ST or GTI
Author
Discussion

Godders

Original Poster:

16 posts

266 months

Wednesday 17th March 2010
quotequote all
There is no better place to ask this question.
I am thinking about a new car for my wife to use as a shopping car/short commute and that I will enjoy owning and driving when I dont want to put miles on my pride and joy. Approx 9-10k budget so thinking 2006/7 Ford Focus ST or Golf GTi. Wondered if anyone did the spadework and looked at both. Thoughts?

BAKS42

200 posts

200 months

Wednesday 17th March 2010
quotequote all
ST for me, been out in both over the last few weeks, The ST has alot more character and a great sounding engine, but it does stand out alot more, the GTI was very nice, couldnt fault it, just a little borring for me but thats just my oppinion, both great cars. get out for some test drives!

BAKS42

200 posts

200 months

Wednesday 17th March 2010
quotequote all
Also a GTI for the budget will be a much higher mileage one, although if it has a fsh should not be a problem.

Urban Sports

11,321 posts

234 months

Wednesday 17th March 2010
quotequote all
That budget would be an ST for me, you'd probably get a better prospect for that price.

I was in the position for either of those a few months back, but bought a 3 series instead, so what the hell do I know?

biggrin

kbf1981

2,351 posts

231 months

Wednesday 17th March 2010
quotequote all
Godders said:
There is no better place to ask this question.
I am thinking about a new car for my wife to use as a shopping car/short commute and that I will enjoy owning and driving when I dont want to put miles on my pride and joy. Approx 9-10k budget so thinking 2006/7 Ford Focus ST or Golf GTi. Wondered if anyone did the spadework and looked at both. Thoughts?
I did.

I bought the ST.

It's a better car, that's prettier imo, with more kit, and costs less to buy. Uses more fuel, but it's just better. Sounds better, slightly faster, more spacious, and you don't have tartan seats! WTF...tartan?

Ecurie Ecosse

4,812 posts

249 months

Wednesday 17th March 2010
quotequote all
Neither. Go for a 147 GTA.

swamp

1,014 posts

220 months

Wednesday 17th March 2010
quotequote all
In a few years time (or sooner), when petrol is £2 a litre, the 35 mpg GTI will still be a popular car. The ST will be a girder in Shanghai. wink

Matt UK

18,084 posts

231 months

Wednesday 17th March 2010
quotequote all
I think I'd like the idea of the ST
But I'd actually settle on the idea of the GTi

Then I'd look at my £9-10k sitting there and buy neither of the above.

Edited by Matt UK on Wednesday 17th March 23:22

ClintonB

5,079 posts

244 months

Wednesday 17th March 2010
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
To be fair, that could easily be levelled at either option (or indeed pretty much any hot hatch). Colour has a lot to do with it & letting Jeremy & co loose in horrible Orange press cars - nono
End result, Billy bullst tools like this who are perfect ammo for Mrs Tonker:


http://pistonheads.com/sales/1517299.htm

HellDiver

5,708 posts

213 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
"electric perlsperant orange"

Perlsperant, no wonder it's a £3k option...

GingerWizard

4,721 posts

229 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
swamp said:
In a few years time (or sooner), when petrol is £2 a litre, the 35 mpg GTI will still be a popular car. The ST will be a girder in Shanghai. wink
you under estimate humans resolve. I am never going to have less then 200bhp ever again, regardless of fuel cost.

Groober

775 posts

211 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
Ecurie Ecosse said:
Neither. Go for a 147 GTA.
Definatly this!

ol

2,387 posts

239 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
Dooshbag said:
...the DSG box is an unwanted faff IMO
Have you ever driven a DSG?? It's fantastic. I've been converted with mine - great on track, you can just stick it in D and forget about it for city driving, and when you have it in manual or sport you can press on round country roads without having to take your hands off the wheel. It changes gear faster than manual and has launch control. What's not to like?!

Edited by ol on Thursday 18th March 09:28

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
Groober said:
Ecurie Ecosse said:
Neither. Go for a 147 GTA.
Definatly this!
How does the thirst compare to the ST? I've not driven the 5 pot ST but a V6 always seems to sound good smile

bazking69

8,620 posts

221 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
Both are great cars, but the ST is great VFM at the moment (10k buys a good one), even more so next to a VW badge and that 5cyl turbo engine is a peach.

Just avoid Wayne Rooney orange or Essex Boy white IMO.

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
ol said:
Dooshbag said:
...the DSG box is an unwanted faff IMO
Have you ever driven a DSG?? It's fantastic. I've been converted with mine - great on track, you can just stick it in D and forget about it for city driving, and when you have it in manual or sport you can press on round country roads without having to take your hands off the wheel. It changes gear faster than manual and has launch control. What's not to like?!

Edited by ol on Thursday 18th March 09:28
Lack of mechanical involvement in the process from the driver, in my opinion.

Matt UK

18,084 posts

231 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
10 Pence Short said:
ol said:
Dooshbag said:
...the DSG box is an unwanted faff IMO
Have you ever driven a DSG?? It's fantastic. I've been converted with mine - great on track, you can just stick it in D and forget about it for city driving, and when you have it in manual or sport you can press on round country roads without having to take your hands off the wheel. It changes gear faster than manual and has launch control. What's not to like?!

Edited by ol on Thursday 18th March 09:28
Lack of mechanical involvement in the process from the driver, in my opinion.
Agree with this. Technically I was very impressed, but it wouldn't be the option for me on a drivers car.

bazking69

8,620 posts

221 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
As far as paddle boxes go, DSG is right up there as one of the best. If you really want flappy shift that is.

Stew2000

2,776 posts

209 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
Focus = Family man.
Golf = Cock.

I should know. my neighbour has a MKV Golf GTI and he's a bit of a cock. and it just sounds terrible.

--edit--
She should get a Clio Sport or something.

Edited by Stew2000 on Thursday 18th March 10:22

rb5230

11,657 posts

203 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
the focus has so much more character, better noise, better interior, looks better and drives better. only downside is less mpg by maybe 4mpg.



Edited by rb5230 on Thursday 18th March 10:42