Really don't know what car to get!
Really don't know what car to get!
Author
Discussion

granty88

Original Poster:

10 posts

197 months

Wednesday 12th May 2010
quotequote all
Hi,

So I currently own a MK1 Ford Focus RS which when purchased I was doing minimal mileage and was able to afford.

However, my photography has taken a turn for the better and I am clocking up more mileage now. To summise if I go to the Peak District its between 80-100 mile round trip, I do this once/twice a week. Lakes/Wales are between 300-350 miles round trip. I'd be doing this once/twice a month (knock a peaks trip off if I do this).

This all starts adding up, especially as I go walking in the Peaks/Lakes/Wales also.

I get about 22mpg normal driving style with a couple of trips to the Peaks included in that...so thats 230 miles roughly per tank. If I go to the Lakes I get 33mpg and this equates to 350miles per tank. At £63 per tank on super unleaded its not good.

All the above has made me decide I need to sell just so I can get out more, which the RS is stopping me doing.

I have been looking at replacement cars but just so unsure what to get. Given the above mileage I am looking to do plus odd trips to Scotland diesel is screaming at me, but all I read is horror stories with new engines.

I personally don't mind diesels, used to own a Ford Focus 1.8TDCI and while having the RS spent 2 months in a 308 HDI which did 600 miles to a tank on a heavy foot when commuting.

So far I've been looking at Mazda 6's but hear their diesel engines are pretty much the worst out there. So what I started looking at next was a Vauxhall Signum with a 1.9 cdti 150bhp. They're nice and roomy (i'm 6ft7), they can carry all my walking gear and others if people go with me. I can chuck a push bike in the back easily etc etc, this car just seems to say buy me! But I'm worried that it'll be costly to repair.

Does anyone have any suggestions as to what car I can get for about 6k (i'm lowering what I spend on a car) and fors and against diesel for me personally (i've read all the other posts and googled!!). From what I've read, anything common rail can and more than likely go wrong. However for the size of car I wish to get I don't see petrol being viable.

As for repair costs...I have an RS....wear and tear isn't that cheap either so I'm used to it!



Thanks,

Granty

maccas99

1,847 posts

218 months

Wednesday 12th May 2010
quotequote all
http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/1658787.htm

Preferably the facelift on an 05 - I can vouch for them, I like mine...

Kevin VRs

13,851 posts

310 months

Wednesday 12th May 2010
quotequote all
Best bet would be a VW group product. If size is not a problem then a Fabia vRS would be good, quick for a diesel, 50 mpg and quite fun too. If bigger then Golf GT Tdi may be better.

MoonMonkey

2,341 posts

243 months

Wednesday 12th May 2010
quotequote all
Something from the VAG range with the 130 PD motor. Sounds like you need a hatchback so consider Leon Cupra, Octavia (hatch / estate), possibly an Audi A4 Avant

mugs

146 posts

240 months

Wednesday 12th May 2010
quotequote all
Skoda Octavia. The estate would make most sense and for your money you should be able to get a facelift which is (I think) based on the Golf mk5 chassis which is perfectly fine in itself, but obviously very tweakable if you're not averse to modifications. If you go for something with the 1.9 it won't be very refined but it should last forever if cared for.

tim2100

6,288 posts

287 months

Wednesday 12th May 2010
quotequote all
What budget are you spending?

granty88 said:
So far I've been looking at Mazda 6's but hear their diesel engines are pretty much the worst out there. So what I started looking at next was a Vauxhall Signum with a 1.9 cdti 150bhp.
I have quote this bit as I currently drive a '58 plate Mazda 6 2.0 diesel, and had before a Vectra 1.9CDTI 150bhp

The Mazda6 diesel is a cracking motor, although not particularly economical but then it is dragging round a big heavy car. It does go pretty well. Fast driving average around 42mpg. Can get above 50mpg if very gently.

I had a Vectra a few years ago. Again cracking motor, and responded very well to a Tuning box. Very quick, pretty frugal, although when on Forum's it did seem after high mileage the bills started mounting.

Haven't got a tuning box yet for the Mazda as they are about £350 currently.

AMST09

570 posts

210 months

Wednesday 12th May 2010
quotequote all
I'm looking to sell up my RS as well, I understand how much they cost
Was looking at getting hte 1.8TDCI you said you had
Without taking over your topic too much how did you find it?

granty88

Original Poster:

10 posts

197 months

Wednesday 12th May 2010
quotequote all
Glad im not the only one considering it!

It was fine when I had it, felt quick etc etc - never really had any problems with it. Only reason I don't want another one is I don't want to be a Focus man all my life!

Thanks for all the advice guys! I'm still liking the idea of a Signum!