Which Diseasel? 4 seats, 5.5k budget, cheap running costs
Which Diseasel? 4 seats, 5.5k budget, cheap running costs
Author
Discussion

Dr Bob

Original Poster:

637 posts

293 months

Thursday 25th March 2010
quotequote all
Sorry for the what car? but I need some advice, the Jag has to go (it's in the classifieds) in favour of something that's going to be cheap to run...

My initial thoughts are Ford for cheap servicing and parts, a Focus would be ideal, but a Fiesta is probably just about big enough... the 1.6 TDCi for the Fiesta and 1.8 or 2.0 for the Focus look OK on paper, but...
...is there anything obvious I've missed? Must have 4 useable seats (but rear seats mostly for kids), real world combined MPG of at least 45MPG, cheap to service, I do about 20k p.a. (mainly motorway) which includes the odd 250 mile trip, as much of a drivers car as possible (but it's obviously going to be a compromise); all for about £5500?

Looking at less than 5 years old, with reasonable miles - which seems to put anything VAG out of budget.

Let the replies of 'MX-5' and 'mapped 335d' begin.
Cheers, CH

Dr Bob

Original Poster:

637 posts

293 months

Thursday 25th March 2010
quotequote all
Cheers Boobles,

I quite like the megane, though I'm not fussed about the others too much... I'm struggling to move too far away from the aesthetic to the practical (the focus estate and mazda 2 do nothing for me I'm afraid) ...I actually like the shape of the Focus (someone has to).

Didn't think a Mazda 6 would be in budget, but have I heard horror stories about them?

What would the Megane be like? It's got 5 NCAP stars hasn't it and it's French... that's about all I know!

CH

daemon

40,169 posts

228 months

Thursday 25th March 2010
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
+1

I bought a new Passat for less than the price of a new golf.

Speaking of Passats, the new model (05 onwards) passats are creeping in at around £5.5K now. Thats where my money would be.

Dr Bob

Original Poster:

637 posts

293 months

Thursday 25th March 2010
quotequote all
Oooh Alfa - thanks Tonks! Though from what I remember reading they're neither that fuel efficient, nor cheap to run... or am I wrong? It's a good point about the Megane being French - my bosses practically new Renault was plagued with electrical gremlins.

Good point about the bigger repmobiles Daemon, though a Passat is definately out (bad associations - reason for needing to economise is impending divorce and F-I-L drives a Passat)... I quite fancy something small and fun though - hence considering the Fiesta - it's probably plenty big enough for most of what I do.

daemon

40,169 posts

228 months

Thursday 25th March 2010
quotequote all
Dr Bob said:
Oooh Alfa - thanks Tonks! Though from what I remember reading they're neither that fuel efficient, nor cheap to run... or am I wrong? It's a good point about the Megane being French - my bosses practically new Renault was plagued with electrical gremlins.

Good point about the bigger repmobiles Daemon, though a Passat is definately out (bad associations - reason for needing to economise is impending divorce and F-I-L drives a Passat)... I quite fancy something small and fun though - hence considering the Fiesta - it's probably plenty big enough for most of what I do.
I'd a 147 1.9JTD and it was reasonably good. Did very early 40s for mpg.

Dr Bob

Original Poster:

637 posts

293 months

Thursday 25th March 2010
quotequote all
daemon said:
I'd a 147 1.9JTD and it was reasonably good. Did very early 40s for mpg.
See, that's the problem, the fiesta which is a similar size promises about 50mpg in the real world and is certainly going to be cheaper to run by most other measures too...
...I might still have a quick look though!

Risotto

3,934 posts

243 months

Thursday 25th March 2010
quotequote all
Audi A2? Whether you'd be happy to do lots of motorway miles in one is up to you but they're ridiculously economical, small, cleverly packaged, hold their value well and, while not really a driver's car, they can be quite a laugh to drive. On the diesel, road tax is £35 and services (variable) are roughly a couple of hundred a pop.

There was a 90bhp diesel - whether you'd get one for £5.5k I'm not sure, but might be worth adding to your shortlist.

There's an owners club for further info.

Edited by Risotto on Thursday 25th March 09:26

dave_s13

14,031 posts

300 months

Thursday 25th March 2010
quotequote all
Dr Bob said:
Oooh Alfa - thanks Tonks! Though from what I remember reading they're neither that fuel efficient, nor cheap to run... or am I wrong?.....
Yes.

Buy mine

http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/1571756.htm

smile

All done recently.

cam belt
aux belts
tensioners
water pump
cam sensor
etc etc (see ad)

It does 43mpg for me and that's all round town. Indicated 50mpg on a run from Leeds to Liverpool.
Peach of an engine. Has a petrolesque rev range and it really rather quick!

