Video : 458 v 12c v SLS v Performante v GT2RS v R8V10
Video : 458 v 12c v SLS v Performante v GT2RS v R8V10
Author
Discussion

Rich_W

Original Poster:

12,548 posts

241 months

Tuesday 21st June 2011
quotequote all
http://vimeo.com/25352861

Don't click the spoiler below till you've watched.

Probably not the result you were expecting. "Allegedly" McLaren said this car had some problems so they came back with another car on a different day and went fastest..... Yeah RIGHT!

Patrick Bateman

13,172 posts

203 months

Tuesday 21st June 2011
quotequote all
I would expect the McLaren to be faster.

FraserLFA

5,083 posts

203 months

Tuesday 21st June 2011
quotequote all
Surely they should have tested all hard tops?

FraserLFA

5,083 posts

203 months

Tuesday 21st June 2011
quotequote all
I think most people prefer the Ferrari. Let's face it, everyone's aware of Ferrari's history with road testers

Turbo Harry

5,196 posts

266 months

Tuesday 21st June 2011
quotequote all

Rich_W

Original Poster:

12,548 posts

241 months

Tuesday 21st June 2011
quotequote all
FraserLFA said:
Surely they should have tested all hard tops?
Maybe, but it's telling that the soft top version Lambo is still faster than the 12C.

davislove

2,295 posts

275 months

Tuesday 21st June 2011
quotequote all
ow, Ron won't be happy

Tallbut Buxomly

12,254 posts

245 months

Tuesday 21st June 2011
quotequote all
That was utterly st. They had the opportunity to do something really fun/great and they made a real hash of it. As for the result well i am not convinced the macca isnt the fastest otherwise why would they have been claiming it is?

It seems to me that he didnt know how to set the car up for a quick lap as iirc macca have at various points stated you can disable the driver aids i believe.

jon-

16,534 posts

245 months

Tuesday 21st June 2011
quotequote all
I actually enjoyed that, nice to see some cars doing some laps in the same conditions. The 458 did well to stay in front of the GT2, given it was on the super sports not the cup tyres.

Has to be said tho, as much as I like / respect Ben Collins he should have stayed voiceless. He doesn't have much TV charisma.

Rawwr

22,722 posts

263 months

Tuesday 21st June 2011
quotequote all
Surprised about the GT2RS result. I was expecting it to be the quickest of the bunch.

Fittster

20,120 posts

242 months

Tuesday 21st June 2011
quotequote all
After all the hype coming out from the Mcbunch things aren't actually going that well.

I wonder if any speculators are getting nervous about their deposits?

YourMother

29 posts

188 months

Tuesday 21st June 2011
quotequote all
Rawwr said:
Surprised about the GT2RS result. I was expecting it to be the quickest of the bunch.
Mee too. I'd also thought with the trick braking system the Mclaren has - would be second.

Were the Ferrari boys there the day before setting it up for the track with a choice of tyres and a remapped engine (as per usual?).

Fair enougth. 458 > 12c on this track. Maybe with Lewis smile at the wheel of the 12c on the top gear track, he'd make up the difference between the 2. After all Mclaren did anounce that the 12c is great in dealing with slow corners.

After getting trounced by the competition the 12c has slipped down my lottery car list.

jon-

16,534 posts

245 months

Tuesday 21st June 2011
quotequote all
To be fair to the 12c, we don't know what tyres it was on. We do know the GT2 and 458 were on cut slicks, which could easily be 2 seconds around rockinghams twisty infield if the 12c was on "normal" uhp tyres...

Fittster

20,120 posts

242 months

Tuesday 21st June 2011
quotequote all
jon- said:
To be fair to the 12c, we don't know what tyres it was on. We do know the GT2 and 458 were on cut slicks, which could easily be 2 seconds around rockinghams twisty infield if the 12c was on "normal" uhp tyres...
And the Lamborghini?

The 997 and Lamborghini are old designs that are due to be replaced and even the Ferrari has been around for a while now.

Every group test in the media is resulting in some straw clutching about the 12C. If the Top Gear test says the 12C is the better car does that mean we all have to take Clarkson's words as the ultimate truth?

Edited by Fittster on Tuesday 21st June 23:46

jon-

16,534 posts

245 months

Tuesday 21st June 2011
quotequote all
Fittster said:
jon- said:
To be fair to the 12c, we don't know what tyres it was on. We do know the GT2 and 458 were on cut slicks, which could easily be 2 seconds around rockinghams twisty infield if the 12c was on "normal" uhp tyres...
And the Lamborghini?

Every group test in the media is resulting in some straw clutching about the 12C. If the Top Gear test says the 12C is the better car does that mean we all have to take Clarkson's words as the ultimate truth?
From what I've seen the hardcore lambos also come on cut slicks.

I'm not defending the McLaren, in fact I'd probably have every other car on test other than the R8 over the MP4-12C, I'm just saying a few seconds can easily be won or lost in a tyre and we don't know what rubber the 12c is on.

That said, McLaren aren't stupid.

GroundEffect

13,864 posts

185 months

Tuesday 21st June 2011
quotequote all
Didn't expect the Mclaren to be 1.8 seconds slower than the Ferrari.

So, the Ferrari looks better, sounds better and is faster. I'll take one in.....crap, I can't choose which colour I want.

SlipStream77

2,153 posts

220 months

Wednesday 22nd June 2011
quotequote all
Interesting, if TC really is not switchable on the McLaren, I wonder how many people will consider it a 'deal-breaker'. I'm sure many potential customers will want to drive at track days in full control of the car.

I thought the video wasn't bad, although less music and more engine sound would have been better.

Asterix

24,438 posts

257 months

Wednesday 22nd June 2011
quotequote all
I know we're mentioning 'cut slicks' but these are the tyres the cars, at least in the GT2's case - not sure about the Fez, come with stock from the factory.

Maybe McLaren need to spec their entry comparatively - you can't blame the Porsche's performance on 'special' tyres when they are stock items.

Not that anyone really was hehe

kambites

71,474 posts

250 months

Wednesday 22nd June 2011
quotequote all
Well I suppose you sort of could if the Porsche was only available with cut slicks and the McLaren was available with either road focused tyres or cut slicks. Mind you if that was the case, I don't think Mclaren would have been stupid enough to put the press car on the slower tyre.

I'd also be interested to know what tyres the R8 was on. I'm quite impressed by how close it got to the more expensive cars anyway; if that was on ordinary road tyres, it's even more impressive.

the-photographer

5,102 posts

205 months

Wednesday 22nd June 2011
quotequote all
SlipStream77 said:
Interesting, if TC really is not switchable on the McLaren, I wonder how many people will consider it a 'deal-breaker'. I'm sure many potential customers will want to drive at track days in full control of the car.

I thought the video wasn't bad, although less music and more engine sound would have been better.
Even PistonHeads found the off switch....

http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?f=23&...

And if you look very carefully in the driver's manual - on about page 86, written in very small letters - you'll even find that there's a way to turn all the electronics off