Haynes build it yourself engine...help please....!
Haynes build it yourself engine...help please....!
Author
Discussion

Mario149

Original Poster:

7,789 posts

209 months

Friday 19th March 2010
quotequote all
Okay, don't laugh (too much!) but the other day I bought one of these models in a moment of curiosity. I've an engineering background but of the aero sort rather than automotive, so thought it might be fun as well as informative to "build" my own engine with moving parts and all that.

Anyway, to cut a long story short, and this is going to sound sad, no matter whether I follow the instructions (which they seem to be very specific in order that it DOES work) or try and do it myself, I cannot for the life of me get the cams and timings set up such that the pistons move and valves open close for the combustion cycle in a way that is actually realistic i.e. suck (intake valve open), squeeze (both valves closed), bang (both valves closed), blow (exhaust valve open). The closest I can get it has the intake and exhaust valve openings swapped (I'm wondering if there was a typo in the manual).

Basically, I'm not convinced that the timings will be right whatever! Anyone else built one of these and had problems??!!

Okay guys, now be gentle, my (engineering) manhood is on the line here! But if I do get it to work I promise to post pics wink ..... tongue out

Robb F

4,614 posts

202 months

Friday 19th March 2010
quotequote all
Seems to me like you have an ideal opportunity to learn how to correctly time up an engine here.
I think it is alot more likely you are doing something wrong than the kit being wrong.

Do some research into valve timing and experiment with your setup.

Good luck biggrin

Fastra

4,289 posts

240 months

Friday 19th March 2010
quotequote all
Can't help other than to suggest contacting some of the guys on Youtube who have built one:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6TTqsEMbOOk&fea...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xZDkiZwEpEY

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-w8knL-U9Gs

smile

Boosted LS1

21,200 posts

291 months

Friday 19th March 2010
quotequote all
The inlet and exhaust valves will spend sometime open during the overlap period. Could this be what you're experiencing?

roscozs

477 posts

212 months

Friday 19th March 2010
quotequote all
Are you sure you have the inlet cam and exhaust cam in the correct place on the cylinder head?

Mario149

Original Poster:

7,789 posts

209 months

Friday 19th March 2010
quotequote all
Fastra: I had a look at those and a couple of others, none seem to get in close enough to see what the valves are doing!

Boosted: given how much play the cams have on the camshaft (tolerances are sh!te) it might be a bit of that, but doesn't look like it!

Roscozs: it's a SOHC with rocker arms so unfortunately only one to bugger up!

Honestly, I think it may just be an error in the kit. When I put the cams on as per the instructions (i've been over them 50x, with fresh eyes at points and all), it simply doesn't look anything like it does in the booklet. For a start, in the booklet, the cam pairings (inlet, exhaust) are all about ~150 degs apart, when I put them on _exactly_ as per the instructions, they're ~30 degs apart and can't be fitted any other way to make them look like the pic except for possibly randomly putting some on backwards, but not others. V frustrating....I can see an email going to haynes tomorrow!


Boosted LS1

21,200 posts

291 months

Friday 19th March 2010
quotequote all
Do you have 2 one piece camshafts or bits that you assemble to make a camshaft? I ask because your terminology isn't quite clear to me.

Mroad

829 posts

246 months

Friday 19th March 2010
quotequote all
I built one of these with my nephew to explain how an engine works. Good kit but you are right we also had issues with the valve timings. I don't think you can get them right, I think the cams are wrong.

Mario149

Original Poster:

7,789 posts

209 months

Friday 19th March 2010
quotequote all
Boosted LS1 said:
Do you have 2 one piece camshafts or bits that you assemble to make a camshaft? I ask because your terminology isn't quite clear to me.
basically, there is a metal rod about 15cm long and 2mm wide (camshaft) onto which slide little teardrop-shaped (in profile) pieces of plastic, 1 for each rocker arm (for each valve). The rod has a circular profile with one flat side such that the tear drops can only go on one way and also "hold" the rod as it goes round. I'll try and take a couple of pics quickly....

ETA: my camera's too crap, can't take pics.

Edited by Mario149 on Friday 19th March 20:58

Boosted LS1

21,200 posts

291 months

Friday 19th March 2010
quotequote all
Those are the cam lobes that you describe. Is there any way you have the shafts fitted the wrong way round or the wrong way round end to end? Usually it's pretty clear the sprockets will only fit on one end but who knows with a kit like this.

NiceCupOfTea

25,608 posts

282 months

Friday 19th March 2010
quotequote all
I got one for Christmas 18 months ago - don't remember having any problems with cam timing...

Want me to take pics?

poo at Paul's

14,621 posts

206 months

Friday 19th March 2010
quotequote all
Fastra said:
Can't help other than to suggest contacting some of the guys on Youtube who have built one:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6TTqsEMbOOk&fea...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xZDkiZwEpEY

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-w8knL-U9Gs

smile
Sorry, but they look a bit crap! laugh


As meentioned there may wel be no time that both valves on a cylinder are shut completely, this is valve overlap and is required as at the low point of cams, as the opening ramp starts to open the valve, the opening speed is so slow, it needs to start opening very early in the cam's rotation.

You may ask why some of the incoming mixture does not get mixed up with the exhaust gas and exit straight out the exhaust? Well it does. Hence cars with a wide overlap have poorer emmissions gernerally.

But again, you may well just have it timed out or stuck the lobes on arse about face!

Edited by poo at Paul's on Friday 19th March 23:46

Mr Will

13,719 posts

237 months

Friday 19th March 2010
quotequote all
Silly question, are you putting the lobes on the shaft in the correct order?

saaby93

32,038 posts

209 months

Saturday 20th March 2010
quotequote all
Mr Will said:
Silly question, are you putting the lobes on the shaft in the correct order?
or the right way around? If the only guide is a flat, that gives you two options for fitting the lobes

Mario149

Original Poster:

7,789 posts

209 months

Saturday 20th March 2010
quotequote all
the lobes are numbered (well lettered) and have a raised ridge on one side to indicate the direction of fitting. It should just be a matter of fitting them on the shaft in order with the ridges all on the same side and robert's your mother's brother. Or not in this case frown

Mario149

Original Poster:

7,789 posts

209 months

Saturday 20th March 2010
quotequote all
NiceCupOfTea said:
I got one for Christmas 18 months ago - don't remember having any problems with cam timing...

Want me to take pics?
Yes please! Any close ups of the camshaft with the lobes fitted would be good smile Unfortunately I think you may have to remove it from the engine so I can see properly!

Bonefish Blues

36,994 posts

254 months

Saturday 20th March 2010
quotequote all
It is, of course entirely possible that you are the first bloke ever to admit this, and expose the fact that the kit has always been flawed biggrin

Mario149

Original Poster:

7,789 posts

209 months

Saturday 20th March 2010
quotequote all
Bonefish Blues said:
It is, of course entirely possible that you are the first bloke ever to admit this, and expose the fact that the kit has always been flawed biggrin
Maybe others don't even think it's flawed, maybe they reckon the valves are _supposed_ to bounce off the pistons wink ..... hehe

bertelli_1

2,437 posts

241 months

Saturday 20th March 2010
quotequote all
The first thing that occured to me....

Does the crank rotate the other way? ie anticlockwise. Surely this will sort the cam timing??

Mario149

Original Poster:

7,789 posts

209 months

Saturday 20th March 2010
quotequote all
bertelli_1 said:
The first thing that occured to me....

Does the crank rotate the other way? ie anticlockwise. Surely this will sort the cam timing??
can turn both ways, neither work. From videos it appears it is supposed to go clockwise