Weird insurance problem
Author
Discussion

Lefty Two Drams

Original Poster:

21,607 posts

233 months

Monday 22nd March 2010
quotequote all
I bought myself an old tipper truck, it's a 3.5 tonne 1990 Mercedes 308D (think Transit equivalent).

Had it on a temp insurance policy for 2 weeks and am now trying to get a proper insurance quote for it.

Firstly, none of the insurance websites I've found will bring up the details using the number plate which is a bit weird. I phoned a local broker who I've used many times before (swinton) and they have often been amongst the cheapest results from gocompare/confused etc.

They gave me a quote over the phone for £650 TPFT, 3000 miles/year for a van valued at £1500! I have 4 years ncb available for this policy (ncb from Swinton).

I then went to gocompare and managed to select a 308D van (but not a tipper) and got a quote from Swinton via gocompare for £170. £170 seems a more reasonable price for such a low value vehicle on TPFT cover....! To clarify, on gocompare, when I select the manufacturer and engine size, it brings up 308D as a model option but only a van, not a flatbed or tipperbed. confused

I phoned Swinton back but they weren't really able to help me and said that their quote of £650 was the best that they could do.

Here's the question: if I just accept the online quote of £170, will the policy be invalid if I ever have to claim because the truck actually has a tipping bed on the back rather than a van body?


marshalla

15,902 posts

232 months

Monday 22nd March 2010
quotequote all
Lefty Two Drams said:
Here's the question: if I just accept the online quote of £170, will the policy be invalid if I ever have to claim because the truck actually has a tipping bed on the back rather than a van body?
Yes.

robinhood21

31,317 posts

263 months

Monday 22nd March 2010
quotequote all
I used to run a couple of tippers and, was always explained to me that tippers were prone to, er, tip over when tipping on soft ground, etc. Something to do with all the weight of the load being (sometimes) stuck at the front end of the tipper so, when in the up position with all the weight up high, could make the tipper fall over to one side or 'tother. Hence high premiums.

Tom H

543 posts

218 months

Monday 22nd March 2010
quotequote all
The dangers of the Third Party Working Risk - This is to say the personal injury is high not only tipping onto someone but the tipper crushing someones arm / leg etc.

I also think that insurers think that a lot of unscrupulous people own them. (no offence to anyone).

Any yes you may as well save yourself £170 as you will end up paying for a worthless piece of paper.

Lefty Two Drams

Original Poster:

21,607 posts

233 months

Monday 22nd March 2010
quotequote all
Tom H said:
The dangers of the Third Party Working Risk - This is to say the personal injury is high not only tipping onto someone but the tipper crushing someones arm / leg etc.

I also think that insurers think that a lot of unscrupulous people own them. (no offence to anyone).

Any yes you may as well save yourself £170 as you will end up paying for a worthless piece of paper.
laugh I'm not a pikey!

And I hope the insurers don't think I am either. I've got 3 household insurance policies with them, two for other cars and not a single policy for a caravan! wink


Anybody else had trouble insuring a tipper van?

Lefty Two Drams

Original Poster:

21,607 posts

233 months

Monday 22nd March 2010
quotequote all
Just spoke to Direct Line and got a "We don't insure tippers".

I told them that they had an option on the website where I could just select Mercedes 308D LWB and it didn't specify it was a van. "Sorry, we don't insure tippers".

FFS.

marshalla

15,902 posts

232 months

Lefty Two Drams

Original Poster:

21,607 posts

233 months

Monday 22nd March 2010
quotequote all
Yeah just spoke to Adrian Flux (who used to insure my heavily modified Unimog fo9r £90/year) and they won't insure it because it's not being used for business purposes.

rolleyes

freakynessless

473 posts

213 months

Monday 22nd March 2010
quotequote all
Might be worth asking a broker for a commercial policy but only covering on the basis of own goods and SD&P. A commercial policy will be geared up with a better wording and cover and as its on the basis of own goods it should be fairly cheap.
As previously stated most personal lines insurers wont touch you with a barge pole due to the nature of the vehicle and what they are generally used for.

Good Luck

Gizmo!

18,150 posts

240 months

Monday 22nd March 2010
quotequote all
I wish people would get away from this ridiculous whinge that "it's more than the value of the car/van/etc".

