maney miles Sporty diesel hatch mpg
maney miles Sporty diesel hatch mpg
Author
Discussion

steve1968

Original Poster:

401 posts

290 months

Monday 7th June 2010
quotequote all
Thinking of changing my m3 for something a bit cheaper to run.
Question is , what do people REALLY get from the a sporty diesel 120 ,A3 , golf etc

briers

873 posts

209 months

Monday 7th June 2010
quotequote all
If your talking about the 170 bhp models then low 40's if you include town driving and shorter trips. Sometimes even high 30s. More on longer runs. Say mid 40s. Even nudging 50 on some journeys but not over a tank.

Ry_B

2,256 posts

231 months

Monday 7th June 2010
quotequote all
VX220 turbo, speed, cheap to fix and run with economy all in one.

HellDiver

5,708 posts

212 months

Tuesday 8th June 2010
quotequote all
I got 43mpg from my Astra Sporthatch 1.9-150, remapped to 200hp. 0-60 in sub-8, top speed over 141mph.

I got 44mpg from my Lancer diesel (140hp), remapped to 170hp. Not as quick top speed as the Astra, but off the line was similar. Liked the car a lot, but suspension was like driving with scaffold poles as shocks.

kiethton

14,656 posts

210 months

Tuesday 8th June 2010
quotequote all
I have the 1.7 astra sporthatch......not exactly sporty mind but have been getting an average of 54ish for the past few tanks. Even with more town driving the worst i seem to get is 48.

HellDiver

5,708 posts

212 months

Tuesday 8th June 2010
quotequote all
kiethton said:
I have the 1.7 astra sporthatch......exact opposite to sporty
EFA.

Moley RUFC

3,672 posts

219 months

Tuesday 8th June 2010
quotequote all
I'm just about to change my Leon FR diesel for a new Octy vRS due to a second child coming. The Leon has been a fantastic car for all it's 90k miles I have racked up in it. Also not since my Mini Cooper have I had the desire to get into a car on a sunny Sunday to go for a spin, especially with it being a company car!

Interior is cack, no question but I have enjoyed my time with it

Moley RUFC

3,672 posts

219 months

Tuesday 8th June 2010
quotequote all
Moley RUFC said:
I'm just about to change my Leon FR diesel for a new Octy vRS due to a second child coming. The Leon has been a fantastic car for all it's 90k miles I have racked up in it. Also not since my Mini Cooper have I had the desire to get into a car on a sunny Sunday to go for a spin, especially with it being a company car! It is however a 5 door but looks hatchback enough with it's Alfa hidden rear handles

Interior is cack, no question but I have enjoyed my time with it

entwisi

728 posts

221 months

Tuesday 8th June 2010
quotequote all
I have had to fall back to an Accord CDTI, 2.2 does 46/7 at 80-85 and heavy right foot(air con off), never below 35 even in mega slow town work

MIssus has 1.9 Astra TD ( 57 plate) thats currently averaging < 20 mpg around town (according to offcial figs, should be 29)

Teh Astra is a st hole to drive, the Honda almost pleasureable ( I come from 155 TS, Saab 9000, V70T5 and A8 4.2 QS ) its never going to be a tarmac ripper but generally its OK adn mappable to 180 for 200 notes

NiceCupOfTea

25,595 posts

281 months

Tuesday 8th June 2010
quotequote all
entwisi said:
MIssus has 1.9 Astra TD ( 57 plate) thats currently averaging < 20 mpg around town (according to offcial figs, should be 29)
What!?

The Wookie

14,209 posts

258 months

Tuesday 8th June 2010
quotequote all
I've averaged 44mpg out of my 123d with a mix of local driving, a few thrashes and a couple of long motorway trips at PH'er acceptable speeds in the two weeks I've had it.

It's a great everyday car... assuming you don't need a big boot.

Edited by The Wookie on Tuesday 8th June 23:01

cptsideways

13,886 posts

282 months

Wednesday 9th June 2010
quotequote all
Our (not so sporting) 130 PD Golf Estate averaged 48mpg over the weekend on a 1600 mile round trip to the far side of Germany & back, cruised at 100mph for most of the way in Germany & 80mph everywhere else. Same engine as the early GTI 130 PD's

It rarely does less than 50mpg in normal driving

nottyash

4,671 posts

225 months

Wednesday 9th June 2010
quotequote all
Sold my 54 plate e46M3 last year now have a Diesel Almera!! Only bought last week.
I am toying with the idea of a new Skoda Octavia VRS 170 PDI, but only as I can get a massive discount on a brand new one, I mean less than 16K!!
I bought a Fabia VRS new and remapped it to about 190bhp, I really regret selling it.banghead

My average MPG in a remapped VRS Fabia on motorway runs was 46MPG, and that wasnt hanging around!!

Edited by nottyash on Wednesday 9th June 01:12

entwisi

728 posts

221 months

Wednesday 9th June 2010
quotequote all
NiceCupOfTea said:
entwisi said:
MIssus has 1.9 Astra TD ( 57 plate) thats currently averaging < 20 mpg around town (according to official figs, should be 29)
What!?
I did ask if she had been lending it out to Button as his daily driver....

They replaced the EGR about 12 months ago and its never run right since, even motorway cruising at 75 only gives 42-45 and she isn't heavy footed at all. The heater takes > 30 mins to warm up and compared to the Honda I have the power is like driving a 2 stroke 250 with a powerband about as wide as a fly's nadger.

apart from that its full of blind spots, the seats are rubbish ( I have a broken back and can't get comfy in it at all), the paint is soft as butter and teh interior plastics are cheap and nasty. Worst bit is its listed at 19545 with 189 CO2 so costs her 5500 on tax. The new Astra 2.0d saloon would be 5000 and the 1.6 petrol VVT is 3450. Hopefully they will let her get teh 1.6 VVT when its up for renewal in Jan.

HellDiver

5,708 posts

212 months

Wednesday 9th June 2010
quotequote all
entwisi said:
They replaced the EGR about 12 months ago and its never run right since, even motorway cruising at 75 only gives 42-45 and she isn't heavy footed at all. The heater takes > 30 mins to warm up and compared to the Honda I have the power is like driving a 2 stroke 250 with a powerband about as wide as a fly's nadger.

apart from that its full of blind spots, the seats are rubbish ( I have a broken back and can't get comfy in it at all), the paint is soft as butter and teh interior plastics are cheap and nasty. Worst bit is its listed at 19545 with 189 CO2 so costs her 5500 on tax. The new Astra 2.0d saloon would be 5000 and the 1.6 petrol VVT is 3450. Hopefully they will let her get teh 1.6 VVT when its up for renewal in Jan.
I got similar on the motorway with my 1.9 Astra (it was a 55 plater 150hp Design, mapped to 200hp). Round town didn't reduce the fuel economy by much at all, certainly not sub 20's.

Agreed about the seats, lack of vision, crap paint. Some mug paid £22k for mine when it was new. I got it 2 years old for £8k. Only kept it for 8 months, couldn't hack it at all. The 1.8 Vectra SRI was a huge upgrade, much, much better car.

chillo

725 posts

252 months

Wednesday 9th June 2010
quotequote all
My missus just paid £8.5k for a black A3 1.9tdi (105bhp) sport, 3door, bose, 07 reg 80k miles but feels like 15k miles, 1 company owner.

On the 100 mile drive home she averaged 53mpg doing 80-85

Bargain if you ask me!