140mile daily commute - I sticking with my petrol V6
Discussion
I'm an IT contractor and have just taken a new contract in Stoke (I live in West Yorks). So that equates to a 70mile drive each way. Not ideal - but the day rate is great.
anyway I currently drive a Nissan 350Z (3.5 V6). I was thinking about getting a diesel as i'll be racking up the miles but come to the conclusion there is no point. My reason being is that I dont want 2 cars, and I'm not selling my car just to save a few quid on fuel.
My car will sit at 70mph all day long doing round 30mpg, I have heated seats when its cold and can have the roof down when its warm ...and it doesn't sound like a tractor!
anyone else do length commutes with large petrol engines??
...so hopefully petrol doesn't go up in the budget or I'm f
ked!! ha ha
Adam
anyway I currently drive a Nissan 350Z (3.5 V6). I was thinking about getting a diesel as i'll be racking up the miles but come to the conclusion there is no point. My reason being is that I dont want 2 cars, and I'm not selling my car just to save a few quid on fuel.
My car will sit at 70mph all day long doing round 30mpg, I have heated seats when its cold and can have the roof down when its warm ...and it doesn't sound like a tractor!
anyone else do length commutes with large petrol engines??
...so hopefully petrol doesn't go up in the budget or I'm f
ked!! ha haAdam
I used to do Rochdale - Leeds every day (70 miles return) in my SL500, not all that far but very tedious with the traffic.
If I get another contract there I will definitely be using the train, bike or small diesel amd ;eaving the SL at home - it's a trememdous waste of money to drive something that you can't even enjoy properly. Plenty of small cars have got lots of creature comforts these days.
If I get another contract there I will definitely be using the train, bike or small diesel amd ;eaving the SL at home - it's a trememdous waste of money to drive something that you can't even enjoy properly. Plenty of small cars have got lots of creature comforts these days.
Gareth79 said:
93 gallons a month = £491. Not excessive if the rate is good. 45mpg would drop the bill to £327. Depreciation due to increased mileage and wear & trear would probably end up costing more.
Cost of fuel set to rise after the budget, but its going to be 20-odd quid a tank so not massive in the great scheme of things (but still depressing). But as mentioned, its going to be the maintenance, replacement of wear and tear parts and loss of value of the car that is going to cost more. I was told that a new car (not quite the same here) will typically lose more in value per month than you paid on a lease if you are doing 20k miles a year. Not sure if that is quite right, but it is still painful....I don't understand the pathological hatred for diesel on this site in general but the OP genuinely mystifies me.
A 140 mile daily commute and you're happy to use a 350Z? Why??
My car will sit at 70mph all day long doing round 30mpg
Good. Mine will sit at 70mph and do 55mpg
I have heated seats when its cold
Great. Diesels come with heated seats too you know.
and can have the roof down when its warm
And they come in soft-top form aswell!
and it doesn't sound like a tractor!
Really? Do modern diesels really sound like a tractor? And even if they do, do you care for the 140 mile commute you're doing?
I wonder if you'll be so happy when you're trading the Nissan in come re-sale time. Or when you've filled it up for the 3rd time in a week.
Madness. Keep the 350Z for weekends and buy a cheap Focus for the commute. Your wallet will thank you.
A 140 mile daily commute and you're happy to use a 350Z? Why??
My car will sit at 70mph all day long doing round 30mpg
Good. Mine will sit at 70mph and do 55mpg
I have heated seats when its cold
Great. Diesels come with heated seats too you know.
and can have the roof down when its warm
And they come in soft-top form aswell!
and it doesn't sound like a tractor!
Really? Do modern diesels really sound like a tractor? And even if they do, do you care for the 140 mile commute you're doing?
I wonder if you'll be so happy when you're trading the Nissan in come re-sale time. Or when you've filled it up for the 3rd time in a week.
Madness. Keep the 350Z for weekends and buy a cheap Focus for the commute. Your wallet will thank you.
Muzzer said:
Keep the 350Z for weekends and buy a cheap Focus for the commute. Your wallet will thank you.
