Charged for rebalancing tyres when swapping wheels
Charged for rebalancing tyres when swapping wheels
Author
Discussion

Gareth79

Original Poster:

9,036 posts

275 months

Saturday 21st August 2010
quotequote all
Hi all,

I replaced my front tyres recently (K11 Micra), I chose a very large place near Winchester/Basingstoke. I agreed a price over the phone because the price they quoted was higher than some of the online people, and they were ordered in (slightly odd size).

Anyway, arrived and confirmed that I wanted the rears moved to the front, and the new ones on the rear (presumably nearly all FWD cars have this), although the rears are under 10k old so it wouldn't have made much difference really. I went in to pay (while they were being fitted) and apparently you get charged for *four* sets of balancing (at £5.50 each), so the total was £11 more than I was quoted.

I queried this, apparently "they need rebalancing because the tyres change as they wear". I said that I doubt they needed anything changing since they were relatively new and seem fine, and he agreed that they would just "spin them up and check". Lo and behold, they were fine and they refunded the £11.

I am wondering if correctly balanced wheels ever really need rebalancing over their life? I have never been charged like this before, although I can't remember if they checked the balancing on the wheels being swapped last time.



Edited by Gareth79 on Saturday 21st August 18:11

crackedfinger

1,569 posts

258 months

Saturday 21st August 2010
quotequote all
Gareth79 said:
Hi all,

I replaced my front tyres recently (K11 Micra), I chose a very large place near Winchester/Basingstoke. I agreed a price over the phone because the price they quoted was higher than some of the online people, and they were ordered in (slightly odd size).

Anyway, arrived and confirmed that I wanted the rears moved to the front, and the new ones on the rear (presumably nearly all FWD cars have this), although the rears are under 10k old so it wouldn't have made much difference really. I went in to pay (while they were being fitted) and apparently you get charged for *four* sets of balancing (at £5.50 each), so the total was £11 more than I was quoted.

I queried this, apparently "they need rebalancing because the tyres change as they wear". I said that I doubt they needed anything changing since they were relatively new and seem fine, and he agreed that they would just "spin them up and check". Lo and behold, they were fine and they refunded the £11.

I am wondering if correctly balanced wheels ever really need rebalancing over their life? I have never been charged like this before, although I can't remember if they checked the balancing on the wheels being swapped last time.



Edited by Gareth79 on Saturday 21st August 18:11
Assuming the tyre wasn't removed from the hub, unless you've reported a judder/ issue, I would not expect wheels to need rebalancing when swapping the wheel about.

bazking69

8,620 posts

219 months

Saturday 21st August 2010
quotequote all
Opportunist profiteering. Unless there were signs of uneven wear between axles rebalancing would never even be a consideration.

Drive Blind

5,774 posts

206 months

Saturday 21st August 2010
quotequote all
Gareth79 said:
I am wondering if correctly balanced wheels ever really need rebalancing over their life?
In my experience cheap tyres can go out of balance during their lifetime. I have also seen tyre places struggle to balance cheap tyres.

Never had any issues with decent, so called 'premium' tyres.

Papa Hotel

12,760 posts

211 months

Saturday 21st August 2010
quotequote all
I'd imagine that you would know if your wheels needed balancing... They'd soon let you know.

Trying their luck, probably pays off 95% of the time, people don't know better and pay up.

Gareth79

Original Poster:

9,036 posts

275 months

Saturday 21st August 2010
quotequote all
Drive Blind said:
In my experience cheap tyres can go out of balance during their lifetime. I have also seen tyre places struggle to balance cheap tyres.

Never had any issues with decent, so called 'premium' tyres.
Yeah, they were Falken Ziex 912's, so not cheapies.

LeoSayer

7,826 posts

273 months

Saturday 21st August 2010
quotequote all
I have occasionally needed to get existing wheels re balanced after using them for a while. Only because I started to get some vibration though. No need to do it otherwise.

henrycrun

2,473 posts

269 months

Saturday 21st August 2010
quotequote all
Only if the balance wights get thrown (very rare)

Chapppers

4,483 posts

220 months

Saturday 21st August 2010
quotequote all
...because the other 9 out of 10 people he's done that to wouldn't have questioned it. £99 profit.

Dunk76

4,350 posts

243 months

Saturday 21st August 2010
quotequote all
Well, yes they do, as it happens...

I used to have to get the Alpina and 328i wheels rebalanced frequently during the life of the tyres.

Seems to be a problem when the wheels are very light - BBS in both cases of the above

Rich_W

12,548 posts

241 months

Saturday 21st August 2010
quotequote all
It's possible because obviously as the tyre wears away part of its tread it changes overall weight slightly.

HOWEVER.

Might have been nice to be given the option before they just did it.