What car didn't live up to your expectations?
What car didn't live up to your expectations?
Author
Discussion

Section 8

Original Poster:

545 posts

219 months

Friday 23rd July 2010
quotequote all
Firtly this isn't a pop at Vauxhall owners as i'm fond of their current sporting models.I have been looking at midsize hot hatches and i had settled on a Mkv Golf GTI after a test drive. The golf was as quick as i expected..progressive in a smooth and unagressive manner,no drama.I supose as a refined gti should be. Today when passing the local Nissan dealer i spied an Astra VXR and i nipped in and i managed to wangle a test drive as soon as the salesman walked upto me.

Now i have watched and read a lot of reviews on the VXR and always wanted a try. In my mind it was going to be a bit of a monster (well for a FWD hatch). The salesman was in short..a sodding lunatic and nice chap asking me as soon as the road was clear to open it up and give it the beans.I duly obliged...and my dream of the VXR was pretty much shattered. It was brisk..but not a patch on what i would have thought.

I just expected a huge turbo shove in the guts and it never materialisd. I really thought 237 bhp in an astra would FEEL more urgent and akin to old school turbo hatches.

Has anyone else driven a car that they liked the look of or read lots about and it just felt deflating when behind the wheel be it in performance and/or handling?

focusboy

274 posts

220 months

Friday 23rd July 2010
quotequote all
Suburu Impreza sti wrx

David87

7,025 posts

242 months

Friday 23rd July 2010
quotequote all
I had a go in a TVR Sagaris and found it curiously lacklustre in performance. Granted, it was quick enough, but it didn't feel all that much faster than an E46 M3, for instance.

Pugland53

574 posts

200 months

Friday 23rd July 2010
quotequote all
I don't know what you were expecting from the Astra but I had one when they first came out and I thought it pulled quite well, certainly faster than Golf GTI/Civic Type R/Focus ST etc.

MonkeyBusiness

4,246 posts

217 months

Friday 23rd July 2010
quotequote all
My Saab 9-3 Tid.
It is a nice car, all the toys, nice to drive (especially with the remap), comfy, looks good (imo) but the niggly build quality lets it down such as the gear knob popping off (today).

I desparately want to like it but I won't miss it when it's gone. Maybe jumping from a supercharged MX5 didn't help.

nobodyknows

12,336 posts

199 months

Friday 23rd July 2010
quotequote all
Nissan 200SX (the 1st one), worst car I've ever owned, horrible bloody thing. Golf Gti Mk5 until I got used to it & learned to appreciate its many qualities. Also test drove an AM V8 Vantage 4.3 & was surprised that it didn't feel that quick - still a gorgeous car though but I'll have the V12 please!

pilchardthecat

7,483 posts

209 months

Friday 23rd July 2010
quotequote all
The 135i/335i - both of which are all mid range and disappointingly flat at the top.

Relentless like a very powerful diesel, with a nicer noise, but not anywhere near as much fun as i'd hoped.

MEATANDCHEESE

409 posts

197 months

Friday 23rd July 2010
quotequote all
Audi RS4 Avant (2000)

Very very quick no doubt about it but it was an effortless and numb feeling car.

You really had to be going some to get the thrill.

I traded a BMW X5 4.4i Sport and it was one of the only trade in regrets I had.

Thing is if I still owned that car today I would be truly happy with it's residuals.

FreeLitres

6,128 posts

207 months

Friday 23rd July 2010
quotequote all
I have a feeling that this thread is going to upset some people!

robemcdonald

10,010 posts

226 months

Friday 23rd July 2010
quotequote all
^^^I know what you mean about the 200sx I had one and had nothing but trouble with it.
That aside the biggest disapointment was a mini cooper S. I got one of the first back in July 2002. I never really got on with it and I found the engine pretty awful. I only kept it for a year.

LuS1fer

43,517 posts

275 months

Friday 23rd July 2010
quotequote all
Cortina Mk II 1600GT and E.

Tsippy

15,078 posts

199 months

Friday 23rd July 2010
quotequote all
VW Golf Mk IV 2.0 GTi

It was so slow, handled like a barge in the Atlantic and drank the fuel.... build quality was good though!

I changed it a month later.

goldblum

10,272 posts

197 months

Friday 23rd July 2010
quotequote all
Golf VR6

Powerband pointlessly high,and when you got the needle there the bloody wheels span

and you stayed still.Terrible handling as well.

BMW E46 M3

Not enough power in the dry or torque around town.

Lethal in the wet,so for much of the year little more than a comfy seat.

Actually as I recall it was quite good at fast cross country-ers.

Rossay

122 posts

198 months

Friday 23rd July 2010
quotequote all
Gallardo. Thought it would feel different to the way it did, Just didnt 'do it' if you get me.

Drove a DB9 and was very suprised by how unboring it felt.

Pferdestarke

7,192 posts

217 months

Friday 23rd July 2010
quotequote all
TT 3.2v6. Too composed and at the time i described it as playstation like meaning it was just too easy to keep it nailed with no worry about anything happening. Sounded nice though

yazza54

20,331 posts

211 months

Friday 23rd July 2010
quotequote all
Drove a Ferrari 430 paddleshift and was disappointed. Too much like playstation for me. Rather have a manual. Drove a manual porsche gayman the same day and actually preferred the gayman, just because I felt more in touch with the car.

runboy

244 posts

211 months

Friday 23rd July 2010
quotequote all
Had an Astra for a week - 59 reg so not the latest model but still a "new" car. 1.8 petrol auto Elite. Fairly well equipped, but it felt so "agricultural". Rattles from the dash, front washer pipes badly routed so they knocked around the engine bay when operated, auto gearbox was a bit rough, seats felt like sitting on granite, took ages to kick down.

OK, so this isn't a BMW, but the Astra has been around long enough and Vauxhall R&D department should have had long enough to "polish" the thing a bit more.

Bonefish Blues

36,563 posts

253 months

Saturday 24th July 2010
quotequote all
330D Touring - no discernible character, just totally competent.

rex

2,067 posts

296 months

Saturday 24th July 2010
quotequote all
May get flamed for this but drove a 355 and just did not live up to expectations. Quick but not "wow thats amazing" and expected more feel as a driving car. Covered a few hundred miles in it but never quite 'got it' as I hoped I would.

On the other hand I would post in a thread about cars that surprised you, the NSX was just fabulous.

Flintstone

8,644 posts

277 months

Saturday 24th July 2010
quotequote all
LuS1fer said:
Cortina Mk II 1600GT and E.
When though? In their day or recently?