I'm sure we could come to a deal on the price.

Edited by dave_s13 on Thursday 25th March 09:35

V88Dicky

7,373 posts

214 months

Thursday 25th March 2010
quotequote all
Are you sure you need a diesel? Here's a little diamond that meets virtually all of your criteria;


http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2010...

Seez

656 posts

211 months

Thursday 25th March 2010
quotequote all
Pissat tdi or old Skoda Superb tdi, there really is NO other choice for heavy motorway work!

Dr Bob

Original Poster:

637 posts

293 months

Thursday 25th March 2010
quotequote all
dave_s13 said:
Dave, only if you buy mine http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/1582911.htm!

I'll have a look at the Skoda (Skodas, Skodae?)... wife was adamant she wouldn't have a Skoda, but that's all a bit by-the-by now! CH

Edited by Dr Bob on Thursday 25th March 10:05

Kenny-Mack

197 posts

227 months

Thursday 25th March 2010
quotequote all
Audi A3 TDi 1.9 110HP? lots of space and goes well, built pretty well too.

I have one for my day to day grind and cannot believe how good the fuel economy is on it!

getting no less than 530miles to a tank costs about £50-55 to fill up, at todays fuel prices that is still very good economy

ETA - you might not get one less than 5 with low miles but it will still feel newer than a 5 year old french car (IMO)

Edited by Kenny-Mack on Thursday 25th March 10:02

Dr Bob

Original Poster:

637 posts

293 months

Thursday 25th March 2010
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
Hmmm, I had a 9-3 (2001 Aero) which I really liked... might still fail on the cheap to run criteria though - even going to indies if something needed doing it wasn't 'Ford' cheap!

CH

Dr Bob

Original Poster:

637 posts

293 months

Thursday 25th March 2010
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
Ha ha, yeah, that's pretty much what I'd say 'possibly... but probably not'.
To be fair, I bought mine at 65k, and ran it 'til 135k over 5 years and it didn't cost me too much (only major things were the DI unit (warranty), a/c compressor at about 90k, and clutch at about 120k), but toward the end I was getting very paranoid about the potential for a major bill. In hindsight, I should have run it for a bit longer... but myeh, then I'd never have bought that luverly Jag would I?!

entwisi

728 posts

222 months

Thursday 25th March 2010
quotequote all
How about an Accord CDTI? plenty at that price range, choice of saloon/tourer on your view of practicality, comfy, good build quality, easy 45mpg, mappable to 180bhp/300ftlb. decent looker etc

Humpy D

658 posts

226 months

Thursday 25th March 2010
quotequote all
Dr Bob, my last car was an old style Fiesta Zetec S 1.6 tdci. Really liked the car. Was getting mid 50s mpg (mainly motorway driving) and as it was the Zetec S it handled pretty well too.

The car I had before that was a Megane 1.5 dci. Had it from new, did 60k miles in it and it didn't let me down once. Don't be put off by the fact that it's only a 1.5 either A very good motorway car - it would easily sit at 80 all day. Plus the fuel consumption was an indicated 60mpg+. I'd certainly have another.

Dr Bob

Original Poster:

637 posts

293 months

Thursday 25th March 2010
quotequote all
Thanks Humpy, valuable info... looking at prices I'd still go for a Fiesta over a Megane, just because everything I see in the price range has done a few miles and I'm still of the opinion that a Fiesta is going to be cheaper to maintain in the long run than the Megane

anonymous said:
[redacted]
Good point Tonker - I think that the standard temp differential between passenger and driver used to be about 4 degrees... still,having single zone a/c could mean I get my own personal t_t monday whenever I feel like it!

CH

Dr Bob

Original Poster:

637 posts

293 months

Thursday 25th March 2010
quotequote all
Well a quick trawl threw this up, this looks OK:
Audi A3

Anything I should watch out for? 8 valve engine/100bhp - I guess that's why they are boringly reliable and efficient?

CH

convert

3,757 posts

249 months

Thursday 25th March 2010
quotequote all
My experience of small diesels is limited to the A2 (Wife's car), which over the past 4 years has, other than regular servicing, cost us a couple of front springs and top mounts.

Other than that my dad's had a 1.4Tdci Fiesta for about the same length of time, other than routine servicing it's needed injector seals repalcing (a couple of hundred quid).


Both pull well, but the Fiesta is a little low rent inside, although it does have a/c and leccy windows. The Audi is a much nicer place to be, and is a little better on diesel.