RE: I, Robot Or Spaceship? The Sound Of The E-tron
RE: I, Robot Or Spaceship? The Sound Of The E-tron
Wednesday 10th November 2010

I, Robot Or Spaceship? The Sound Of The E-tron

Audi decides how cars will sound driving down electric avenue...



Audi is currently trying to work out what its 2012 e-tron cars will sound like - and it sounds as if help will come from film star Will Smith.

It sounds odd, but because electric cars are near-silent at speeds of up to 15mph, so Audi's acousticians (there's a job that'd be a talking point at cocktail parties) are deciding just what noise its electric cars should make to alert pedestrians and other road users to their presence.

This is where Will Smith comes in, because his 2004 film I, Robot features the Audi RSQ concept car, and the noise that car makes in the film, we're told, may give an indication of how electric Audi models of the future may sound.

"The obvious approach would be to work on the basis of the familiar sound of a combustion engine," says Christian Schueller, Head of Brand Development/Corporate Identity (whatever that means) at Audi. "On the other hand, we want to underscore that an electric or hybrid Audi is an innovative product. We also want to make our Vorsprung durch Technik audible in the era of electric mobility."

Audi's sound chaps and chapesses are also said to be drawing inspiration from the sound of space travel from science fiction films. We suppose the only question is whether you want yout e-tron to sound Like the Enterprise or the Millennium Falcon...

Author
Discussion

Mercutio

Original Poster:

304 posts

184 months

Tuesday 9th November 2010
quotequote all
I actually like the sound of the warp drive from Star Trek, but mixed with a little of that throaty roar I'm used to hearing.

Something distinct, but not too far from what we know and love.

sleepersix

127 posts

229 months

Tuesday 9th November 2010
quotequote all
Has to be a TIE fighter howl.....

Riggers

1,859 posts

200 months

Tuesday 9th November 2010
quotequote all
sleepersix said:
Has to be a TIE fighter howl.....
Good call...

Mr Gear

9,416 posts

212 months

Tuesday 9th November 2010
quotequote all
sleepersix said:
Has to be a TIE fighter howl.....
I rode a prototype electric motorcycle thatmade EXACTLY this sound, but with no speakers attached, it was just from the motor and chain. Like.

EDIT: A lot like this- http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l5oml9uHbkw

Skip on to 2:56 for a good example!

Edited by Mr Gear on Tuesday 9th November 14:47

chazwozza

930 posts

208 months

Tuesday 9th November 2010
quotequote all
Riggers said:
sleepersix said:
Has to be a TIE fighter howl.....
Good call...
You win!

jdw1234

6,021 posts

237 months

Tuesday 9th November 2010
quotequote all
The car in the Jetsons made a cool noise!


Roberty

1,180 posts

194 months

Tuesday 9th November 2010
quotequote all
sleepersix said:
Has to be a TIE fighter howl.....
or that of a Speederbike (Minus the scream of the Midget in the Koala costume!)

M666 EVO

1,129 posts

184 months

Tuesday 9th November 2010
quotequote all
Or the droney (bit scary) sound that Darth Vaders ship makes at the start of Return of the Jedi... That'd be neat

Daniel1

2,931 posts

220 months

Tuesday 9th November 2010
quotequote all
chazwozza said:
Riggers said:
sleepersix said:
Has to be a TIE fighter howl.....
Good call...
You win!
another +1 from me, that would be so smokin

Agent Orange

2,194 posts

268 months

Tuesday 9th November 2010
quotequote all
Riggers said:
sleepersix said:
Has to be a TIE fighter howl.....
Good call...
Very good call!

I'd say the Tron Lightcycle

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1AwvuirSEAA&fea...

dvance

605 posts

190 months

Tuesday 9th November 2010
quotequote all
Why settle for one sound? I am pretty certain they'll be going for an emulation i.e. some sort of dedicated speaker and playback unit, so they might as well let you pick whatever you fancy from a pre-set collection...

anonymous-user

76 months

Tuesday 9th November 2010
quotequote all
Surely they will become like ringtones on phones where you can download your own, a massive market for manufactures to open into.....could be quite an experience trying to cross the road though..!

thegreenhell

21,672 posts

241 months

Tuesday 9th November 2010
quotequote all
Spokey Dokes on the wheels would do the trick.

goron59

397 posts

193 months

Tuesday 9th November 2010
quotequote all
+1 for TIE fighter, although some other possibilities:

  • Ice cream van :-)
  • Magic Roundabout sound.
  • Super Mario when he gets the invincible star boost.
  • Bonanza theme tune.
  • Anything you choose from your iPod.

orbital

14 posts

302 months

Tuesday 9th November 2010
quotequote all
Why does it have to make any noise, why can't pedestrians just look before they cross the road.

But if it has to, it could say something like, "Look at me I own an electric Audi therefore I am a bigger cock than that petrol audi drivers....."

VPower

3,598 posts

216 months

Tuesday 9th November 2010
quotequote all
Are they saying they are trying to make the drive train to make a certain noise?

WHY?

Manufacturers have been trying to make their cars quieter for years.

Even my old A8 could not be heard over the normal hustle and bustle at 15mph.

A modern top of the range car "Wafts" along.

I though PH has told us Lotus have patented the electronic noise box already?


So I've just put in a patent application for a device that holds different length/width/thickness/materials of "Lolly Stick" against the wheel, so that the spokes of the alloy wheel makes that noise kids loves so much! All adjustable from the cabin of course!

The original ZOOM Lolly stick is just Chavtastic!

Some Gump

13,009 posts

208 months

Tuesday 9th November 2010
quotequote all


Failing tat, the germans should stick to what they know. They want futuristic, new sound? Kraftwerk here we come!

scubadude

2,619 posts

219 months

Tuesday 9th November 2010
quotequote all
Tardis sounds for me please... or Merlin equipped Spitfire.

Seriously, they need a "scaleable" sound (is that a word?) like an engine sound that changes as RPM/Speed increase, be awfully tiresome to hear from inside if its a constant beep or something like a reversing alarm!

For what its worth this might be something to add to IC engined luxury cars, was nearly flattened by a Lexus that backed silently from its garage one morning at I cycled past, however on the same trip I heard and avoided several rattling diesels and a couple of scratchy 4pot petrol engined cars.

SevenR

242 posts

186 months

Tuesday 9th November 2010
quotequote all
I've said for a while now that I think in the future you'll be able to select from your dash what sound you want to hear whilst driving. So if you fancy a V12, it'll sound like that or a V6 or a screaming Honda 4 pot etc.
That's just on the inside mind you. As for the outside, it needs noise of some kind for pedestrians. The old electric trolley buses in Glasgow used to knock people down all the time years ago.
I vote for the sound the pod racers made in the Star wars movie Phantom Menace.

Edited by SevenR on Tuesday 9th November 16:50

pantalooons

23 posts

210 months

Tuesday 9th November 2010
quotequote all
The two way swoosh from K.I.T.T? Not sure all cars would suit a strobing red light on the bonnet though.