I'm going to buy a car. Which one?
I'm going to buy a car. Which one?
Author
Discussion

MrPeters

Original Poster:

371 posts

186 months

Tuesday 2nd November 2010
quotequote all
Ok. So I'm bored with my current hack. It owes me nothing, and tbh I'll probably sorn it and come back to it if I ever want to use it again. So, I decided I'd buy something new.

I'm split between what I want to go for though. I can't decide if I want something go-kart-y or big and womfy. I'm willing to spend upto around £2500.

The car will be used twice weekly for running between Hull and Scarborough - so on crappy B roads.

Option one: The GF has a Fiesta thingy which is rather good fun, despite it being the 1.25. I understand the Zetec S came with a 1.6 which would be all
right in a car that size. The thing that concerns me slightly is whether I'd find the ride too harsh on the road between Driffield and Staxton.

Option two: I do rather like old E class Mercs. Not the really old ones, but the quite but no so old ones. Like this:


Are they as comfortable as they look? Anything to watch out for? I understand rust is an issue (with both vehicles I've mentioned), Cambelts? Diesel options for the merc? Did it come with the 5cyl diesel engine (3.2, iirc).

Cheers!

mnkiboy

4,409 posts

189 months

Tuesday 2nd November 2010
quotequote all
If money is an issue, then you're probably best going the Fiesta route than the E-Class route.
The Merc could land you with big bills, the fiesta is less likely to do so.

Personally, i'll suggest 2.0 Focus Zetec. Drives well and is reasonably comfy, and won't cost the earth to run.

But really, you need to decide if you want fun or comfy, before people will offer suggestions.
Currently, you've narrowed it down to 'a car'.

MrPeters

Original Poster:

371 posts

186 months

Tuesday 2nd November 2010
quotequote all
mnkiboy said:
If money is an issue, then you're probably best going the Fiesta route than the E-Class route.
The Merc could land you with big bills, the fiesta is less likely to do so.

Personally, i'll suggest 2.0 Focus Zetec. Drives well and is reasonably comfy, and won't cost the earth to run.

But really, you need to decide if you want fun or comfy, before people will offer suggestions.
Currently, you've narrowed it down to 'a car'.
Money isn't an issue as such... But if I'm getting big bills (circa >£1k) regularly it'd get tiresome rather quickly.

My current car is a 'middle of the road' sort of car, much like the Focus. I think, to be honest, I'm more likely to go with the Merc.

harryowl

1,114 posts

204 months

Tuesday 2nd November 2010
quotequote all
mx5

MrPeters

Original Poster:

371 posts

186 months

Tuesday 2nd November 2010
quotequote all
harryowl said:
mx5
Don't fit. Already had one. Too tight a squeeze.

T84

6,941 posts

217 months

Tuesday 2nd November 2010
quotequote all
If it helps I have an old Focus and it's a fking moneypit.

winshent

1,174 posts

218 months

Tuesday 2nd November 2010
quotequote all
MrPeters said:
mnkiboy said:
If money is an issue, then you're probably best going the Fiesta route than the E-Class route.
The Merc could land you with big bills, the fiesta is less likely to do so.

Personally, i'll suggest 2.0 Focus Zetec. Drives well and is reasonably comfy, and won't cost the earth to run.

But really, you need to decide if you want fun or comfy, before people will offer suggestions.
Currently, you've narrowed it down to 'a car'.
Money isn't an issue as such... But if I'm getting big bills (circa >£1k) regularly it'd get tiresome rather quickly.

My current car is a 'middle of the road' sort of car, much like the Focus. I think, to be honest, I'm more likely to go with the Merc.
Your profile says you already own an E class.. are you just looking at buying another one?

MrPeters

Original Poster:

371 posts

186 months

Tuesday 2nd November 2010
quotequote all
winshent said:
MrPeters said:
mnkiboy said:
If money is an issue, then you're probably best going the Fiesta route than the E-Class route.
The Merc could land you with big bills, the fiesta is less likely to do so.

Personally, i'll suggest 2.0 Focus Zetec. Drives well and is reasonably comfy, and won't cost the earth to run.

But really, you need to decide if you want fun or comfy, before people will offer suggestions.
Currently, you've narrowed it down to 'a car'.
Money isn't an issue as such... But if I'm getting big bills (circa >£1k) regularly it'd get tiresome rather quickly.

My current car is a 'middle of the road' sort of car, much like the Focus. I think, to be honest, I'm more likely to go with the Merc.
Your profile says you already own an E class.. are you just looking at buying another one?
That's in my 'fantasy garage' thingemybob?

winshent

1,174 posts

218 months

Tuesday 2nd November 2010
quotequote all
MrPeters said:
winshent said:
MrPeters said:
mnkiboy said:
If money is an issue, then you're probably best going the Fiesta route than the E-Class route.
The Merc could land you with big bills, the fiesta is less likely to do so.

Personally, i'll suggest 2.0 Focus Zetec. Drives well and is reasonably comfy, and won't cost the earth to run.

But really, you need to decide if you want fun or comfy, before people will offer suggestions.
Currently, you've narrowed it down to 'a car'.
Money isn't an issue as such... But if I'm getting big bills (circa >£1k) regularly it'd get tiresome rather quickly.

My current car is a 'middle of the road' sort of car, much like the Focus. I think, to be honest, I'm more likely to go with the Merc.
Your profile says you already own an E class.. are you just looking at buying another one?
That's in my 'fantasy garage' thingemybob?
Nope.. its in your current fleet at the moment..

Anyway.. if its a choice of the two.. i'd go for a fiesta.. should be able to get a reasonable MY02 car for that amount of cash..

Edited by winshent on Tuesday 2nd November 13:02

ManOpener

12,467 posts

192 months

Tuesday 2nd November 2010
quotequote all
T84 said:
If it helps I have an old Focus and it's a fking moneypit.
I've got one and besides the ariel snapping off and a broken wing mirror adjuster it's tip top.

T84

6,941 posts

217 months

Tuesday 2nd November 2010
quotequote all
Does it have 110k on it smile

edthedead

386 posts

205 months

Tuesday 2nd November 2010
quotequote all
E-class = RUST RUST RUST