture of the Proton, mocking you etc



But you know what? On looks alone, it looks quite good!

BUT - the Swift is better to drive, better handling, better looking, better built, more reliable, will hold its value better, and is much much cooler.

Well worth the extra outlay IMO.
Haha, cheers Beefmeister... I think

About the Swift - you're probably right about the first 6 things but in terms of coolness, purely due to the rarity of the Proton, I think the Satria takes it wink

Out of interest, has anyone here actually driven the Satria? It's probably no Swift in the handling department, but don't be write it off with such haste, you'd be surprised!

Sixpackpert

5,371 posts

245 months

Wednesday 17th March 2010
quotequote all
.blue said:
About the Swift - you're probably right about the first 6 things but in terms of coolness, purely due to the rarity of the Proton, I think the Satria takes it wink
This is wrong. Very wrong.

.blue

Original Poster:

726 posts

211 months

Wednesday 17th March 2010
quotequote all
Sixpackpert said:
.blue said:
About the Swift - you're probably right about the first 6 things but in terms of coolness, purely due to the rarity of the Proton, I think the Satria takes it wink
This is wrong. Very wrong.
Why's that? biggrin

Sixpackpert

5,371 posts

245 months

Wednesday 17th March 2010
quotequote all
.blue said:
Sixpackpert said:
.blue said:
About the Swift - you're probably right about the first 6 things but in terms of coolness, purely due to the rarity of the Proton, I think the Satria takes it wink
This is wrong. Very wrong.
Why's that? biggrin
Because IMHO and everyone else who his crowded around my monitor chuckling the Proton is not a cool car.

Buy

the

Swift.

Republik

4,525 posts

221 months

Wednesday 17th March 2010
quotequote all
Swift or Satria. No contest.

.blue

Original Poster:

726 posts

211 months

Wednesday 17th March 2010
quotequote all
In terms of image, the Swift might/probably does trump the Satria. Fair enough.

But has anyone here driven both cars? Looks and resale value aside, what did you think?

Republik

4,525 posts

221 months

Wednesday 17th March 2010
quotequote all
I think as most people have said, you would be crazy to buy the Satria. Not a good image, terrible build quality, probably not great to drive, looks OK but will depreciate like a stone. Whereas the Suzuki Swift is better on every level. I'd also consider a Fiat Panda for similar money.

SystemParanoia

14,343 posts

229 months

Wednesday 17th March 2010
quotequote all
loved the old GTI proton

saaby93

32,038 posts

209 months

Wednesday 17th March 2010
quotequote all
Beefmeister said:
Are those the same lights as Lotus Europa?

SystemParanoia

14,343 posts

229 months

Wednesday 17th March 2010
quotequote all
no

.blue

Original Poster:

726 posts

211 months

Wednesday 17th March 2010
quotequote all
saaby93 said:
Beefmeister said:
Are those the same lights as Lotus Europa?
Nah, unfortunately not: http://www.seriouswheels.com/pics-2007/2007-Lotus-...

I had a feeling that PHers wouldn't take too well to anything Proton but the sheer number of negative replies is worrying...

On the bright side though, those that have driven it seem to think more favourably of the car:
"The ride is firm and the suspension crashes a little unnervingly over larger bumps in the road but the most important thing is that the Satria is great fun. The steering is sharp and accurate, inviting you to carve into corners where youll find plenty of grip at the front end and an impressive absence of body roll. Its here that the Lotus magic is in evidence." - http://uk.cars.yahoo.com/car-reviews/car-and-drivi...

Sixpackpert

5,371 posts

245 months

Wednesday 17th March 2010
quotequote all
.blue said:
"The ride is firm and the suspension crashes a little unnervingly over larger bumps in the road but the most important thing is that the Satria is great fun. The steering is sharp and accurate, inviting you to carve into corners where youll find plenty of grip at the front end and an impressive absence of body roll. Its here that the Lotus magic is in evidence." - http://uk.cars.yahoo.com/car-reviews/car-and-drivi...
Which sounds to me like it is more jittery than my pick up.

Oh and I'll correct the quoted person, it's you'll.