Best £12k 4-Door Family Wagon with poke?
Best £12k 4-Door Family Wagon with poke?
Author
Discussion

Malcster

Original Poster:

647 posts

202 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
Moving from a Golf GDTI to something more spacious, but looking for something that still fun to drive, with a bit of poke.

Needs to be:
- Not too heavy on the sevicing and running costs.
- 4-Door or Estate.

Had considered something like the Audi S4, although maybe servicing is a little pricey? Maybe an Accord Type R? Although I have heard they are pretty tame as Type R's go?

Any other suggestions?

Thanks in advance!

Crusoe

4,126 posts

262 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
default choice would be a 330i or 330d, test drive those before you choose.

Stu R

21,701 posts

246 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
Subaru forester STI
E60 5 series touring, might just get a 525D in that price range, trifle dull.
Chrysler 300c touring - V8 engined goodness with bags of poke

Malcster

Original Poster:

647 posts

202 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
Might be worth montioning also that this will need to travel the 200miles to Aberdeen every so often... so will have to deal with rain and snow.

Should this put the RWD BMW's out the window?
(Wife will be driving it sometimes too!)

Crusoe

4,126 posts

262 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
Drive mine up here all year round, just have to take a bit more care and make sure you have plenty of tread on the tyres for winter.

RobM77

35,349 posts

265 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
Crusoe said:
Drive mine up here all year round, just have to take a bit more care and make sure you have plenty of tread on the tyres for winter.
Or winter tyres, would they help? Given that Bavaria isn't exactly devoid of snow, I'm guessing there must be a way round the problems of FE/RWD somehow.

Renn Sport

2,761 posts

240 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
Malcster said:
Might be worth montioning also that this will need to travel the 200miles to Aberdeen every so often... so will have to deal with rain and snow.

Should this put the RWD BMW's out the window?
(Wife will be driving it sometimes too!)
They are pretty sure footed cars especially in normal driving conditions for this country.

Apart from lots of snow I think its a good option. Then again you can run cold weather tyres.

Not sure if the Forester is cost effective on servicing as my WRX wasn't cheap when it came to dealer services. Perhaps because it was sports model?

Malcster

Original Poster:

647 posts

202 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
Any dissadvantages to an S4?
300BHP V6 / V8 is quite tempting...

Crusoe

4,126 posts

262 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
Malcster said:
Any dissadvantages to an S4?
300BHP V6 / V8 is quite tempting...
A bit front heavy, and high teens mpg isn't great when pushing on, average in mid 20s if you behave and don't drive it round town too much. Nice quality though and a great place to sit.

RobM77

35,349 posts

265 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
Malcster said:
Any dissadvantages to an S4?
300BHP V6 / V8 is quite tempting...
Taking into account transmission losses, you can get nearly as much power to the wheels out of the engine in a 330ci, plus instead of 15-25 mpg you'll get 30-40 mpg. Not as nice a car to spend time in though, I'd rather sit in an S4 on a long drive to Scotland. It's not an easy choice! smile

Malcster

Original Poster:

647 posts

202 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
What about a s-line A4? Decent acceleration?