Vans and economy- please dont hurt me!
Discussion
I know this isnt really an interesting topic but id like some opinions all the same, if that ok, please.
Im a complete novice where vans are concerned. I dont like them much either. However, the time may soon arise that i need a van for deliveries. Now, What im delivering may be quite heavy at times, depending on how full the van is.
I'm thinking along the lines of the small car/van type vehicles rather than transits.
With regards to fuel economy, would a smaller engine with less torque struggle with a heavy load so much that it would become less fuel efficient than a larger engine with more torque?
I would mainly be driving about town and not visiting the motorways too often. I would do short stints on A roads but nothing like as much as the pootling about town through traffic etc.
Im comparing the likes of these:
http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/1554720.htm
http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/1247344.htm
My main concern is fuel economy for the obvious reason thats to so flippin' expensive!
Im a complete novice where vans are concerned. I dont like them much either. However, the time may soon arise that i need a van for deliveries. Now, What im delivering may be quite heavy at times, depending on how full the van is.
I'm thinking along the lines of the small car/van type vehicles rather than transits.
With regards to fuel economy, would a smaller engine with less torque struggle with a heavy load so much that it would become less fuel efficient than a larger engine with more torque?
I would mainly be driving about town and not visiting the motorways too often. I would do short stints on A roads but nothing like as much as the pootling about town through traffic etc.
Im comparing the likes of these:
http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/1554720.htm
http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/1247344.htm
My main concern is fuel economy for the obvious reason thats to so flippin' expensive!
Edited by simple101 on Tuesday 23 March 11:11
I've got a 1.7DTi combo and its pretty good for economy. Roof rack is always full, as is the back and i can usually get 80-100miles out of a tenner if i drive carefully and depending how far in the red im willing to push it. 380-400 out of a full tank being a bit less careful. Anything over 50-60 and your diesel will plummet when laden though. Good van overall, Usual bland vauxhall interior but i'd gladly get another.
We also run a few astra vans, they're good enough for what they are but if your planning on lugging heavy items with the back full don't forget to factor in the lack of a side door meaning you will be having to pull things from the bulkhead to the rear.
We also run a few astra vans, they're good enough for what they are but if your planning on lugging heavy items with the back full don't forget to factor in the lack of a side door meaning you will be having to pull things from the bulkhead to the rear.
Edited by Mr AJ on Tuesday 23 March 11:12
Edited by Mr AJ on Tuesday 23 March 11:14
I used to get well over 50mpg out of a Combo 1.7 DTi, although that was long distance work. I've heard bad things about the 1.3, but don't know if they were true. Also look at Berlingo / Partner with the HDi engines, I'm not sure at what point they stopped doing the 2.0 but that was a good engine, used to get around 49mpg out of that one. Avoid Kangoo unless you like bills.
I’ve had a Combo 1.7 CDTI for a couple of years now and it has been a great workhorse and very reliable. Economy doesn’t suffer too much when laden with a load (race kit including tools, jacks, wheels and tyres), does dip a wee bit though when it’s also towing a trailer plus a race car.
Might be put up for sale at some point in the very near future, so keep an eye on the PH classifieds if you are interested in an immaculate privately owned 06 Combo with side loading door.
Might be put up for sale at some point in the very near future, so keep an eye on the PH classifieds if you are interested in an immaculate privately owned 06 Combo with side loading door.
king arthur said:
Also look at Berlingo
Avoid avoid avoid. Just been given one as a replacement from the leasing company for the combo while its getting bodywork done. I've done 56 miles in it and its going back to them tomorrow. I'll try and be subjective here because it is a 56 plate and it has done a smidge under 76k. BUT horrible thing to drive, Admittedly it feels nippier than the combo did. Fuel seems to be about the same but its a real dog. Wing mirrors may aswell not exist when your on the motorway, Passenger wing mirror seems to be made from funhouse glass - any cars in it stretch out to fill the mirror and go blurry. Can't adjust it either. Gear change is sloppy, even by van standards. Terrible wind noise at anything over 50 (Admittedly it had an empty roof rack on, but it was alot noiser than the combo was doing the same journey with the nothing on the roof - Exact same roof rack too.) Interior rubbish. Heater Rubbish. Radio Rubbish. Mirrors rubbish. Loadspace rubbish. Clutch rubbish (But probably on its way out.) Oh, and the back door doesn't lock. Oh the brightside though it does seem a little nippier than the combo and roughly used the same amount of fuel i guess. Perhaps i'm being harsh on it, and will give it a proper chance tomorrow morning. But those are my opinions of it from my first trip. My father has the same opinion on them, His firm have just swapped their fleet of berlingos over to combo's for similiar reasons.Sorry to keep bumping this, but just picked up van #3 from the leasing company today and this time its a Ford Connect. To summarise my thoughts on all 3 (After taking a sleep and giving the citroen a fair run)
Combo (58 Plate 1.7 DTi) - Nice van, Comfy enough to drive. Bit noisy in the front though. Good on juice. Not blisteringly quick but will get you by. Turning circle isn't that great, and has a fair bit of body roll. Decent enough sound quality from the standard radio. Good economy aslong as you don't over-do the right foot. Over-all a good van and would defenitly put my own money down on one again.
Citreon Berlingo (1.5 Thingy-ma-boo 57 Plate) - Smallest load capacity in the back (Don't be fooled by the sliding door.) Not that pleasant to drive, Terrible road (And wind) noise in the front. Uncomfortable seating position. Terrible gear stick (Think 1995 Transit). Very poor rear visibilty. Poor sound quality from the radio. Handled better than the other two, with less body roll though. Probably good enough if your just looking for something dirt cheap. Didn't really do enough miles in it to give it a fair comparison fuel consumption wise, But i used up nearly 1/2 (Indicated) tank picking it up from the hire company and then returning it to them (Around 70-80 mile round trip) but to be fair, i was spanking it alot harder than i normally do.
