bloody confused dot com
Author
Discussion

Atomic Gibbon

Original Poster:

13,018 posts

216 months

Tuesday 13th July 2010
quotequote all
Just spent time checking insurance quotes to try to help decide between one car and another for my next purchase.
Details in etc, quote for 3.2 2005 boxster, value 22k - 1300 quid pa, 3k excess. Sounds a bit daft excess I think, but the 600 quid excess range is asking 2k a year!
So I tried a 3.6 2003 carrera cab. Exactly the same quotes. Must be the soft top bit, I think.
Tried 3.6 2003 carrera coupe Strangely, all the quotes are the same again.
Tried putting in a garage. Exactly the same quotes.
Tried a 996 turbo, exactly the same quotes.
Tried valuing a GT2, valued at 60k, exactly the same quote.

WTF are these quotes based on? It can't be engine size, car value, wether it's garaged or not, wether it's a drop top, anything.

Been driving since 1999, never had a claim, always held insurance over this time - so i'm guessing it can't be me personally that's the issue?

scorcher

4,126 posts

264 months

Tuesday 13th July 2010
quotequote all
The quotes are based on people willing to pay whatever insurance companies think they can get away with quoting on price comparison sites.Do some homework,select a few companies with decent feedback from customers on forums,and ring them.Chances are you'll get a better deal.

jondude

2,441 posts

247 months

Tuesday 13th July 2010
quotequote all
I'd use all the search sites...gocompare, moneysupermarket etc. I received quotes from £150 -£1100 for my Lotus Elise.

Naturally, I will take the £150 one, knowing there is no way they will keep near this price at renewal - this price is to get me on the books, the £1100 one is a chancer, that maybe I am one of those people who believe I must be getting a better deal because it is so expensive.

It is all but a game.

homerjay

1,249 posts

255 months

Tuesday 13th July 2010
quotequote all
jondude said:
I'd use all the search sites...gocompare, moneysupermarket etc. I received quotes from £150 -£1100 for my Lotus Elise.

Naturally, I will take the £150 one, knowing there is no way they will keep near this price at renewal - this price is to get me on the books, the £1100 one is a chancer, that maybe I am one of those people who believe I must be getting a better deal because it is so expensive.

It is all but a game.
£150???

who is that with?

Atomic Gibbon

Original Poster:

13,018 posts

216 months

Tuesday 13th July 2010
quotequote all
Jesus. Comparethemeerkat, exactly the same prices, from the same list.
It hurts me to do it, but time to try the piss boiling fat man advert's wares...

Jasandjules

72,607 posts

259 months

Tuesday 13th July 2010
quotequote all
Can be easier to call a broker and get them to do the leg work.

Chas88

630 posts

196 months

Tuesday 13th July 2010
quotequote all
When I tried confused.com I tried a few different variants and I somehow managed to end up getting higher quotes for Third Party than Fully Comp. rolleyes

Atomic Gibbon

Original Poster:

13,018 posts

216 months

Tuesday 13th July 2010
quotequote all
Well, it looks like that excersise was a waste of time =(
All the comparison sites no help whatsoever, I'll ring flux tomorrow and get them to quote me for a few options, and go from there.

I still think it;s strange these sites are not reflecting what I have asked them to quote, I'm not miffed at the non-desirable quotes, it;s more that they don't change when the car changes, or the value changes, or wether it is garaged or not changes.

It's almost like the only universal constant is me as a driver, and third party risk. However, why would that be high, I've got 9 years no claims, ffs!

eldar

25,291 posts

226 months

Tuesday 13th July 2010
quotequote all
Just been looking at them now, as I've just received my renewal. Probably save me £25 quid on a £300 renewal. Pity you can't shop around for VED, that costs me more than insurance.

jondude

2,441 posts

247 months

Tuesday 13th July 2010
quotequote all
homerjay said:
jondude said:
I'd use all the search sites...gocompare, moneysupermarket etc. I received quotes from £150 -£1100 for my Lotus Elise.

Naturally, I will take the £150 one, knowing there is no way they will keep near this price at renewal - this price is to get me on the books, the £1100 one is a chancer, that maybe I am one of those people who believe I must be getting a better deal because it is so expensive.

It is all but a game.
£150???

who is that with?
Someone called 'Sureterm Direct'. (Through go compare) Mind you, I am low risk, garage and countryside postcode, 8 years NCD, 42 and I can put a lady on the policy, too. She knocked £30 off the premium!!

Endlsleigh were next best at £200. Both with £250 excess, fully comp. Can't complain.

  • * ah yes, another thing, I probably have the only unmodified Elise in the country, even down to the orginal Pioneer cassette - insurers love unmodified cars ****
Edited by jondude on Tuesday 13th July 21:22

Dog Star

17,609 posts

198 months

Tuesday 13th July 2010
quotequote all
I've just had my renewal through from Adrian Flux - it's up a negligable amount (about 20 quid to the mid 500s for a group 50 5 litre V8) and they much better than anyone else. Not only that it's a policy with a "quality" underwriter (not "Aggamemnon at Lloyds" or somesuch), no daft conditions, unlimited mileage etc. Oh and a PH discount wink (the young lady on the phone was referring to an "owners club" - I assume this must be PH which I got a discount for last year).