Would I be mad to swap my car for a scooter?
Would I be mad to swap my car for a scooter?
Author
Discussion

dpbird90

Original Poster:

5,535 posts

220 months

Tuesday 25th May 2010
quotequote all
Before the automatic PH "yes" answer comes in, hear me out. I'm a student, 20 years old, 3 years car NCB. Not driven my car for nearly a year due to the massive cost of keeping it at halls of residence (weekly parking charges > weekly fuel cost) but am going to need my own transportation for second year, as our new house is 3.5 miles away from the University (before you ask why, we couldn't find anywhere close to our uni with an HMO, weird but true. Its right next to RGU which is OK for my mate's girlfriend, but bad for me and him, who are at Aberdeen Uni). Anyway, it'd take us just over an hour to walk, which means leaving at 7:30am to make it in for morning lectures. The bus is marginally quicker, bit oweing to recent experiences, I'd rather remove my own testicles in a vice than take public transport. So the realistic option is to bring my car up. Not any hassle with the insurance, it'll be fully paid for, and our house has a garage which is always a good thing.
But recently, I've been attracted to old scooters. Yes, its partly due to my love of Quadrophenia, great album and a great movie, but somehow I'm almost able to justify it. It'd be half as much in insurance costs, running costs will probably be much cheaper, and if I sold my car to get one, I'd have some spare cash left over for a classic mini project. The only downsides I can see are I would only do the CBT, so my friend wouldn't be able to get a ride into uni with me, I don't suppose I could fit a weekly shop on the back, and seeing as its a 500 mile trip to home, I don't think a scooter would be much fun.

However, I'm kinda tempted by one of the below, buy it, spend a few quid sticking the mod mirrors on it and I can live out my Quadrophenia fantasies, only Aberdeen beach is a fair bit colder than Brighton.
http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/1553754.htm
http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/1735662.htm

bks, just thought; am I right in thinking that because the Lambretta is actually a 150cc, I couldn't ride it with a CBT? If so this Vespa wouldn't be much good either, despite being much cheaper so I'd have money left over for mirrors etc http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/1738411.htm

james_gt3rs

4,816 posts

221 months

Tuesday 25th May 2010
quotequote all
I'd take the car definitely. Those scooters are bloody expensive too!

The Wookie

14,209 posts

258 months

Tuesday 25th May 2010
quotequote all
You could always get a bike

justin a

21 posts

197 months

Tuesday 25th May 2010
quotequote all
i would say no mate ,for a few reasons,you cant take anyone around with you,they are awful to ride in crap/cold/wet weather and unless you have real good wet weather gear you will get wet somewhere on your body,they are prone to being pinched and easy to take,why dont you get good push bike and cycle when its nice weather and maybe cadge a lift or go on bus when its cold.also old lambrettas always need fixing my uncle had one and it was in bits more than on the road.

sjg

7,682 posts

295 months

Tuesday 25th May 2010
quotequote all
Get a pushbike. Way easier to lock to something solid, thus a much higher chance of it being there when you get back.

dougc

8,241 posts

295 months

Tuesday 25th May 2010
quotequote all

soad

34,697 posts

206 months

Tuesday 25th May 2010
quotequote all
Keep the car and buy a bicycle - it'll keep you fit too.

R11ysf

1,968 posts

212 months

Tuesday 25th May 2010
quotequote all
Aberdeen + January morning lecture = snow.
Snow + scooter = bad experiences and a hefty price to fix your quadrophenia scooter.

MGZRod

8,176 posts

206 months

Tuesday 25th May 2010
quotequote all
R11ysf said:
Aberdeen + January morning lecture = snow.
Snow + scooter = bad experiences and a hefty price to fix your quadrophenia scooter.
The roads round here werent too bad when we had very very heavy snow depending on traffic, just a bit skitey and affffa nippy.

Rusty Arches

694 posts

203 months

Tuesday 25th May 2010
quotequote all
3.5 miles.

Save the cash while you're a student. Bus, bike or walk.

anonymous-user

84 months

Tuesday 25th May 2010
quotequote all
I'm in a similar position to you, my house is about 4 miles away from my uni.
All of the people in my house, including me, had cars until last term when one of them had to get rid of his. I drive in every day, but when we have differant scheduals and cant get a lift (3-4 days a week) he rides his peddle bike. Its fine now the weather is good, but it was a pain in the arse for him when it was raining or freezing cold.

I also had a 50cc scrambler when I was 16, although it was good transport at the time I could never live without the practicality of a car now.

Stick with the car, its not worth the hassel having the bike. Bikes need more regular servicing, are cold in winter, give you hat hair, you can take mates anywhere and you cant take them to the supermarket.

Edited by anonymous-user on Tuesday 25th May 18:24

balders118

5,941 posts

198 months

Tuesday 25th May 2010
quotequote all
The Wookie said:
You could always get a bike
+1. My halls were 4 miles from Uni. I had a motorbike for a while and, well, lets say motorbikes and idiot drivers in the city don't mix for too long. Rest of the year I cycled.. easy!!


v8will

3,310 posts

226 months

Tuesday 25th May 2010
quotequote all
Honda CG125

Problem sorted and you'll not be a big girls blouse cos it's got proper gears

Killer2005

20,615 posts

258 months

Tuesday 25th May 2010
quotequote all

james_gt3rs

4,816 posts

221 months

Tuesday 25th May 2010
quotequote all
rofl love the Sniff petrol pictures!