What should you expect from a second hand car?
What should you expect from a second hand car?
Author
Discussion

markswebpages

Original Poster:

174 posts

208 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
This has probably been done before,but I'll ask anyway.

I work in retail (part of this means providing a service in the customers home) so I'm used to the fact that regardless of how hard you try there are some people who's expectations are just unreasonable and they usually unwittingly make the situation worse by being difficult form the off.

But listening to the radio this morning they are saying that trading standards say that second hand cars are the thing that they received the most complaints about.

So I've got questions,

What would you expect from a second hand banger?

I Know it's all relative but 1K is allot of money for me, however if I spent it on a second hand car unless it had a fault that was deliberately hidden I'd chalk most things up to experience and move on, after all in that sort of price range a car is going have seen allot of use.

What would you expect from a second hand car bought from a main dealer?

I would expect say a 2 year old car to be in pretty good shape and would expect it not to have a major failure for a good time after i'd bought it. However consumable stuff is to be expected and some things no one could reasonably be expected to spot, however i would expect some sort of good will gesture depending on what it was that failed or needed replacing.

It seems to me reading things on here or other car related sites that often the people who are enquiring about obscure rules and requirements that a second hand car should conform to are really taking the mickey, but somehow they seem to get away with it as the law is on their side. Yet some people who have genuine problems seem to be left completely powerless (I can't remember who it was but the guy with the air bag that had gone off randomly in the mini springs to mind), so should the laws be changed to make them more relevant to modern trading conditions?

I seems to me that sometimes people forget that when you buy a car second and even if it's not very old no one can really say for sure how it's been treated (you can take an educated guess, but you'll never know for sure), so is it realistic to expect everything to be perfect when you buy a second hand car?

kavanagh

555 posts

225 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
In an ideal world a 1k car should be perfect but expecting it to be so is a little unrealistic.Experience in the faults of the marque and do your homework beforehand is the key.Trust no one!.

pat_y

1,029 posts

232 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
I at least expect the car to match the description, if the dealer is describing it as 'excellent' and 'best example of this model' then i expect it to be just that.
I'm getting a bit fed up with dealers description not matching the actual article. Especially when i've paid thousands trying to mitigate against buying a lemon. Recently i rejected 2 cars bacause i found fairly major faults not declared by seller, the third i bought, but despite after having it only 2 weeks and buying a big warranty and paying top dollar for the spec i'm building a list of 'issues'.
I'm gradually coming to the conclusion that people tend to sell their cars to dealers when there is a problem.

Fittster

20,120 posts

244 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
I'd expect it not to be stolen.

I'd expect the mileage to be correct unless stated otherwise.

I'd expect FSH to mean that there is documentation (not just a stamp in a book) for a service on the manufactures schedule.

Drederick Tatum

1,033 posts

216 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
Fittster said:
I'd expect it not to be stolen.

I'd expect the mileage to be correct unless stated otherwise.

I'd expect FSH to mean that there is documentation (not just a stamp in a book) for a service on the manufactures schedule.
I think this post sums it up

bazking69

8,620 posts

221 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
Everyone has their own expectations. Sadly some people expect the earth when they aren't prepared to pay the money for the best. We've all had pedantic buyers splitting hairs haven't we..

Basics though, I'd expect a service history, preferably full, a long MOT if private or a new one if dealer, valid tax, 2 keys, V5 in the owners name at the owners address if private and a truthful description in the advert.

Chris71

21,549 posts

273 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
Same as any car - an honest description and no attempts to cover up serious problems. You can't expect every seller to be an expert, but it is reasonable to expect them to be honest about what they do know.

Drederick Tatum

1,033 posts

216 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
Dont buy a 2nd hand car from London

markswebpages

Original Poster:

174 posts

208 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
I've only ever bought and sold a handful of cars, but they've all been sub 1K.

The first one was a Mini and i just wanted to feel it had gone to a good home so i sold it cheap to someone on a Mini forum.

Second one I put a poster in the car window when it was parked up while I was at work and I got a call before I had even got to work (5 Min walk) and the guy wanted to take it there and then, I perused him to wait until the evening and thought it seemed a bit to good to be true, he came round paid cash and never haggled or even test drove it.

However many years ago me and a mate where trying to sell car, I knew the history of it as it had belonged to another mate for a few years. But the logbook stated the wrong model car (it was a very late Cav Mk2 SRi 130 and had CDi on the log book) but the previous owner had tried to change it without success and when I had it I amended it when I sent it off and it still came back the same. Everything else tied up though and other than that it was a decent car, so we spent some money bringing it back to life (previous owner had abused it and never really spent anything on it during his ownership)whilst using it for a few weeks and then advertised it for sale to make a little profit. Well I had allot of interest in it as the price we pitched it at was very keen This young lad turns up and I show him everything (probably allot of stuff that others wouldn't even have mentioned), but before he arrived I had explained about the log book and I explained again while he was looking and showed him all the chassis numbers etc. and he buys the car.

So fast forward an hour and I get his dad on the phone saying he's contacted the police as he thinks I've sold his son a ringer and I also coerced his lad into buying it by creating another buyer waiting in the wings (another buyer had arrived early and had already started sniffing around even though I asked him to wait) and I actually said to the lad if you want to take a minuet and think about it don't feel pressurised.

I was bricking it even though I couldn't see how I did anything wrong, but sure enough i never here anything afterwards. Problem is it still plays on my mind now and I worry that I might end up in a similar situation when I try to sell another car.

The thing is I read some of the stuff about people being complete dicks about old cars and now I'm worried about trying to sell my current car as I fancy a change again.

I suppose my best bet is to try to remember that most people are genuine.

Whitean3

2,197 posts

229 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
I think I would also expect a second hand car to have a fault or two or something on it/in it you don't like or is not ideal. Sometimes I think people expect perfection from something that is used and sudffers from wear and tear!

But as others have said, I would expect the condition of the car to match the description, and I would expect to see some evidence that the car has been looked after- whether it be a stack of bills and service history, whether it is in really good condition for it's age, or whether the owner is enthusiastic about it and clearly knows about the car. All three of these things rang true when I bought my car; but as I stated above, I could list things that were not perfect- But it didn't put me off one bit...

mat205125

17,790 posts

244 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
Fittster said:
I'd expect it not to be stolen.

I'd expect the mileage to be correct unless stated otherwise.

I'd expect FSH to mean that there is documentation (not just a stamp in a book) for a service on the manufactures schedule.
Stay away from the Midlands then.