Torque/BHP
Author
Discussion

tyranical

Original Poster:

927 posts

221 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
I know there are alot of variables etc but take them all away, we have 2 cars, both weigh the same, handle the same etc etc etc. The ONLY difference is, one is a 200bhp/200lb/ft Petrol and the other is a 150bhp/300lb/ft Diesel

If they both floored it, would the diesel pull away due to the extra torque assuming turbo kicks in at same revs and all that sort of stuff?

No variables at all, the only difference between the two is the 100 torques.

I know this isn't a real life situation, its merely hypothetical.

Vixpy1

42,699 posts

295 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
Depends completely on gearing

The Lukas

2,773 posts

225 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
Depends on gearing, power curves, and many other things.

I would say horsepower is the final figure so the petrol would be faster if it was in it's prime rev range.

motoroller

657 posts

204 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
Strictly speaking acceleration depends on torque. If they were both in the torque band, the diesel would win.

tyranical

Original Poster:

927 posts

221 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
Ok, perhaps i didn't make it clear.

NO VARIABLES.

They are both exactly the same in every single way apart from the BHP/Torque.

Weight, gearing, torque curves, whatever other variables you can come up with, they are all the same.

kambites

71,709 posts

252 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
Flywheel torque means nothing in isolation because it's relative to gearing.

In answer to your question, it'd probably depend on which gear you were using. Using the right gear, the higher powered car would be (quite a lot) faster unless it has a really daft power curve. However, you might be able to pick a really stupid gear in which the lower powered car is faster.

Dracoro

9,038 posts

276 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
BHP is torque (multipled by gearing to give bhp effectively).

All things being equal, the 200bhp car will beat the 150bhp car, both driven properly etc.

For sure the high low down torque car will probably pull harder at 2000rpm but the other one will pull a lot harder at 6000rpm.

Whether the torque and bhp is powered by petrol or diesel is neither here nor there.

Edited by Dracoro on Thursday 18th March 18:34

nbetts

1,455 posts

260 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
If everything else was equal - as you describe in your scenario - the more Powerful car would win as it would be able to accelerate for longer due to its higher rev band.

mackie1

8,169 posts

264 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
the 200bhp car will win if both have the same torque curve and the road speed in each gear is the same as it'll be making more torque at the wheels.

The Lukas

2,773 posts

225 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
motoroller said:
Strictly speaking acceleration depends on torque.


Please explain?

Dracoro

9,038 posts

276 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
The Lukas said:
motoroller said:
Strictly speaking acceleration depends on torque.

Please explain?
It's true, except he's missed out the word "gearing".

Now, if only there was a figure that illustrated torque multiplied by gearing... scratchchin

mackie1

8,169 posts

264 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
The torque *at the wheels* at any given moment will determine the rate of acceleration. This is dependant on gearing so the 200bhp car will actually have more torque at the wheels than the 150bhp car all else being equal (flat torque curve and same top speed in each gear).

This is why a standalone torque figure is useless and power (torque x rpm) is a much more useful number.


PS. Where's Mr Whippy?

Edited by mackie1 on Thursday 18th March 18:51

The Lukas

2,773 posts

225 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
Dracoro said:
The Lukas said:
motoroller said:
Strictly speaking acceleration depends on torque.

Please explain?
It's true, except he's missed out the word "gearing".

Now, if only there was a figure that illustrated torque multiplied by gearing... scratchchin
But horsepower is the final figure. Torque is only as good as the revs.

(T o clarify? Are we talking wheel torque or flywheel torque?)

Edited by The Lukas on Thursday 18th March 18:52

nbetts

1,455 posts

260 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
The more powerful car will always win.

Your scenario says everything equal - therefore more powerful car generates more on the road torque. And will whip that nasty oil burning jalopy into kingdom come.

Probably. smile

Dracoro

9,038 posts

276 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
A car is producing a given BHP at a given revs, the higher the bhp at whatever revs, the higher the acceleration.....

So for example a car producing 100 bhp at 3000rpm will accelerate quicker than another producing 80bhp at 3000rpm at that point.

When going for maximum acceleration you use all the power that is available, the more the faster. The 200bhp has more and thus will be faster.

Dracoro

9,038 posts

276 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
The Lukas said:
Dracoro said:
The Lukas said:
motoroller said:
Strictly speaking acceleration depends on torque.

Please explain?
It's true, except he's missed out the word "gearing".

Now, if only there was a figure that illustrated torque multiplied by gearing... scratchchin
But horsepower is the final figure. Torque is only as good as the revs.

(T o clarify? Are we talking wheel torque or flywheel torque?)
It doesn't matter. What you need to know is, how much BHP is there at whatever revs.

A torque figure tells us nothing, that's why we use BHP as it's the torque multiplied by the revs.

The Lukas

2,773 posts

225 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
I think we have an answer. Tell me: where did that saying:

"Horsepower sells cars, torque wins races"

come from?

nbetts

1,455 posts

260 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
The Lukas said:
I think we have an answer. Tell me: where did that saying:

"Horsepower sells cars, torque wins races"

come from?
An Ass.

Dracoro

9,038 posts

276 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
The Lukas said:
I think we have an answer. Tell me: where did that saying:

"Horsepower sells cars, torque wins races"

come from?
Someone talking rubbish? biggrin To be fair, I think it was Shelby and is mis-interpreted/quoted out of context.

It's ironic really as now it's the other way round (people going on about torque, not knowing what it is, as it sells cars yet it's bhp that is the important figure).

Edited by Dracoro on Thursday 18th March 19:05

otolith

69,758 posts

235 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
I think the Shelby quote carries the implicit assumption that racing cars under the same regulations will have similar peak power - in which case making more power elsewhere in the rev range may be a significant benefit. I'm pretty sure that if you offered McLaren the choice of 25% more peak power or 25% more peak torque, they wouldn't give a stuff about the torque.