Which Moron thought Electric Handbrakes
Which Moron thought Electric Handbrakes
Author
Discussion

telecat

Original Poster:

8,528 posts

257 months

Thursday 9th December 2010
quotequote all
Were a good idea on a Sports Hatchback??? VAuxhall have decided that the Astra SRI "needs" this pointless option as Standard. Yet Climate Control and Multi CD remain Options?????

Despite the tasty Turbo petrols this has taken them off the list to replace the wife's car.

rottie102

4,029 posts

200 months

Thursday 9th December 2010
quotequote all

TheEnd

15,370 posts

204 months

Friday 10th December 2010
quotequote all
Quite a few BMWs have electric steering locks.

They break quite commonly too.

anonymous-user

70 months

Friday 10th December 2010
quotequote all
My mother's Discovery 3 has an electric hand brake, she was driving along and something failed in it casuing the brakes to lock on. Lucking she was only driving slowly at the time.

Pints

18,448 posts

210 months

Friday 10th December 2010
quotequote all
Oddly enough I was talking to a colleague about these yesterday. Electric handbrake on his Passat went FUBAR on the way into a multi-storey carpark causing all sorts of hilarity.

F i F

46,970 posts

267 months

Friday 10th December 2010
quotequote all
I had my rant about these in the Volvo forum on the S60 thread.

I reckon these things have been introduced for the sort of mongs who cannot figure out how to operate a normal handbrake properly, e.g. pull it on rasping the ratchet, don't apply it properly and don't leave the car in gear so it runs away and so on.

In short people who can't drive very well and what's worse don't care that they are lousy drivers. The sort who should be culled.

Then the manufacturers have to offer all sorts of bodgery as extras such as hill hold and active hold BECAUSE THE ELECTRIC HANDBRAKE CONCEPT JUST DOESN'T WORK IN ANY DECENT WAY IF YOU KNOW HOW TO DRIVE PROPERLY!!!!!!

Are you listening car designers, bet not you're just the sort of spastic-ated window licking mongtwots that this garbage was designed for. censored

daveparry

988 posts

216 months

Friday 10th December 2010
quotequote all
Does that not act on both front and rear brakes at the same time, and does it have a rachet?

rottie102 said:

anonymous-user

70 months

Friday 10th December 2010
quotequote all
First time I drove a Prius, same thing happened. I ws sat at the traffic lights in Basngstoke at rush hour, the car would not move for toffee. Ended up having to totally turn it off, get out, lock it, unlock and start again. Hateful things. Totally confusing and as far from intuitive as you can get.

anonymous-user

70 months

Friday 10th December 2010
quotequote all
F i F said:
spastic-ated window licking mongtwots
laugh

T.K

461 posts

194 months

Friday 10th December 2010
quotequote all
daveparry said:
Does that not act on both front and rear brakes at the same time, and does it have a rachet?
I love pistonheads.

Vipers

33,294 posts

244 months

Friday 10th December 2010
quotequote all
I wonder how many actually ratchet the handbrake, I was taught on my HGV3 course not to, it would wear the handbrake out, and I never have ratcheted it since.

Opinions will differ of course. How is it taught these days I wonder?




smile

Jonny_693

5,442 posts

192 months

Friday 10th December 2010
quotequote all
rottie102 said:
I was under the impression that technically those aren't legal on a road car because the handbrake needs to be mechanical rather than hydraulic.

Trevelyan

727 posts

205 months

Friday 10th December 2010
quotequote all
telecat said:
Despite the tasty Turbo petrols this has taken them off the list to replace the wife's car.
Seems a bit extreme. I don't particularly like them either and consider them to be pointless but it hasn't stopped me buying a car with one fitted. It's just something you get used to. After having the car for a few days it just seems normal to use one.

LuS1fer

42,685 posts

261 months

Friday 10th December 2010
quotequote all
I will never buy a car with an electronic handbrake. The end.

madala

5,063 posts

214 months

Friday 10th December 2010
quotequote all
LuS1fer said:
I will never buy a car with an electronic handbrake. The end.
....plus one....absolutely 'feckin STUPID idea.

F i F

46,970 posts

267 months

Friday 10th December 2010
quotequote all
madala said:
LuS1fer said:
I will never buy a car with an electronic handbrake. The end.
....plus one....absolutely 'feckin STUPID idea.
I'd really like to say plus two but the way industry does the "Me too!!!" thing I wonder how long it will be.

Let's face it, I can recall saying "If petrol ever gets to £1 a gallon then I'll stop driving as it will be just too expensive.

Is there a foot in mouth smiley?

LuS1fer

42,685 posts

261 months

Friday 10th December 2010
quotequote all
F i F said:
madala said:
LuS1fer said:
I will never buy a car with an electronic handbrake. The end.
....plus one....absolutely 'feckin STUPID idea.
I'd really like to say plus two but the way industry does the "Me too!!!" thing I wonder how long it will be.

Let's face it, I can recall saying "If petrol ever gets to £1 a gallon then I'll stop driving as it will be just too expensive.

Is there a foot in mouth smiley?
Not a problem for me, I'll just go and buy an older car, I feel that strongly about it.
How much better can you honestly get than an infinitely variable cable-operated clamp that works. Why do we need more switches and servos and relays.
Can you ever imagine a Lotus Elise with one?
Precisely!

GestapoWatch

1,393 posts

206 months

Friday 10th December 2010
quotequote all
This is really annoying me as its present on almost all the nearly-new Bimmers I'm looking at (X6, F10 5er etc..).

I assumed there was a foot brake like on the Merc I used to have (which was equally scensored for my fat legs) but no - stupid plasticky 'comfort' switch to the rescue!!

madshootidea

Edited by GestapoWatch on Friday 10th December 08:53

Thorburn

2,417 posts

209 months

Friday 10th December 2010
quotequote all
LuS1fer said:
Can you ever imagine a Lotus Elise with one?
Precisely!
With Bahar in charge.......

The Wookie

14,164 posts

244 months

Friday 10th December 2010
quotequote all
Have to say I've driven a few and never had a problem, perhaps they were particularly good systems but typically I found them to be pretty easy and convenient.

I came to the conclusion that it's a bit like most of PH getting wound up about one-touch indicators. Frankly, if you find it that difficult to operate one touch indicators, then you're the one that's stupid. The first time my girlfriend drove my 1er, the first car she'd ever driven with them, she didn't even comment on it, she drove 200 miles, regularly indicating through a variety of different sorts of roads and roundabouts, and didn't cock it up once.

At the end of the journey I asked her about it, and her exact words were 'I noticed it was different, but it's pretty fking obvious how it works isn't it?'