Which do you think is the beter car?
Which do you think is the beter car?

Poll: Which do you think is the beter car?

Total Members Polled: 65

BMW 525d Sport: 80%
Audi 2.7 TDi S Line: 20%
Author
Discussion

Ciaran

Original Poster:

1,474 posts

233 months

Sunday 21st March 2010
quotequote all
I've test drove the BMW but there isn't a 2.7 Audi near me unfortunately. Obviously I'm not going to buy a car without testing driving it but I thought I'd get the forums opinion anyway. Both cars are 2006 with similar miles.

I loved the BMW, to be honest I've had a few over the years and although I'd take another tomorrow I thought I would maybe try something different - hence the Audi.

Is the 3.0l quattro worth looking at?


Ciaran

Original Poster:

1,474 posts

233 months

Monday 22nd March 2010
quotequote all
I honestly didn't think the consensus would be over 70% in favour of the BMW!

Rawwr

22,722 posts

265 months

Monday 22nd March 2010
quotequote all
They both seem like the kind of vehicle that'd slowly eat away at your soul eventually leaving you as a husk.

Fruitcake

3,850 posts

257 months

Monday 22nd March 2010
quotequote all
Rawwr said:
They both seem like the kind of vehicle that'd slowly eat away at your soul eventually leaving you as a husk.
At least the BMW would be engaging when he wanted it to be.

Chr1sch

2,592 posts

224 months

Monday 22nd March 2010
quotequote all
I have to agree with the engagement comment. A6's are so dull to drive and IMO only look good inside and out in SLine spec which is almost intollerably hard.

However the 3.0 is a gem of a diesel so I wouldn't write that off either.

I am more of a BMW man but in 3.0 (Audi) form it's a tough call.

If you throw a 530/535d in the mix it's a no brainer!

V8mate

45,899 posts

220 months

Monday 22nd March 2010
quotequote all
Ciaran said:
I honestly didn't think the consensus would be over 70% in favour of the BMW!
How can 70% be a consensus? confused

mat205125

17,790 posts

244 months

Monday 22nd March 2010
quotequote all
Haven't been up close to the new 5 series, however I was never a fan of the outgoing car's interior. If I were chossing between the two on the basis of a company hack to thunder up and down the motorways I'd take the Audi, however I'd prefer the BMW if I were spending my own money.

The new E Class is also supposed to be a fine car, and unlike Merc of recent years.

coley20

2,965 posts

222 months

Monday 22nd March 2010
quotequote all
Don`t be fooled by the engine size a BMW 525d is a 3.0l

Somnophore

1,364 posts

207 months

Monday 22nd March 2010
quotequote all
You're surprised BMW won? Lots of Bimmer Fanboys on here.

Those the only two cars you're looking at? 335d mapped maybe? Lol

kambites

71,713 posts

252 months

Monday 22nd March 2010
quotequote all
Better at what? The BMW will be more fun to drive and probably faster. The Audi will have a nicer looking interior and exterior and I find the ergonomics much better. They both have surprisingly poor ride quality for such big, expensive, cars. Since you're on Pistonheads, I suspect the BMW would be better for you, but it really does depend on what you expect from it.