the BEST Gearchanges ???
the BEST Gearchanges ???
Author
Discussion

jackal

Original Poster:

11,251 posts

311 months

Sunday 12th June 2011
quotequote all
What's your best BOX people ?



The ones that I remember:

Honda S2000, lovely action and throw, a bit clinical and japanese for my tastes though
Griffith 4.0, amazing box, tiny travel and very mechanical but can be a PITA
993RS short shift, lovely and organic and mechanical, could be a bit shorter
Ferrari 360/430, mechanical and satisfying, that click and gorgeous gate
Exige S2, clattery but in keeping with the car and very characterful
205GTi, still reckon it after all these years


But my winner has to be the Caterham 6 speed box. The throw is perfect, wonderfully short but very useable and quick, gorgeously weighty and just the most delicious mechanical feeling to it. To gun a powerful caterham up through the gears with the 6 speed is one of life's real treats.

Stu R

21,638 posts

244 months

Sunday 12th June 2011
quotequote all
BMW S1000RR with a quickshifter. Faster than superman with his arse on fire.

jackal

Original Poster:

11,251 posts

311 months

Sunday 12th June 2011
quotequote all
Stu R said:
BMW S1000RR with a quickshifter. Faster than superman with his arse on fire.
thats a bike, and a bmw, so excluded by definition on both counts

TheStig44

170 posts

210 months

Sunday 12th June 2011
quotequote all
EP3 Civic Type R has the best gearbox Ive ever used. Silky smooth yet a satisfying mechanical clunk when the gear is selected!


Stu R

21,638 posts

244 months

Sunday 12th June 2011
quotequote all
jackal said:
Stu R said:
BMW S1000RR with a quickshifter. Faster than superman with his arse on fire.
thats a bike, and a bmw, so excluded by definition on both counts
Damn, I'm crushed. In that case a Holinger sequential in a 33 GTR.

iva cosworth

44,044 posts

192 months

Sunday 12th June 2011
quotequote all
Escort RS2000 Mk2,tiny movements,quickshifts,very precise,only 4 speeds to think about smile

Oldandslow

2,405 posts

235 months

Sunday 12th June 2011
quotequote all
Has to be said.

MX5. Like the bolt action on a well oiled rifle smile

Animal

5,667 posts

297 months

Sunday 12th June 2011
quotequote all
TheStig44 said:
EP3 Civic Type R has the best gearbox Ive ever used. Silky smooth yet a satisfying mechanical clunk when the gear is selected!
Me too.

xr287

875 posts

209 months

Sunday 12th June 2011
quotequote all
You didn't specify manual so...................

First time I went flat out in an F430 F1 in race mode, wow it changes gear fast if you have just stepped out of a manual car and it feels so aggressive, very satisfying!

Manual box, probably the Caterham CSR.

grenpayne

2,082 posts

191 months

Sunday 12th June 2011
quotequote all
jackal said:
...But my winner has to be the Caterham 6 speed box. The throw is perfect, wonderfully short but very useable and quick, gorgeously weighty and just the most delicious mechanical feeling to it. To gun a powerful caterham up through the gears with the 6 speed is one of life's real treats.
I'm biased but yes it's very, very good. When you get the blip on the down change right too it's heaven woohoo

Turbo Harry

5,196 posts

266 months

Sunday 12th June 2011
quotequote all
I've never driven a manual box better than an S2000's.

danneth

1,083 posts

216 months

Sunday 12th June 2011
quotequote all
ep3 type-r

LukeBird

17,170 posts

238 months

Sunday 12th June 2011
quotequote all
The 6-speed in my MX-5 is fantastic.
Always enjoyed the gearbox in my dad's Seven as well.

otolith

68,809 posts

233 months

Sunday 12th June 2011
quotequote all
MX-5 is excellent, but EP3 better, in my opinion.

aeropilot

40,636 posts

256 months

Sunday 12th June 2011
quotequote all
Should have done a search as we did a dozen or so page thread on this very subject about a year or so ago.....

My favourite is still the same though..

Ford 2000E as fitted to a Twin Cam/Mexico/RS1600, not driven a better manual 'box since.

stephen300o

15,464 posts

257 months

Sunday 12th June 2011
quotequote all
Seems a lot of romanticism for just stirring a stick..

jackal

Original Poster:

11,251 posts

311 months

Sunday 12th June 2011
quotequote all
The mx5 is great but bettered by the s2000 so thats why i didnt mention it. Both are slightly too clinical and lacking in good old fashioned mechanicalness to topple the very best changes imo.

I like the idea of including paddle changes. I hope to try th 430f1 box very soon. The 458 box is supposed to be even more amazing .. A whole other league.

jackal

Original Poster:

11,251 posts

311 months

Sunday 12th June 2011
quotequote all
stephen300o said:
Seems a lot of romanticism for just stirring a stick..
For me its a massively important thing when driving/choosing a car. Changing gear is 33% of everything you do and there is as much if not more percieved feel to it as the steering and pedals so in some ways it can be quite defining of the overall experience of a car.

The worst box ive ever owned has to go to the esprit S4. Like all things you get used to it of course but today it just wouldnt be allowed. People moan about the evora box ... Theyve never had it so good ! I think the M5 manual shift would come in as second worst, just a horrid thing with tons of baulk to go with it.

Martin_Hx

4,028 posts

227 months

Sunday 12th June 2011
quotequote all
Another vote for the EP3 Civic, quick throw and very accurate. When its fully warmed up that is smile

mattcov

721 posts

255 months

Sunday 12th June 2011
quotequote all
S2000