Transit Connect (1.7 - 56 Plate) Roughly the same load capacity in the back, Bit more spacious in the front. Very quiet in the front compared to the other two. Slower acceleration, Driving position more like that you'd get in a bigger van. Not alot of space in the front for odd's n ends compared to the combo/Berlingo which had cavernous door pockets. Body roll/cornering not too bad, Just what you'd expect from a van really. Economy wasn't as bad as i'd been told it was going to be (I've done roughly the same MPG as i get out of the combo) Rear visibilty is alot better than the other two. Wide angle wing mirrors makes lane changes a bit more comfortable. Over-all i can't decide whether i prefer it to the combo yet, But i'm not disappointed to be paying my own money into it. Just a shame if it was red it'd look like Postman Pats van!
I'd take a Combo and a Connect out for a test drive and see which you prefer, Don't think you could go wrong with either to be honest. Hope this helps.
Combo (58 Plate 1.7 DTi) - Nice van, Comfy enough to drive. Bit noisy in the front though. Good on juice. Not blisteringly quick but will get you by. Turning circle isn't that great, and has a fair bit of body roll. Decent enough sound quality from the standard radio. Good economy aslong as you don't over-do the right foot. Over-all a good van and would defenitly put my own money down on one again.
Citreon Berlingo (1.5 Thingy-ma-boo 57 Plate) - Smallest load capacity in the back (Don't be fooled by the sliding door.) Not that pleasant to drive, Terrible road (And wind) noise in the front. Uncomfortable seating position. Terrible gear stick (Think 1995 Transit). Very poor rear visibilty. Poor sound quality from the radio. Handled better than the other two, with less body roll though. Probably good enough if your just looking for something dirt cheap. Didn't really do enough miles in it to give it a fair comparison fuel consumption wise, But i used up nearly 1/2 (Indicated) tank picking it up from the hire company and then returning it to them (Around 70-80 mile round trip) but to be fair, i was spanking it alot harder than i normally do.
Transit Connect (1.7 - 56 Plate) Roughly the same load capacity in the back, Bit more spacious in the front. Very quiet in the front compared to the other two. Slower acceleration, Driving position more like that you'd get in a bigger van. Not alot of space in the front for odd's n ends compared to the combo/Berlingo which had cavernous door pockets. Body roll/cornering not too bad, Just what you'd expect from a van really. Economy wasn't as bad as i'd been told it was going to be (I've done roughly the same MPG as i get out of the combo) Rear visibilty is alot better than the other two. Wide angle wing mirrors makes lane changes a bit more comfortable. Over-all i can't decide whether i prefer it to the combo yet, But i'm not disappointed to be paying my own money into it. Just a shame if it was red it'd look like Postman Pats van!
I'd take a Combo and a Connect out for a test drive and see which you prefer, Don't think you could go wrong with either to be honest. Hope this helps.
A couple of things to bear in mind.
What Van has a good review section.
Generally the larger the frontal area the worse mpg - particularly at higher speeds.
Cheap / french vans tend to have higher repair bills than the better / more expensive ones.
Might be worth considering an LPG van unless you need the extra torque of the diesel.
HTH
What Van has a good review section.
Generally the larger the frontal area the worse mpg - particularly at higher speeds.
Cheap / french vans tend to have higher repair bills than the better / more expensive ones.
Might be worth considering an LPG van unless you need the extra torque of the diesel.
HTH
Brite spark said:
When you say heavy load- how heavy do you mean?
just be aware that many vans won't carry heavy loads, or as heavy as you might think, rather you might risk vosa/ police weighing the van and being overloaded
Max load would be approx 600kg.just be aware that many vans won't carry heavy loads, or as heavy as you might think, rather you might risk vosa/ police weighing the van and being overloaded
out of interest, what is the overload limit? Obviously i would be sticking below it once i know what it is.
Edited by simple101 on Thursday 25th March 10:10
simple101 said:
Brite spark said:
When you say heavy load- how heavy do you mean?
just be aware that many vans won't carry heavy loads, or as heavy as you might think, rather you might risk vosa/ police weighing the van and being overloaded
Max load would be approx 600kg.just be aware that many vans won't carry heavy loads, or as heavy as you might think, rather you might risk vosa/ police weighing the van and being overloaded
out of interest, what is the overload limit? Obviously i would be sticking below it once i know what it is.
Edited by simple101 on Thursday 25th March 10:10
gross weight 2040
gross payload 648
kerb weight 1392
600 kg load + driver would be pushing it/ overweight by my understanding, but I am no expert SP&L forum might be better to ask the question as there are other weght requirements that need to be met, not just gross weight
Yeah 600kg is pushing it for a small van. Think of the plated weights as an absolute maximum rather than a typical design payload, in the same way an engines designed to rev to x k but not continuously. The old 1.7D combo I drove on the leccy board was on the load limit at 1.7t IIRC and you couldn't use 5th gear- 2 hours on the motorway in 4th, welly on the floor, on the limiter. Returned about 16mpg. Then spat it's valves out. Also don't forget the 5~0 are pretty hot on overloads these days, and it's not easy to gauge weight accurately when time's pressing. If you carry that regularly I'd be thinking of a transit/vito class van.
But if a small van it is...
The astravans a nicer drive but less practical and probably less payload- check it.
My money would go caddy first and transit connect second.
But if a small van it is...
The astravans a nicer drive but less practical and probably less payload- check it.
My money would go caddy first and transit connect second.
Gassing Station | General Gassing [Archive] | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



