Sensible car or sporty car?
Sensible car or sporty car?
Author
Discussion

T84

Original Poster:

6,941 posts

223 months

Wednesday 22nd September 2010
quotequote all
Does anyone get conflicted between the two?

"Oh, I'll just get something normal to run for a few years and save money while I build up some NCB"

"Hmm, actually, maybe I should just spend a little bit extra and get something with a bit more grunt"

"Actually, I have a fast motorbike anyway so surely running two fast vehicles will cost a fortune"

ARGH!

volumeone

321 posts

193 months

Wednesday 22nd September 2010
quotequote all
Everyone does.

You just have to buy two cars and it solves the problem... which I am in the process of doing right now. Getting a cheap BMW 3-series as a runnabout and maybe a MR2 for a sporty drive. The MR2 is weak juice, but for £5-6k you can get a low-mileage car, with hardtop, leather, and heated glass window.

T84

Original Poster:

6,941 posts

223 months

Wednesday 22nd September 2010
quotequote all
True, I have a motorbike as my 'fun' though so I think I may be greedy getting a fast car too smile

twazzock

1,930 posts

198 months

Wednesday 22nd September 2010
quotequote all
T84 said:
Does anyone get conflicted between the two?

"Oh, I'll just get something normal to run for a few years and save money while I build up some NCB"

"Hmm, actually, maybe I should just spend a little bit extra and get something with a bit more grunt"
yes

Currently somewhat torn between a nice sensible super-cheap Pug 106 diesel or a Mk1 MX5.

Edited by twazzock on Wednesday 22 September 15:58

Mr Roper

14,232 posts

223 months

Wednesday 22nd September 2010
quotequote all
T84 said:
Does anyone get conflicted between the two?

"Oh, I'll just get something normal to run for a few years and save money while I build up some NCB"

"Hmm, actually, maybe I should just spend a little bit extra and get something with a bit more grunt"

"Actually, I have a fast motorbike anyway so surely running two fast vehicles will cost a fortune"

ARGH!
It's all about circumstance, if you want it and can afford it you will, if you want it but can't afford you'll find a way. And the bike scenario? Two totally different experiences unless your talking about keeping an R1 and an Atom

T84

Original Poster:

6,941 posts

223 months

Wednesday 22nd September 2010
quotequote all
Well I'm torn between getting a Diesel Accord/Focus/Mondeo or an ST220... Insurance is a massive problem for me at the moment though until I can jump ship on providers in December...

Mr E

23,040 posts

288 months

Wednesday 22nd September 2010
quotequote all
volumeone said:
Everyone does.

You just have to buy two cars and it solves the problem...
Snap. Elise + Barge

mullerrice18

200 posts

218 months

Wednesday 22nd September 2010
quotequote all
Same problem mate

Should I buy the sensible little 1.1 shopping cart and build up my no claims or should I buy that nice seat ibiza fr and be raped by the insurance?

Its 50/50 at the minute

PaulHogan

7,552 posts

307 months

Wednesday 22nd September 2010
quotequote all
Mr E said:
volumeone said:
Everyone does.

You just have to buy two cars and it solves the problem...
Snap. Elise + Barge
Double snap. Elise + CaymanS + Barge

Mr E

23,040 posts

288 months

Wednesday 22nd September 2010
quotequote all
PaulHogan said:
Mr E said:
volumeone said:
Everyone does.

You just have to buy two cars and it solves the problem...
Snap. Elise + Barge
Double snap. Elise + CaymanS + Barge
That's cheating. smile

T84

Original Poster:

6,941 posts

223 months

Wednesday 22nd September 2010
quotequote all
mullerrice18 said:
Same problem mate

Should I buy the sensible little 1.1 shopping cart and build up my no claims or should I buy that nice seat ibiza fr and be raped by the insurance?

Its 50/50 at the minute
Hmm, I'm thinking of building up the NCB, I really like the look of the newer shape Accords as well.

I know, I'm disgusting, sorry boxedin

otolith

68,728 posts

233 months

Wednesday 22nd September 2010
quotequote all
PaulHogan said:
Mr E said:
volumeone said:
Everyone does.

You just have to buy two cars and it solves the problem...
Snap. Elise + Barge
Double snap. Elise + CaymanS + Barge
Economy snap. Elise + 350Z + barge

volumeone

321 posts

193 months

Wednesday 22nd September 2010
quotequote all
If you're only deciding between two relatively crappy cars e.g. Pug 106 and Ibiza FR then just get an older version of the car you really want and insure it third-party until you build up NCB.


ShadownINja

80,032 posts

311 months

Wednesday 22nd September 2010
quotequote all
I think getting something that's only slightly better than what you would get if you were sensible is a waste of time as you'll still get rid of it ASAP and get the properly sporty car in the end.

patmahe

5,919 posts

233 months

Wednesday 22nd September 2010
quotequote all
volumeone said:
You just have to buy two cars and it solves the problem...
Speaking as a guy who has owned two cars for a number of years, the problem with it is that usually when you stumble across a road like this that happens to be empty you'll be in the wrong car because you needed to do something practical that day or bring someone somewhere, its very rare planned outings in your pride and joy coincide with perfect conditions, an ideal and empty road and you being in the mood for a hoon.



I actually think that one pretty cheap but fun car is better than two and provided you don't regularly need it to be practical you can hire a van for load lugging, or maybe get something practical and performance oriented like a fast estate. The cost savings of having one car over two can be considerable too.

ETA: to the OP get something that balances sporty and sensible, you know what your needs are get something that meets them, but I'd say whatever you get just make sure its fun.

Edited by patmahe on Wednesday 22 September 16:46

T84

Original Poster:

6,941 posts

223 months

Wednesday 22nd September 2010
quotequote all
I'm thinking ST220 Estate or similar to provide fun and practicality alongside my bike, I don't lug many loads but there are a few times a year where I'd like to carry loads of gear smile

volumeone

321 posts

193 months

Wednesday 22nd September 2010
quotequote all
Get a Jaguar 3.0 V6 Estate then, at least you'll get AWD.

y2blade

56,318 posts

244 months

Wednesday 22nd September 2010
quotequote all
good thread smile

"Sporty" cars are not a patch on "Sporty" motorbikes
I have a couple of bikes and a "sensible" car

Maybe one day I'll have a proper "Sporty" car but so far I've not really wanted one (otherwise I'd have bought one)

Edited by y2blade on Wednesday 22 September 16:57

T84

Original Poster:

6,941 posts

223 months

Wednesday 22nd September 2010
quotequote all
I quite fancy a Diesel as they seem the best of both worlds, good fuel economy and you can remap if you want a bit more shove, cheap to insure and tax too but DMF/DPF/Injector issues put me off!

y2blade

56,318 posts

244 months

Wednesday 22nd September 2010
quotequote all
T84 said:
I quite fancy a Diesel as they seem the best of both worlds, good fuel economy and you can remap if you want a bit more shove, cheap to insure and tax too but DMF/DPF/Injector issues put me off!
go for it
I love mine (S60 D5) it keeps up with my T5 now, and does more than double the MPG in all situations

I bought it as a "hack" but I am so impressed with it it has all but replaced my T5 as my main car... my other half uses my T5 now

just don't bother with the 1.9VAG TDIs, the engine is a real let down (even the 150) after driving any of the bigger engine Diesels


BTW ignore the Diesel hater idiots on here wink I'm sure they'll be along in a while