reliable 50mpg diesel for a grand
reliable 50mpg diesel for a grand
Author
Discussion

steebo888

Original Poster:

784 posts

220 months

Sunday 10th October 2010
quotequote all
ok im looking for a reliable diesel for work commuting of 20k a year that does 50mpg. i have about a grand to spend with the preference of under 150k on the clock and so far have a shortlist of;

golf mk3/4
polo 96-2000
ibiza 97-2000
focus
a4 95-97


im looking for other options or would like to hear on what you have and how it is on reliability

Conian

8,030 posts

223 months

Sunday 10th October 2010
quotequote all
passat tdi about an S reg

Pints

18,449 posts

216 months

Sunday 10th October 2010
quotequote all
As the owner of both a VAG and Ford diesels (both 2L), I'd take the VAG anytime. In fact, I fking hate the Focus. fking hate it.

That is all. As you were.

Nash_wrx

467 posts

205 months

Sunday 10th October 2010
quotequote all
VAG diesel +1

Swoxy

2,842 posts

232 months

Sunday 10th October 2010
quotequote all
Audi 80?

martin mrt

3,878 posts

223 months

Sunday 10th October 2010
quotequote all
Look hard enough and you may find a BMW 325 or 525tds, they should get near to 50mpg but be a damned sight better than the other suggestions

Other than that Passat over an A4 more car for your money.


matt21

4,371 posts

226 months

Sunday 10th October 2010
quotequote all
martin mrt said:
Look hard enough and you may find a BMW 325 or 525tds, they should get near to 50mpg but be a damned sight better than the other suggestions

Other than that Passat over an A4 more car for your money.
you will struggle to average 40mpg out of one of these, let alone 50mpg! great cars though!

dougc

8,240 posts

287 months

Sunday 10th October 2010
quotequote all
Peugeot 406 HDi. Not glamorous but comfy with a huuuuuuuuuuuuuuuge fuel tank and 50mpg. Should be able to get something with around 100-120k on it for £1000. Friend has one for hacking back and forth to work and easily gets 700+ miles to a tank at high 40s, low 50s.

XitUp

7,690 posts

226 months

Sunday 10th October 2010
quotequote all
martin mrt said:
Other than that Passat over an A4 more car for your money.
Octavia for even more for your money.

SlowStig

916 posts

193 months

Sunday 10th October 2010
quotequote all
cheap plug but dads got an 02 reg 206 hdi for sale. reliably gets 60+ mpg and costs 35 quid road tax!

steebo888

Original Poster:

784 posts

220 months

Sunday 10th October 2010
quotequote all
cheers for the replys, i think german seems the best bet for engines doing over 200k although i read that the 2.0 hdi engine in the pug 206/306/406 is pretty good as well.
gona test a few out in the next week and also goto the local bca auction to see what i can find

Kevin VRs

13,657 posts

302 months

Sunday 10th October 2010
quotequote all
Skoda Octavia TDi fits the bill.

richyb

4,615 posts

232 months

Sunday 10th October 2010
quotequote all
dougc said:
Peugeot 406 HDi. Not glamorous but comfy with a huuuuuuuuuuuuuuuge fuel tank and 50mpg. Should be able to get something with around 100-120k on it for £1000. Friend has one for hacking back and forth to work and easily gets 700+ miles to a tank at high 40s, low 50s.
I agree. I had a 406 hdi 90 for 3 years and it was a great motorway cruiser. 70 litre tank and 60mpg on a run was great.

bazking69

8,620 posts

212 months

Sunday 10th October 2010
quotequote all
306 Diesel?

shaun442k

262 posts

218 months

Sunday 10th October 2010
quotequote all
Just sold my 206 2.0 HDi for about a grand with 162k miles on it. Engine still sweet and new owner getting 62-63mpg out of it. Cheap motoring. Never broke down either. In 50k miles of ownership, all it had was regular servicing, cambelt change and new £40/pair wishbones at front as bushes knackered.
Not bad for a french car. Recommended if you're after a cheap and reliable car.

DJC

23,563 posts

258 months

Sunday 10th October 2010
quotequote all
1.9tdi Passat.

I bought mine for £540 last yr. Ive down 25,000 miles in it since Xmas eve now, it will do 30k by the end of the year.

rumpelstiltskin

2,805 posts

281 months

Sunday 10th October 2010
quotequote all
I've had an old 99 Rover 75 2.0 cdt to run about in,very economical,BMW turbo diesel motor,86,000 miles,service history,£800!Best thing i ever bought!

thejpster

227 posts

184 months

Sunday 10th October 2010
quotequote all
I drove an 2001 Octavia TDi 110 from 95k to 175k and all it needed (aside from consumables) was four shocks and a front ARB. Fairly sure it was on the original clutch and turbo too. Did 54 mpg. I even upgraded it to the OEM satnav and the dashboard that showed satnav directions.

I miss that car. I'm pretty sure you could get one for a grand.

crofty1984

16,829 posts

226 months

Sunday 10th October 2010
quotequote all
My Dad had a 306 diesel and I've had a mk3 golf td (not tdi)
Both engines are fine (I thought the TD was a little agricultural but OK) As far as the car that surrounds them the golf rots and there's the risk of electrical maladies with the pug. Also, may only be mine but the gearbox was like stirring porridge. Still, I commuted 1hr plus each way every day in it for 6 months, it never let me down and even towed "a substantial amount" for 5 hrs down south.
I'd argue the pug 306 would be the better driver's car.
So if you do go for the Golf, check the bodywork thoroughly. The arches are obvious, but also behind the front lip of the bonnet, watser catches in the rubber seal.

Fabiao

125 posts

184 months

Sunday 10th October 2010
quotequote all
matt21 said:
martin mrt said:
Look hard enough and you may find a BMW 325 or 525tds, they should get near to 50mpg but be a damned sight better than the other suggestions

Other than that Passat over an A4 more car for your money.
you will struggle to average 40mpg out of one of these, let alone 50mpg! great cars though!
They're also shockingly unreliable as they age.