Pointless. Another car to buy (half decent £2k,at at this price point could be a right nail with big bills around the corner), more servicing and consumables(given the mileage), TAX, MOT, INSURANCE!! Enjoy the car you have, it will take a while to get any decent savings from running a second car. Either that or lose the will to live, sell the current car and buy a dullsel.Muzzer said:
I don't understand the pathological hatred for diesel on this site in general but the OP genuinely mystifies me.
A 140 mile daily commute and you're happy to use a 350Z? Why??
My car will sit at 70mph all day long doing round 30mpg
Good. Mine will sit at 70mph and do 55mpg
I have heated seats when its cold
Great. Diesels come with heated seats too you know.
and can have the roof down when its warm
And they come in soft-top form aswell!
and it doesn't sound like a tractor!
Really? Do modern diesels really sound like a tractor? And even if they do, do you care for the 140 mile commute you're doing?
I wonder if you'll be so happy when you're trading the Nissan in come re-sale time. Or when you've filled it up for the 3rd time in a week.
Madness. Keep the 350Z for weekends and buy a cheap Focus for the commute. Your wallet will thank you.
yes but if he's an IT contractor he's probably on a very good wage and the difference saved isnt worth or a big enough proportion of his disposable income compared to the potential loss of enjoyment of getting a diesel boat.A 140 mile daily commute and you're happy to use a 350Z? Why??
My car will sit at 70mph all day long doing round 30mpg
Good. Mine will sit at 70mph and do 55mpg
I have heated seats when its cold
Great. Diesels come with heated seats too you know.
and can have the roof down when its warm
And they come in soft-top form aswell!
and it doesn't sound like a tractor!
Really? Do modern diesels really sound like a tractor? And even if they do, do you care for the 140 mile commute you're doing?
I wonder if you'll be so happy when you're trading the Nissan in come re-sale time. Or when you've filled it up for the 3rd time in a week.
Madness. Keep the 350Z for weekends and buy a cheap Focus for the commute. Your wallet will thank you.
i do the 2 car thing diesel clio and a sports car but to me the difference in running costs justifies it, however there are times i wish i was in the noble when im finished work late and want a nice drive home.
slipstream 1985 said:
i wish i was in the noble when im finished work late and want a nice drive home.
Thats a big one for me too. I only work 12 miles from home, but if I've had a stressful day then I make it a 50 mile trip home with a good hoon.Edited by Marf on Wednesday 24th March 12:40
Marf said:
Muzzer said:
Madness. Keep the 350Z for weekends and buy a cheap Focus for the commute. Your wallet will thank you.
Will it though?Would the increased MPG cover the purchase cost, insurance and wear and tear of the second diesel commuter car?
I will recoup the outlay in the first 8 months. Also I only have to go to the pumps once a fortnight now instead of weekly.
Trick is buy a cheap thow-away diesel.
ridds said:
Marf said:
Muzzer said:
Madness. Keep the 350Z for weekends and buy a cheap Focus for the commute. Your wallet will thank you.
Will it though?Would the increased MPG cover the purchase cost, insurance and wear and tear of the second diesel commuter car?
I will recoup the outlay in the first 8 months. Also I only have to go to the pumps once a fortnight now instead of weekly.
Trick is buy a cheap thow-away diesel.
If your Nissan is currently below average mileage I would run it until the mileage was higher than average but not too high to really have a terrible effect on re-sale. Sell at the right time , for the right price and replace it with whatever takes your fancy at the time ,even another 350, get a low mileage example and repeat the process.
I thought of buying a second car, but once you've factored in purchase, tax, insurance and up keep then it will cost me more than running my Zed.
Yes i know the millage will hit me when it comes to sell it. But I bought it as I enjoy driving. If I loss a few £k then so be it - least a wont be blending in with the sea of 3series and A4 diesels that populate the motorway.
Not that I wouldn't have an A4 tdi quattro, great cars, but I'm not at that stage in my life yet to give up my sporty motor just for a few quid in the bank.
