Sheds - BMW/Volvo/Saab?
Author
Discussion

Elskeggso

Original Poster:

3,100 posts

218 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
I was thinking something like E34, S40 or 9000, any opinions on which would be best for a wafty shed, or which ones would be a nightmare at that sort of money? (>£1000)

hairykrishna

14,539 posts

234 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
All of them are good, really. The 9000 is my vote for the sensible option but the E34 is more fun.

kavanagh

555 posts

225 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
You missed out garden ;-).Bm for me.Mine cost me 600 for a clean N e34 5.H/G has just went but in the past few thousand miles in a short period of time on all type of roads/weather conditions hasent put a foot wrong.My ms wants another!.Bargetastic.Cant comment on the others but the e34 gets a thumbs up and for your money you should get a mint,low miles example.Rwd too!.Go for it!.You know you want too.

Elskeggso

Original Poster:

3,100 posts

218 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
Would anything above a 520 be decent enough not to fall apart/blow up for that money? A 525 would be nice

Wing Commander

2,220 posts

263 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
My 9000 was £600 and has:

2.3 turbo petrol engine which does 30mpg avg
Heated leather
Power everything
Climate
Cruise

it's reliable, spacious and comfy. The only let down is it's built for wafting at a constant speed. Fling it mercilessly around an A road or try and pull up mega quick and you are reminded how heavy the car is...

It would be my choice but that's mostly due to not having had any of the others.

hairykrishna

14,539 posts

234 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
Elskeggso said:
Would anything above a 520 be decent enough not to fall apart/blow up for that money? A 525 would be nice
If it's purely wafting ability you want go for the 7 series. A 730 costs peanuts.

macp

4,823 posts

214 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
Dont forget to look at a Volvo S70 or V70 which are bombproof and generally fully loaded.I had a T5 and thought it was brilliant.

Edit:
Also check out the 850 series which is the older version of the above.

Edited by macp on Thursday 18th March 15:02

Elskeggso

Original Poster:

3,100 posts

218 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
Wing Commander said:
My 9000 was £600 and has:

2.3 turbo petrol engine which does 30mpg avg
Heated leather
Power everything
Climate
Cruise

it's reliable, spacious and comfy. The only let down is it's built for wafting at a constant speed. Fling it mercilessly around an A road or try and pull up mega quick and you are reminded how heavy the car is...

It would be my choice but that's mostly due to not having had any of the others.
Actually that sounds pretty good, any niggling problems with electrics etc? I know nothing about Saabs

hairykrishna

14,539 posts

234 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
I've had two Saabs, my current 9000 Aero (cost me a bargain £750) and a previous 9000 eco turbo that cost ~£300. Beyond a drive belt neither had any problems whatsoever.

Gad-Westy

16,665 posts

244 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
I only have experience of the E34 so I'd unwittingly vote for that . They seem to be built to last forever and handle very nicely for such a large car. The electronics aren't too complex either so they seem to generally still be fully operational on most cars unlike some of the later BM's. Somebody mentioned earlier about an H/G failure. A neighbour of mine has just suffered this on a 525 and a friend's old 520 also blew a gasket so maybe its something to look out for. That and suspension bushes it would seem.

SJobson

13,915 posts

295 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
I had an E34 and a 9000 simultaneously a couple of years ago. Sold the 9000 first because I preferred the BMW, but either would make a good shed.

E34 weak point would be the front bushes and sloppy steering, leading to the 60mph shimmy. You could spend much of the value of the car trying to put that right so get one without it. 525i 24v for preference, and try to get a facelift one (with VANOS so a bit more torque) that's had the metric wheels replaced so tyres don't cost £200 a corner.

9000 weak point would be the gearbox, but that's no reason to avoid going for a 2.3T. Make sure it has leather because the Bridge of Weir stuff in the 9000 is just lovely.

Edited by SJobson on Thursday 18th March 15:27

Elskeggso

Original Poster:

3,100 posts

218 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
macp said:
Dont forget to look at a Volvo S70 or V70 which are bombproof and generally fully loaded.I had a T5 and thought it was brilliant.

Edit:
Also check out the 850 series which is the older version of the above.

Edited by macp on Thursday 18th March 15:02
I actually wouldn't mind spending a bit more and getting something less shed-like such as this:
http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/1471921.htm

Vic Cooper

230 posts

200 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
Reliable old Saab? :O I like the "Opelsson" as a funny car with intresting solutions, but loads of them have problems with electronics, sensors and turbos. Sometimes gearboxes as well. A Volvo C70 seems to be better choice (non turbo), or a not chav'd Beemer.

