Another one of those 'Hmmm, what car?!' thread
Discussion
Hello people
Great website this, been browsing on it for years and have finally plucked up the courage to join.
I need your help, pretty much as the title says really. Am definately going to change my car in the next 4 months and am saving the pennies for a new 'un. Have a budget of about £4000, and am 24, looking for the following:-
1) Reliability
2) Speed
3) Economy (30mpg and over will do)
4) Handling
5) Comfort
I've so far owned Hondas so am spoilt by the ownership experience, as in zilch faults; but do fancy a change. I have a shortlist as follows-
Mercedes 190
Mercedes W124
Mercedes W202, either the c230 kompressor or c250td
Lexus LS400
Honda Accord Type R (this is a strong contender)
As you can see I am leaning towards a classicish kinda car and that is what my heart really wants, but am frightened at the long term reliability prospects; as I plan to keep the car for 3 years. I love the idea of having the Type R but am thinking need a change and would like to change to another brand as you only live once.
What are your thoughts guys? Or do you have any other/better suggestions?

Great website this, been browsing on it for years and have finally plucked up the courage to join.
I need your help, pretty much as the title says really. Am definately going to change my car in the next 4 months and am saving the pennies for a new 'un. Have a budget of about £4000, and am 24, looking for the following:-
1) Reliability
2) Speed
3) Economy (30mpg and over will do)
4) Handling
5) Comfort
I've so far owned Hondas so am spoilt by the ownership experience, as in zilch faults; but do fancy a change. I have a shortlist as follows-
Mercedes 190
Mercedes W124
Mercedes W202, either the c230 kompressor or c250td
Lexus LS400
Honda Accord Type R (this is a strong contender)
As you can see I am leaning towards a classicish kinda car and that is what my heart really wants, but am frightened at the long term reliability prospects; as I plan to keep the car for 3 years. I love the idea of having the Type R but am thinking need a change and would like to change to another brand as you only live once.
What are your thoughts guys? Or do you have any other/better suggestions?
OK, if you've got £4k to spend and want to see that £4k again, or perhaps even more, then you need to act fast - get yourself a Mercedes-Benz 190E 2.3-16v Cosworth. You can pick up a decent one for £4k now, but you can bet they'll go up in value over the next few years.
The other one on your list that struck me was the W124. Another good 'banker' as long as it isn't rusting, specified in bright red, or fitted with chrome wheelarch rims and dodgy AMG alloys. The convertibles have hardly depreciated at all, so you can bet a convertible (if you can find one at that price) or a decent 300CE-24v coupe will be a good car.
Try www.lancaster-ins.co.uk or comparethemarket.com for insurance quotes. You might be surprised how cheap they come up.
The other one on your list that struck me was the W124. Another good 'banker' as long as it isn't rusting, specified in bright red, or fitted with chrome wheelarch rims and dodgy AMG alloys. The convertibles have hardly depreciated at all, so you can bet a convertible (if you can find one at that price) or a decent 300CE-24v coupe will be a good car.
Try www.lancaster-ins.co.uk or comparethemarket.com for insurance quotes. You might be surprised how cheap they come up.
mwahahaha said:
Sound advice, I should have mentioned I only have one years ncb, and insurance can be a bit pricey shall we say. How reliable are these old Mercs?
More reliable than some of the newer ones.I insured a Porsche 924 with no NCB through Lancaster for less than £700 pa when I was younger than you are now. The W124s are largely in lower insurance groups than the Porsche - try Lancaster's 'Quick Quote' - you might be pleasently surprised.
Gassing Station | General Gassing [Archive] | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


