Your £15k three car garage - there is a criteria
Your £15k three car garage - there is a criteria
Author
Discussion

Matt UK

Original Poster:

18,084 posts

229 months

Monday 13th September 2010
quotequote all
So, you have £15k to spread across 3 cars.

You are choosing to spend less than you could, so insurance, tax, servicing and mpg are not massive concerns, but can't be too silly either. You'll hold on to them for a while, so standing the test of time is more important than residual values down the line.

Car 1 - used for 20,000 business miles a year and needs to look sort of 'professional' in the eyes of the masses and customers. Must be enjoyable to drive as lots of time spent in it.

Car 2 - used for carting kids around, domestic duties, dump runs and B&Q, holidays to Europe. Key prioities are tough enough to withstand abuse, safe, and ultra reliable so the important people are not calling you from a hard shoulder on a wet Thurday November evening. Must be big enough for camping type stuff, bit small enough for the good lady to man-handle around a multi-story carpark.

Car 3 - kept in the garage and used only occasionally. Must be fun, able to enjoy some track use, be different. Will get abused and then put away agin so needs to be mechanically tough - it's got to be ready for whenever you want to use it, not always waiting for you to ;attend to it's fragile needs'. Being easy to work on yourself is a plus.

I'm going through this now so will update one element of the fleet, you can have a guess at which one if you like!

What do you pick and why?

eta - you don't really like diesel much and have yet to find one that was better than the equivalent petrol.

Edited by Matt UK on Monday 13th September 15:43

kambites

71,460 posts

250 months

Monday 13th September 2010
quotequote all
Can car-2 be car-1 plus a trailer for the tip duties? That'd be my approach.

papabear

14,232 posts

223 months

Monday 13th September 2010
quotequote all
320D
T5 Estate
190 2.5 cosworth

Bullett

11,175 posts

213 months

Monday 13th September 2010
quotequote all
Car 1+2 = the same. Skoda

Car 3 = Cateham

Ok slightly over budget, but you get the idea.

varsas

4,075 posts

231 months

Monday 13th September 2010
quotequote all
1. BMW E46 diesel £5k
2. Honda FRV or similar, whatever you can get for £4k
3. Honda S2000 (£6k, if that's not enough then an RX8)

Not too bad a list, but you are missing a classic and a 4x4 (I like doing off roading events) which could both be fixed by spending £2k on a series III LR.

Bill

58,633 posts

284 months

Monday 13th September 2010
quotequote all
I'm not convinced you've got enough money to do all three, so I'd spend £10k on a 530 or a Legacy (and a non-age-related plate) and £5k on an MX5+FI.

fido

18,885 posts

284 months

Monday 13th September 2010
quotequote all
1. M5 E39
2. Accord Estate
3. Porsche 944S2/968, S2000, or one of those kit-car things ..

Edited by fido on Monday 13th September 15:31

TommyBuoy

1,298 posts

196 months

Monday 13th September 2010
quotequote all
fido said:
1. M5 E39
2. Accord Estate
3. Porsche 944S2/968, S2000, or one of those kit-car things ..

Edited by fido on Monday 13th September 15:31
Links and I will buy all three!


G_T

16,163 posts

219 months

Monday 13th September 2010
quotequote all
1) Jaguar 3.2 V8 XJ - Non-German, lovely place to sit, reliable, V8 and reasonable economy.

2) I'm afraid I can't suggest better than an old volvo estate for this.

3) Fisher Fury Fireblade (or similar).


Speed addicted

6,329 posts

256 months

Monday 13th September 2010
quotequote all
Matt UK said:
So, you have £15 to spread across 3 cars.
Are we buying model ones?

The Lukas

2,773 posts

223 months

Monday 13th September 2010
quotequote all
1) BMW 328i Sport 4k
2) A trailer 0.5k
3) TVR Chimarea 10.5k

thumbup

fido

18,885 posts

284 months

Monday 13th September 2010
quotequote all
TommyBuoy said:
Links and I will buy all three!
Do you own homework! Okay, the M5 is pretty variable but you can get one for £8k or thereabouts. Honda Accord Tourer - i like the 2.4 but easier to find a high-mileage 2.0 diesel for around £3k. Erm, admitedly it might be difficult to find that S2000 for £4k, but i'm sure you can find a CAT C/D import .. that's why i included the 944S2 as an alternative.

Edited by fido on Monday 13th September 15:39

Kentish

15,169 posts

263 months

Monday 13th September 2010
quotequote all
BMW e39 535i (with non-age related plate) £3k.

BMW e39 525i Touring £2.5k, or an old LR series 3 £2.5k.

Porsche 911 Turbo (circa 1985) £9.5k.



