260 mile commute: am I nuts?
260 mile commute: am I nuts?
Author
Discussion

JumboBeef

Original Poster:

3,772 posts

208 months

Thursday 25th March 2010
quotequote all
I am looking at transferring within the company I work for, to a base 130 miles away (just about all motorway). The problem is I like where I live, and not where the new base is! (but it is a very good career move).

As I work 12 hour shifts, I would need to be there 3 times per week for two weeks, and 4 times on the third week (on average).

I currently drive a Disco V8, on LPG. Travel expenses would be my own.

I can't work out whether to drive as required, use the Disco or buy something cheaper as well (don't really care what, as long as it has cruise), or stay there in a B&B.

Am I nuts to even consider a 260 mile round trip, on top of working 12 hour shifts (which will also include driving)?

Rawwr

22,722 posts

265 months

Thursday 25th March 2010
quotequote all
Well, I wouldn't.

Rawwr

22,722 posts

265 months

Thursday 25th March 2010
quotequote all
I should probably expand on that smile

130 miles is going to be covered in bang-on 2 hours, I imagine. That's 2 hours of your life that you could be sat at home, covered in jelly and masturbating. I damn well know what I'd rather do.

sday12

5,068 posts

242 months

Thursday 25th March 2010
quotequote all
Now that would be silly wouldn't it?

Mag1calTrev0r

6,481 posts

260 months

Thursday 25th March 2010
quotequote all
I'd be extremely worried about working a 12 hour day and then travelling 4 hours (average speed of 60mph ish). Or rather 2 hours travel, 12 hours work, 2 hours travel.
What if you have a bad nights sleep and feel tired. You'll fall asleep at the wheel, especially if you get used to the journey and 'switch off'.

Is the career move worth more than your life?

Could you get a room in shared professional house a couple of nights a week? Share with a colleague at the new office? If somebody at the new office has a spare room then they might appreciate the company for a couple of nights a week in exchange for a bit of beer money? Ok, you'll be away from your family (?) but then you'd be away permanently if you crash and die.

Sorry for being so morbid but you're crazy to consider driving.

Neil1300R

5,785 posts

209 months

Thursday 25th March 2010
quotequote all
Depends on how good a career move it is!

If its that good and works out, then look to move nearer to work in 6 months or so
Distance isn't so much the issue as time - although its mainly motorway, how busy is it during commuting hours. Much over 2 hours becomes a real drag, especially early in the morning in the winter

HellDiver

5,708 posts

213 months

Thursday 25th March 2010
quotequote all
JumboBeef said:
Am I nuts to even consider a 260 mile round trip, on top of working 12 hour shifts (which will also include driving)?
Yes. Rent a flat nearby. I've done 2 hours each way on top of an 8 hour shift, and I could only stick it for 18 months. I was in my early 20's. I wouldn't even entertain it now, for any money. Life is way too short to be getting up, driving 2 hours, working, driving another 2 hours, eating (reheated) dinner, going to bed.

patmahe

5,924 posts

235 months

Thursday 25th March 2010
quotequote all
Why not move somewhere closer to the new job, I know you like your current area but frankly you won't see it much with that commute. There must be somewhere nice you could live thats less than 130 miles away from work.

off_again

13,917 posts

265 months

Thursday 25th March 2010
quotequote all
B&B it. I know a few people who have done this and it works out better. Focus on the days that you can work and put the time and effort in on the days away. Then when you are back home, focus on you, your family and what you want to do - Get the balance right and its fantastic. 4 hours a day stuck in a car sounds like my vision of hell. Sorry.

Speedracer329

1,507 posts

208 months

Thursday 25th March 2010
quotequote all
I did just over half that (85 mls each way) for two years, mostly motorways. It was ok, but it was a good job I was a manager, as the number of times I was stuck in accidents that made me late was frightening, often with no alternative of getting off & finding another route. Same thing would often happen on the way home, so what should have been an hour & a half each way was often three hours, which makes a huge difference. Think if I were you I would rent.

PHmember

2,487 posts

202 months

Thursday 25th March 2010
quotequote all
How is the week structured? Are your three shifts running on consecutive days? or is it more like one day, one day off?