Yes i know the millage will hit me when it comes to sell it. But I bought it as I enjoy driving. If I loss a few £k then so be it - least a wont be blending in with the sea of 3series and A4 diesels that populate the motorway.
Not that I wouldn't have an A4 tdi quattro, great cars, but I'm not at that stage in my life yet to give up my sporty motor just for a few quid in the bank.
infact heres some rough figures i appreciate the cars are different and running costs slightly wider appart
clio has done 12000 miles since i had it in august, 10000 of which are commuter miles
10000 miles has been 20 tanks of diesel at £50 a go so £1000
10000 miles in the noble would be 50 tanks of fuel at £50 a go so £2500
saving of £1500 in 7 months
annualised that will be arround £2250 in fuel alone
clio cost £2000 to buy and conveniently cost £250 insurance tax £35 so rather conventiently about the same as the fuel saved.
so in 1 year its paid for itself
however there is also the wear and tear costs the noble would be through 2 sets of tyres by that time the clio not even through one.
the clio has been packed to the rafters with ski gear 4 people 2 snowboards and 2 sets of ski's and been on roads the noble would never get to.
2 cars works imo if the difference between them is extreme but i dont think a 350z is extreme enough (if the extra fuel cost is neglegable compared to income) to warrent a commuter car.
clio has done 12000 miles since i had it in august, 10000 of which are commuter miles
10000 miles has been 20 tanks of diesel at £50 a go so £1000
10000 miles in the noble would be 50 tanks of fuel at £50 a go so £2500
saving of £1500 in 7 months
annualised that will be arround £2250 in fuel alone
clio cost £2000 to buy and conveniently cost £250 insurance tax £35 so rather conventiently about the same as the fuel saved.
so in 1 year its paid for itself
however there is also the wear and tear costs the noble would be through 2 sets of tyres by that time the clio not even through one.
the clio has been packed to the rafters with ski gear 4 people 2 snowboards and 2 sets of ski's and been on roads the noble would never get to.
2 cars works imo if the difference between them is extreme but i dont think a 350z is extreme enough (if the extra fuel cost is neglegable compared to income) to warrent a commuter car.
I do 100 miles a day in an S3, roughly 28-33mog depoending on my mood.
I used to have a diseasel A3 but I hated it; it so was ruddy boring. I'm currently spending £70 every 3.5 days and do you know what, I might be spending £30 more a week by having a 'fun' (I use the term looseley, it still an Audi!) car but I just couldn't care less. When the mood takes me I can go the long way home for a hoon and fun!
I used to have a diseasel A3 but I hated it; it so was ruddy boring. I'm currently spending £70 every 3.5 days and do you know what, I might be spending £30 more a week by having a 'fun' (I use the term looseley, it still an Audi!) car but I just couldn't care less. When the mood takes me I can go the long way home for a hoon and fun!
I do about 110 miles per day in a 530i (well I did until the gearbox broke.. in the meantime I am doing it in a Cerbera *grin*) I get about 30mpg too (from the BMW not the Cerb - I don't know what the Cerb does and I don't WANT to know either). I had a Polo as a daily hack before, got 50mpg out of it. Would I go back? - no way. The polo was a good car, but when you are spending 2 hours a day in a car it might as well be nice.
True my 5 isn't worth what your Z is worth, and yes you will lose money with the extra miles, but these are miles you will have enjoyed. Even having to spend £1300 fixing my car it's still worth it.
Enjoy the car and the drive and stuff the expense. You can also feel smug every time you drive past a Toyota Pious - offsetting their tiny carbon footprint - somebody has to do it.
True my 5 isn't worth what your Z is worth, and yes you will lose money with the extra miles, but these are miles you will have enjoyed. Even having to spend £1300 fixing my car it's still worth it.
Enjoy the car and the drive and stuff the expense. You can also feel smug every time you drive past a Toyota Pious - offsetting their tiny carbon footprint - somebody has to do it.
Gassing Station | General Gassing [Archive] | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