300bhp/ton

41,030 posts

219 months

Monday 13th September 2010
quotequote all
Matt UK said:
So, you have £15 to spread across 3 cars.

You are choosing to spend less than you could, so insurance, tax, servicing and mpg are not massive concerns, but can't be too silly either. You'll hold on to them for a while, so standing the test of time is more important than residual values down the line.

Car 1 - used for 20,000 business miles a year and needs to look sort of 'professional' in the eyes of the masses and customers. Must be enjoyable to drive as lots of time spent in it.

Car 2 - used for carting kids around, domestic duties, dump runs and B&Q, holidays to Europe. Key prioities are tough enough to withstand abuse, safe, and ultra reliable so the important people are not calling you from a hard shoulder on a wet Thurday November evening. Must be big enough for camping type stuff, bit small enough for the good lady to man-handle around a multi-story carpark.

Car 3 - kept in the garage and used only occasionally. Must be fun, able to enjoy some track use, be different. Will get abused and then put away agin so needs to be mechanically tough - it's got to be ready for whenever you want to use it, not always waiting for you to ;attend to it's fragile needs'. Being easy to work on yourself is a plus.

I'm going through this now so will update one element of the fleet, you can have a guess at which one if you like!

What do you pick and why?

eta - you don't really like diesel much and have yet to find one that was better than the equivalent petrol.

Edited by Matt UK on Monday 13th September 15:21
If its business miles do you get an expense claim of fuel allowance?

Also I personal believe it's total bull all this "image" for customers sake. It's total bks. Drive what you like, it's hardly likely to truly affect any business outcome. If it's oddball or different it's more likely to be a talking point than a negative. A generic Audi/BMW will only pigeon hole you as a or tit and evidently making enough money to spend it on a perceived flashy car, even if it's a base model.


Still thinking on the cars though.

CampDavid

9,145 posts

227 months

Monday 13th September 2010
quotequote all
Kentish said:
BMW e39 535i (with non-age related plate) £3k.

BMW e39 525i Touring £2.5k, or an old LR series 3 £2.5k.

Porsche 911 Turbo (circa 1985) £9.5k.
Pretty much with you on the first two, though you have absolutely no chance of getting into a 911 Turbo which won't immediately die on track for that sort of cash

Gad-Westy

16,568 posts

242 months

Monday 13th September 2010
quotequote all
TommyBuoy said:
fido said:
1. M5 E39
2. Accord Estate
3. Porsche 944S2/968, S2000, or one of those kit-car things ..

Edited by fido on Monday 13th September 15:31
Links and I will buy all three!
I think its feasible to get slightly ropey examples of all of those for £15k.

M5 - £8500 (though 20k miles per year is going to cost!)
Accord - £2000 for something usable
944 - £4500 Not going to be mint but should get something that could be TLC'd back to it's former glory. 968 would be out of the question though.

mr_tony

6,351 posts

298 months

Monday 13th September 2010
quotequote all
15k as a deposit on a 996GT2 for 45k - this is 1 and 3.
Rent the garage out to someone (250 a month) to help make the monthly payments on the 996.

The mrs and kids will be happy to take the bus safe in the knowledge that they are saving the planet. We will now be poor, so holidaying in the UK is the only option anyway.

Or if I'm being serious

1. Old XJ JAg - 1000 quid.
2. Old Volvo V70 T5 - 4500 quid
3. 205 GTi with a cage - 1000 quid

8500 quid for repairs and spares over the next 3 years, well it's an old jag isn't it...



Edited by mr_tony on Monday 13th September 15:56

Kentish

15,169 posts

263 months

Monday 13th September 2010
quotequote all
CampDavid said:
Kentish said:
BMW e39 535i (with non-age related plate) £3k.

BMW e39 525i Touring £2.5k, or an old LR series 3 £2.5k.

Porsche 911 Turbo (circa 1985) £9.5k.
Pretty much with you on the first two, though you have absolutely no chance of getting into a 911 Turbo which won't immediately die on track for that sort of cash
I was eyeballing a nice 1984 911T at a garage the other day for £10.5k - reckon a hard haggle could just about get it on budget.

Stu R

21,638 posts

244 months

Monday 13th September 2010
quotequote all
BMW E38 740i or a Jag XJR
Nissan Patrol
Spend the rest on an E36 beemer and a few cheap upgrades.

SC7

1,882 posts

210 months

Monday 13th September 2010
quotequote all
I'd have two E39s as car 1 and 2: A 530i Sport saloon, and a 530d Sport touring.

Then probably a stripped out E36 M3.


Edit - I kinda put them all at the same value (5k each). If they're variable I'd have a £9-10k M5, an E34 touring (1500 quid-ish), and again the E36 M3.

Edited by SC7 on Monday 13th September 16:02