A rusty old tank is equally as capable of driving through a queue at a bus-stop and maiming half a dozen nursing mothers as anything else.

Lefty Two Drams

Original Poster:

21,607 posts

233 months

Monday 22nd March 2010
quotequote all
It's sorted!

Got an online quote from More Than Business. It was the first website I used which actually recognised the number plate and brought up the type of vehicle and engine size.

It asked business type but there was an option in the dropdown box for "Private User" and there is a specific exclusion that I will not be insured for business use.

I opened up all the policy documents (you know, the ones you never read) and searched for the terms "tip", "tipper", "tipping" with no results.

It says on the policy: "Mercedes 308D" which is correct.

£195 and I think I'm legal. It's insured for SDP.

If I need to claim I hope that I can succesfully argue that the vehicle details were supplied by the insurers website from the reg plate I gave them and, in as far as they have described them, they are correct. The v5 confirms that the number plate is for a Mercedes 308D Tipper. Neither the website nor the policy documents make any mention of the specific body type of Mercedes 308D. Neither of the documents specifically exclude a tipper.

Anything else I should be worried about?




Edited by Lefty Two Drams on Monday 22 March 13:59

ShiggyBiggs

713 posts

205 months

Monday 22nd March 2010
quotequote all
I pay more than that for my VW caddy for insurance. And was quoted (far)higher than that for my old tdi mk3 golf.

550Hep

3,135 posts

248 months

Monday 22nd March 2010
quotequote all
Sounds like it ought to be ok but I would bet my left nut that if you ever claimed they would argue it to the ends of the Earth!

2fster

2,732 posts

257 months

Monday 22nd March 2010
quotequote all
Gizmo! said:
I wish people would get away from this ridiculous whinge that "it's more than the value of the car/van/etc".

A rusty old tank is equally as capable of driving through a queue at a bus-stop and maiming half a dozen nursing mothers as anything else.
+ 1

Lefty Two Drams

Original Poster:

21,607 posts

233 months

Monday 22nd March 2010
quotequote all
ShiggyBiggs said:
I pay more than that for my VW caddy for insurance. And was quoted (far)higher than that for my old tdi mk3 golf.
I've had a few "specialist" vehicles (ex MOD Land Rover, Unimogs etc) insured for well under £200 in the past.

Lefty Two Drams

Original Poster:

21,607 posts

233 months

Monday 22nd March 2010
quotequote all
550Hep said:
Sounds like it ought to be ok but I would bet my left nut that if you ever claimed they would argue it to the ends of the Earth!
I've no doubt. shoot

550Hep

3,135 posts

248 months

Monday 22nd March 2010
quotequote all
Lefty Two Drams said:
550Hep said:
Sounds like it ought to be ok but I would bet my left nut that if you ever claimed they would argue it to the ends of the Earth!
I've no doubt. shoot
The challenge is I guess that do you view that IF you have to claim and IF they argue they won't pay out are you happy to take that risk?

Also and someone correct me if I am wrong here but IF you claim and your insurance company successful argue your policy was invalid therefore won't payout you also risk getting done for driving without insurance! If that is the case is it a risk you are willing to take?

Curry Burns

5,620 posts

246 months

Monday 22nd March 2010
quotequote all
Iain, give me a call on 01224 743978, i'll se what I can do for your matey thumbup

Lefty Two Drams

Original Poster:

21,607 posts

233 months

Monday 22nd March 2010
quotequote all
That's why I didn't accept the other "cheap" quote that I received from swinton, because I had to enter vehicle details myself that didn't match the truck exactly.

The More Than quote is based on vehicle details provided by the insurere from the reg plate. The details shown on the policy are correct. The v5 is correct (and presumably the insurers get vehicle data from a DVLA database?) The dvla search from autotrader correctly identifies it as a 308D Tipper.

I haven't lied, omitted any facts or bent the truth in any way whilst applying for the policy and there are no exclusions which apply to the truck provided that I only use it for SDP purposes.

thumbup

Edited by Lefty Two Drams on Monday 22 March 14:26

Lefty Two Drams

Original Poster:

21,607 posts

233 months

Monday 22nd March 2010
quotequote all
Curry Burns said:
Iain, give me a call on 01224 743978, i'll se what I can do for your matey thumbup
Get off the phone!

wink