Paul6217

324 posts

205 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
Elskeggso said:
macp said:
Dont forget to look at a Volvo S70 or V70 which are bombproof and generally fully loaded.I had a T5 and thought it was brilliant.

Edit:
Also check out the 850 series which is the older version of the above.

Edited by macp on Thursday 18th March 15:02
I actually wouldn't mind spending a bit more and getting something less shed-like such as this:
http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/1471921.htm
Thats his car

Elskeggso

Original Poster:

3,100 posts

218 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
Paul6217 said:
Elskeggso said:
macp said:
Dont forget to look at a Volvo S70 or V70 which are bombproof and generally fully loaded.I had a T5 and thought it was brilliant.

Edit:
Also check out the 850 series which is the older version of the above.

Edited by macp on Thursday 18th March 15:02
I actually wouldn't mind spending a bit more and getting something less shed-like such as this:
http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/1471921.htm
Thats his car
So it is, I didn't click on his profile before

Garett

1,689 posts

223 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
Another vote for the 9000, I also have a 2.3 turbo CSE so its got all the gadgets and absolutely everything works. Not bad for a 15 y.o car.

They have no real weaknesses to speak of, just steer clear from cars with TCS as it can be a major expense and headache to sort. If they are well looked after they tend to go on pretty much forever. The biggest expense with mine has been the clutch which all in was £500, but you can put that down as a wear and tear item really.

The turbos are also ridiculously easy to re-map, mine cost around £140 for a re-map plus a few bits of hose and a boost controller, and that took my car from 170 bhp to 230bhp approx. And it'll still do 35mpg on a run, 29 on average and low 20s if you cane it.

macp

4,823 posts

214 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
Elskeggso said:
Paul6217 said:
Elskeggso said:
macp said:
Dont forget to look at a Volvo S70 or V70 which are bombproof and generally fully loaded.I had a T5 and thought it was brilliant.

Edit:
Also check out the 850 series which is the older version of the above.

Edited by macp on Thursday 18th March 15:02
I actually wouldn't mind spending a bit more and getting something less shed-like such as this:
http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/1471921.htm
Thats his car
So it is, I didn't click on his profile before
Yes twas mine and it was superb not entirely sure now why I sold it except there was a bidding war for it and I couldnt say no.

Edited by macp on Thursday 18th March 16:32

Jag-D

19,633 posts

250 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
Elskeggso said:
I was thinking something like E34, S40 or 9000, any opinions on which would be best for a wafty shed, or which ones would be a nightmare at that sort of money? (>£1000)
Right, I've had two of these and my mate had the other

The S40 is an ok car, I've got one now (which is exceptional in it's condition for price btw) but it's not a wafter in the long distance sense..really could use a 6th cog.

Mines the 1.8ise so nicely specced, comfortable and for average running (shorter motorway jaunts, town plodding) it's very good. Fuel economy? Pure town running will see a return of about 28mpg, good motorway runs you can return neigh on 40mpg at a steady pace and combined an average of about 33 is around the norm with mine.

BMW E34: Definitely the better long distance tourer and infinitely more fun to drive especially if you get the inline 6 engine or V8.

The 1.8 is useless so unless you're really wanting one, avoid them!

The 2.0 M20 straight 6 isn't a bad ole stick, neither is the 2.5 of the breed. Not a huge amount of poke, but the 2.5 has enough to keep you chuckling when it comes to roundabouts. The M30 3.0 is a corking engine and the M30 3.5 is better still more so for the slight hike in power. Just check for cracked heads, poor oil feed, leaks and the usual gubbins.

The M50B20/25 is a corker of a lump, tends to sound a bit grumbly in my experience, but never seems to cause concern. Plenty of poke, sounds good, reasonable MPG returns for the size and fairly reliable.

Early V8s had problems with the Nikasil liners, but the majority of these problems should be sorted by now

The 4 litre is the V8 of choice if you can find a good one

Obviouslly if you go for the BMW then you're gonna suffer on MPG and likely to pay more than the other alternatives, but such a satisfying car to own!!!!

Elskeggso

Original Poster:

3,100 posts

218 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
Thanks a lot

NiceCupOfTea

25,608 posts

282 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
Will be looking into this in a few months' time. Heart says Beemer - straight six, rear wheel drive, drivers' car - but they do tend to get ragged and can't help thinking a sub grand example would be very ratty.

I am a Saab guy and I know 9000s pretty well. A grand will see you into a really good example, fully loaded, and they just don't go wrong. As said, there are no real weak points! Head says 9000 - and they are still quite fun to hustle and very tunetable.