RE: GM To Sue Over Rare 'Vette Replicas
RE: GM To Sue Over Rare 'Vette Replicas
Tuesday 23rd March 2010

GM To Sue Over Rare 'Vette Replicas

The General is to take Mongoose Motorsports to court over £60k Corvette Grand Sport racer reps



Proof that major corporations lack a sense of fun, especially when it comes to lucrative licensing deals. General Motors is suing Ohio-based Mongoose Motorsports for producing unlicensed replicas of the super-rare 1963 Corvette Grand Sport.

The original Grand Sport was designed as a 'Cobra killer' to compete in sports car racing. The original production run was supposed to be 125 cars, but the programme was axed after just five had been built. These now change hands for millions of dollars.

GM says that the $90,000 (£60k) Mongoose replicas have caused irreparable damage to the Corvette brand and wants to bar the company from using any Corvette labels or trademarks. It is also claiming unspecified financial damages.

Part of the problem is that Texas's Duntov Motor Co has an exclusive deal to make Grand Sport replicas - for $189,000 (£126k). But GM has also taken exception to Mongoose's use of Corvette emblems and trademarks.

For Mongoose's own part, the small print at the bottom of its website says that "it is neither inferred nor implied that any item offered by Mongoose Motorsports is a product of, authorized by or in any way connected with any vehicle manufactured by General Motors. The Trademarks Corvette, Stingray, Chevrolet, GM and the Corvette emblems are Trademarks of General Motors Corporation."

But whatever the result of the lawsuit there's no doubt that the Mongoose replica, be it illegal copy or homage (delete as appropriate), remains a pretty tasty machine, as this video (below) goes to show.

 

Author
Discussion

teen_cerbera

Original Poster:

7,927 posts

256 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
That thing looks immense!

theqtrmile

1,155 posts

281 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
To be fair to GM, if Mongoose does not hold the licence to produce the cars, then it is copyright infringement.

soad

34,759 posts

207 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
teen_cerbera said:
That thing looks immense!
It sure does.

I don't know what offcial Duntov Motor Co replicas are like at double price - but no surprise it's a messy situation over this.

Edited by soad on Tuesday 23 March 12:20

ZesPak

26,164 posts

227 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
theqtrmile said:
To be fair to GM, if Mongoose does not hold the licence to produce the cars, then it is copyright infringement.
Indeed, and as I can make out from the license is that they left the guys alone till they wanted to make money on the same thing.

paynter17

31 posts

220 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
i want i want i want i want i want i want i want i want i want i want

slipstream 1985

13,802 posts

210 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
had anyone ever heard of this before GM started complaining??? sounds more like a PR exercise to me

Mr2Mike

20,143 posts

286 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
theqtrmile said:
To be fair to GM, if Mongoose does not hold the licence to produce the cars, then it is copyright infringement.
So how do the numerous manufacturers of Lotus 7 style cars manage then?

Uhura_Fighter

7,018 posts

214 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
That is nice, I prefer Shaun Doves 63 vette though.

Shame on GM.

daveco

4,418 posts

238 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
The number they produce is extremely small and it isn't competing with any of the current Corvette range so why would they win this? It's a quality product based on a discontinued model.

PascalBuyens

2,868 posts

313 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
Someone should sue GM for trying to gain money on these guys...

Every kit car maker that ever built a replica should have a lawsuit then, if you continue that logic...

Gun

13,432 posts

249 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
Well, that's one way for GM to get some of the money they lost back.

Whitean3

2,197 posts

229 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
I don't see the problem with the small manufacturer- assuming a couple of criteria:

1) they are not using the Corvette badges if they are producing a replica; or
2) The cars they are building are already based on a Corvette- the car will still be a Corvette, just a different looking one.

Of course, there is copyright infringement if they are applying GM badges to something that is not GM.

HiRich

3,337 posts

293 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
Mr2Mike said:
[So how do the numerous manufacturers of Lotus 7 style cars manage then?
They don't. The Westfield people will tell you about the day the men from Caterham came.

DavidCane

853 posts

272 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
HiRich said:
Mr2Mike said:
[So how do the numerous manufacturers of Lotus 7 style cars manage then?
They don't. The Westfield people will tell you about the day the men from Caterham came.
Indeed, just search for Westfield Pre-Lit (as in pre litigation) for the answer.

Nickellarse

533 posts

220 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
If only 5 people own one then detracting from the brand is a pretty lame argument.

GM need every penny they can get. They should negotiate the licence and get on with their lives.

dickieandjulie

1,068 posts

288 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
I thought (rightly or wrongly) that once a car had been out of production for 10 years then anyone could produce a car looking the same albeit that they cannot use the name etc as obviously someone will own that.

Hence why there are an abundance of Cobra replica's.

fathomfive

11,259 posts

221 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
How does this all work with, say, these naff MR2 / Ferrari looky-likey kits then?

theqtrmile

1,155 posts

281 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
fathomfive said:
How does this all work with, say, these naff MR2 / Ferrari looky-likey kits then?
As i understand it, they make the body panels ever so slightly different from the original. Still very lame tho.

GIRF

32 posts

263 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
Wow.. Some of guys are missing the point.

GM sold a license to a company as they are allowed and as good business dictates.

Where upon if GM turns a blind eye to un-licensed replicas the original license they sold would be of diminished value. They would be likely in breach of contract to the first license holder for not taking steps to protect the value of the license.

Don't you think that Duntov Motor Co is getting kinda screwed here. They spent money to acquire a license legally and in good faith only to have someone else undercut them by not having to pay any license fees. If the new unlicensed company, having no contractual relationship with GM to do otherwise, should produce substantially inferior products or deal dishonestly then the value of future licenses or Grand sports is arguably diminished by the negative reputation generated by the infringe.

You lot arguing otherwise are allowing your own greed (in the form of desiring a cheaper alternative) to cloud your sense of fairness.

Mongoose’s primary problem is the use of GM badges and the Grand sport name. This is an obvious no no unless you don’t mind buying your Nike shoes and not knowing if they are cheap slave labor knock offs or the real thing. Numerous other lawsuits have been brought in the States against Kit car manufacturers. Particularly by the ever litigious Carol Shelby. BOTTOM LINE. If you market this as a Grand sport replica then you have violated the law and you get what is coming to you.

Drederick Tatum

1,033 posts

216 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
theqtrmile said:
To be fair to GM, if Mongoose does not hold the licence to produce the cars, then it is copyright infringement.
yes