When did LR release the Td5? Is it any good?
When did LR release the Td5? Is it any good?
Author
Discussion

eltax91

Original Poster:

10,791 posts

237 months

Saturday 27th March 2010
quotequote all
As title really. Looking at Disco's and among all the 200/ 300 TDi's that came up in my budget one Td5 came up - i'm weary as it's a bit cheap, but what year was it released and how would anyone rate it against the olde TDi lumps from LR?

BLUETHUNDER

7,881 posts

291 months

Saturday 27th March 2010
quotequote all
They are a good engine. Early ones had head trouble. And some issues with electronics. But most,if not all have been by cured now. They were launched with the launch of the Discovery 2 in 1998.They can adapt well to mods. Chipping larger intercoolers etc. More refined than the 200-300tdi.

Cyberprog

2,326 posts

214 months

Sunday 28th March 2010
quotequote all
Yep, solid engine, tuneable upto about 200bhp without major changes (other than intercooler), and you can get a bit more than that with the new hybrid turbo's that are on the market now too.

thinfourth2

32,414 posts

235 months

Sunday 28th March 2010
quotequote all
BLUETHUNDER said:
They are a good engine. Early ones had head trouble. And some issues with electronics. But most,if not all have been by cured now. They were launched with the launch of the Discovery 2 in 1998.They can adapt well to mods. Chipping larger intercoolers etc. More refined than the 200-300tdi.
Never heard of head trouble but heard of them dropping the drive off the oil pump and the engine going nuclear. But only early ones but it should of been modded by now.

What to look for is oil working its was along the loom from the engine to the ECU and eventually killing the ECU.

So do a google for TD5 oil ECU and see what comes up.


BLUETHUNDER

7,881 posts

291 months

Sunday 28th March 2010
quotequote all
thinfourth2 said:
BLUETHUNDER said:
They are a good engine. Early ones had head trouble. And some issues with electronics. But most,if not all have been by cured now. They were launched with the launch of the Discovery 2 in 1998.They can adapt well to mods. Chipping larger intercoolers etc. More refined than the 200-300tdi.
Never heard of head trouble but heard of them dropping the drive off the oil pump and the engine going nuclear. But only early ones but it should of been modded by now.

What to look for is oil working its was along the loom from the engine to the ECU and eventually killing the ECU.

So do a google for TD5 oil ECU and see what comes up.
Very early ones suffered head trouble.

v1paul

723 posts

207 months

Sunday 28th March 2010
quotequote all
From reading about defenders, I think the tdi engines are more reliable and they're easier/cheaper to repair. The TD5's are slightly more refined and quicker but they're more expensive to repair and service etc.