If you can work three shifts on three consecutive days then you can cut your commute by 2/3 & perhaps stay in a cheap B&B for two nights. Would that work out cheaper than doing the same commute 3 or 4 times a week?

skoff

1,387 posts

265 months

Thursday 25th March 2010
quotequote all
I've done the long commute thing into central London. Managed about 3 years, it affected my health and my general well being. One day I got into the office after a bad journey and just walked into my bosses office and quit there and then. BIG surprise for them as I was doing well at the firm and apparently was about to be made a partner. BUT I had had enough, they could have offered me the world on a stick and I wouldn't have stayed, so it ended up not being a career at all.

You might be different, but 4 hours travelling a day equals an extra shift every 3 shifts you do. Is it really that good a career move? Brings your hourly rate down a bit looking at it that way.

Dapster

9,609 posts

211 months

Thursday 25th March 2010
quotequote all
Is driving your only option?

I leave the house at 7, grab a coffee at the station, catch the 7:35 London to Leeds train and am at my desk by 9:45 having done a few hours work on the train. I grab the 16:40 on the way back and am home in time to read the kids their story. Everyone's a winner. A season ticket plus taxis works out cheaper than a weekly return plus a few nights in a hotel.

If I dont work on the train, I can watch iPlayer, read the paper or just get some zzzzz's. Driving 260 miles a day, every day is mental.

Bluebarge

4,519 posts

209 months

Thursday 25th March 2010
quotequote all
For the 3 day week, 2 nights B&B will save you 520 miles worth of fuel, wear and tear and increased servicing costs, and, more importantly, wear and tear on you, so it probably pays for itself, and some.

You will have no home life after an 18 hour day at the office/wheel, so there is no real difference in you being away.

Plus I think 2 hours for 130 miles at commuting times is v.optimistic.

If the new job is a success, I would think about relocation.

zcacogp

11,239 posts

275 months

Thursday 25th March 2010
quotequote all
I met a nice chap the other day who worked for Mercedes in Stuttgart, and lived just over 120 miles away.

He commuted that every day. Reckoned it took him a little under an hour, door-to-door. In his work-provided car (S-class.)

Yes, I did type that correctly. Yes, it did make me realise (afresh) just how crappy the road transport system in this country is.


Oli.

Liokault

2,837 posts

245 months

Thursday 25th March 2010
quotequote all
I was looking at a 139 mile (each way) commute, did it once and book a hotel room!

With no traffic and almost all on Mway its 2.30 hours.

tim2100

6,288 posts

288 months

Thursday 25th March 2010
quotequote all
If it is a good career move, then take it but B&B it. If it was all week then i would say no, but for 3 days per week i would B&B it.

260 mile commute is NOT do-able day in day out 5days per week. I do 130 mile daily commute, i really wouldn't want to do any more.

a cheap B&B will be cheaper than the fuel & running costs. Chuck in a curry & some beers and each night is sorted!

richardxjr

7,561 posts

241 months

Thursday 25th March 2010
quotequote all
I spent 4 years doing half that mileage, but twas in the SE so took 2 hours each way, in a fully expensed (& taxed) co. car.

It damn near nearly killed me many times. Drifting off, knackered, the route was too familiar. Leaving home at 7 getting back at 7.30, Mon to Fri.

Still, much better than living in SE London biggrin

clarkey

1,430 posts

315 months

Thursday 25th March 2010
quotequote all
It's only 3 times a week, and only 8 hour shifts. If it's worth it in the long run, I'd do it. I average 1000 miles a week and work good hours (usually), you get used to it before long.

snotrag

15,748 posts

242 months

Thursday 25th March 2010
quotequote all
Gaz. said:
Inbetween shifts it's going to leave you just 8 hours,
Exactly - think of it that way. Its utter madness.

I will never understand people who have these monster commutes.

Even what Dapster has said back there - that is waaaay too much time out of the day to be at, or travelling to/form work.

Theres so, so much to go wrong with a 260mile commute.

You'll be putting an extra 13k miles a year on your car. Thats going to cost £££. The chances are it could have some serious affects on your health and mental state. No job promotion is worth that. Your social life will suffer. Even the fact that you have the 5th day off - you'll be cream crackered after 4 days of that.

Work to live guys.