All the car you need?
Author
Discussion

ehyouwhat

Original Poster:

4,606 posts

247 months

Sunday 29th August 2010
quotequote all
Irrespective of price, what car would satisfy all of your requirements?

I've pondered this question on a number of occasions, wondering just how little an 'ideal' car could cost. To use my own experiences as examples, I used to own an E46 M3 and I found it a great allrounder. It has four comfy seats, plenty of toys, good build quality, as much performance as I would ever need, and half-decent running costs (25mpg average fuel consumption, fair priced servicing, no expensive faults). It cost me around £17k at about five years old, and I think it represented great value for money...it was as much car as I would ever need.

Then I think on and remember a friend used to own a Renault Clio 172. He bought it from a main dealer as an ex-demo car, with a couple of thousand miles on the clock, for £10k. It was a highly capable car and would often surprise much more expensive machinery in performance stakes. Whilst it suffered from typical french build quality, nothing major ever went wrong with it (and the bits that did go wrong were always covered under warranty). It could seat four in comfort, had a decent boot, and even had styling that I would call 'nice' (subjective I know). I drove it on a number of occasions and I found it a great little car, in many ways better than the much more expensive MINI Cooper S JCW that I had at the time.

So for you, what car would satisfy all the requirements you have?

Tonberry

2,295 posts

221 months

Sunday 29th August 2010
quotequote all
E39 530i/d

Edited by Tonberry on Sunday 29th August 19:32

robsco

7,875 posts

205 months

Sunday 29th August 2010
quotequote all
A 156 GTA, probably the Sportwagon if it needs to be practical. All the power most people will ever need, Italian design & character, and powered by one of the all time great production car engines.

daemon

40,169 posts

226 months

Sunday 29th August 2010
quotequote all
535d M Sport Touring.

Economy
Power
Lots of room
Estate for the two retrievers and dump runs

... just bought a Xsara VTS, so somewhat short of the ideal at the moment...

Edited by daemon on Sunday 29th August 19:34

Luke.

11,996 posts

279 months

Sunday 29th August 2010
quotequote all
Audi s4 Avant at the mo. But I reserve the right to change my mind on a whim.

ewenm

28,506 posts

274 months

Sunday 29th August 2010
quotequote all
There is no one car that would satisfy all my requirements.

Jem0911

4,415 posts

230 months

Sunday 29th August 2010
quotequote all
Supercharged Full Fat Holland & Holland Range Rover.
Or Maybe
A G55 Right hand drive.

vit4

3,507 posts

199 months

Sunday 29th August 2010
quotequote all
Subaru Legacy GT-B Estate/Mitsubishi Legnum VR4 estate. Massive boot which is needed, comfortable over distance and if you don't hoon them will get almost average fuel economy.

Oh, and they go like st off a shovel by most standards hehe

Edited by vit4 on Sunday 29th August 19:44

harryowl

1,114 posts

210 months

Sunday 29th August 2010
quotequote all
caterham

ewenm

28,506 posts

274 months

Sunday 29th August 2010
quotequote all
harryowl said:
caterham
Fits most of my requirements apart from the "carrying the baby around" one.

OllieWinchester

5,700 posts

221 months

Monday 30th August 2010
quotequote all
TDV8 Autobiography, if I absolutely had to have one car to do everything in, for ever.



All your saloon car choices are good, but what happens come the apocalypse?

va1o

16,113 posts

236 months

Monday 30th August 2010
quotequote all
BMW 330d (E90 lci nerd)

- Economical
- Fast
- Practical
- Handles well
- Looks smart
- Cheap to tax

Edited by va1o on Monday 30th August 11:58

ShadownINja

80,055 posts

311 months

Monday 30th August 2010
quotequote all
OllieWinchester said:
All your saloon car choices are good, but what happens come the apocalypse?
He'd be limited to driving on broken up tarmac like you. Or does the RR come with 14" steel wheels and off-road tyres?

Edited by ShadownINja on Monday 30th August 12:01

Animal

5,667 posts

297 months

Monday 30th August 2010
quotequote all
Ferrari Enzo. I want to meet the apocalypse quickly and with plenty of sturm und drang.

ali355

397 posts

200 months

Monday 30th August 2010
quotequote all
X350 shape Jag XJR. In black. Big wafty cruiser for when you are not in the mood, and a supercharged 400 bhp beast when you are!

andy43

13,192 posts

283 months

Monday 30th August 2010
quotequote all
ewenm said:
There is no one car that would satisfy all my requirements.
This.
Builders merchant trip last week for 200 bricks/roof-down sunny day wasting petrol/snow and ice run for food/long haul visiting family.
That's three cars there at least smile

bikemonster

1,188 posts

270 months

Monday 30th August 2010
quotequote all
Two seater
Space for 5 adults
Convertible
Must be able to take roofrack
Light weight
Able to venture off road on occasion
Must wear sticky rubber for track days (where I expect it to destroy more expensive machinery)
Petrol engine for performance
Diesel engine for economy
Cheap to run

I haven't found one such vehicle yet, but I refuse to give up!

chevy-stu

5,392 posts

257 months

Monday 30th August 2010
quotequote all
vit4 said:
Subaru Legacy GT-B Estate/Mitsubishi Legnum VR4 estate. Massive boot which is needed, comfortable over distance and if you don't hoon them will get almost average fuel economy.

Oh, and they go like st off a shovel by most standards hehe

Edited by vit4 on Sunday 29th August 19:44
I'm on a 2nd VR4 Legnum at the moment, and while it is great for most things, and usually quick enough, it isn't exiting to drive, but I've a V8 toy too ...

Can't think of any car I've driven that could be genuinely seat of the pants exciting/involving, yet comfortable and easy to drive/roomy/practical etc.. at the same time...

RB26DETT

2,519 posts

204 months

Monday 30th August 2010
quotequote all
Nissan Stagea with an R35 front end and an RB26DETT cloud9

torres del paine

1,588 posts

250 months

Monday 30th August 2010
quotequote all
This in black.

They look ace too.

daemon said:
535d M Sport Touring.

Economy
Power
Lots of room
Estate for the two retrievers and dump runs

... just bought a Xsara VTS, so somewhat short of the ideal at the moment...

Edited by daemon on Sunday 29th August 19:34