'quality' family hatchback ?
'quality' family hatchback ?
Author
Discussion

Fatboy40

Original Poster:

22 posts

182 months

Thursday 7th July 2011
quotequote all
Getting close to the time to replace my car, and I'm struggling to think of what to go with next.

I want a Mondeo sized car as the kids are getting bigger, something around five years old and it must be a hatchback. My ideal choice would be another Honda (I've a 98 Civic VTI that I've has since it was five years old) but the Accord is not a hatchback and I realy don't need an estate.

I'm strugling to think of a well built, as in I buy it at five years old and look after it so it lasts me to ten years or more, car that matches the above.

For me the Mazda 6 is an option, but long term I don't see it as being better than a Mondeo (other than the looks and handling).

I just can't think of a German or Japanese car that fits the above spec ?. Not fussed if it's petrol or diesel, or about performance as I'm in a new job with a commute that's just a short motorway cruise (so no more nice twisty country roads and overtaking opportunities frown ).

Ta.

Heathwood

3,032 posts

231 months

Thursday 7th July 2011
quotequote all


Skoda Octavia VRS?

poing

8,743 posts

229 months

Thursday 7th July 2011
quotequote all
Skoda Octavia? It's the same quality as a VW/Audi, unless by quality you mean badge, but I don't see Skoda as any worse than Ford or Mazda in image terms now.

Edit, beaten to it! Damn you bladder for making me need a wee!

turbopug

285 posts

182 months

Thursday 7th July 2011
quotequote all
Mondeo sized car?

How about a Mondeo?

Efbe

9,251 posts

195 months

Thursday 7th July 2011
quotequote all
is that vrs a hatchback? didn't know that!

5charlie46

248 posts

204 months

Thursday 7th July 2011
quotequote all
You might not need an estate but it isnt half nice having that extra space. thats why I'd suggest a Passat TDi or 1.8t estate. We bought ours on 150,000 and its now on 260,000miles without a single real problem. Good image, quality build and comfy, pretty perfect in my book!

Fatboy40

Original Poster:

22 posts

182 months

Thursday 7th July 2011
quotequote all
For a long while I've been thinking about a diesel Octavia VRS, but there's just not enough rear leg room frown

Why can't there just be an Accord or A4 hatchback, then I'd be happy.

Regarding a Mondeo, I'm just not a Ford fan, I've never been happy with any I've owned.

Contigo

3,139 posts

238 months

Thursday 7th July 2011
quotequote all
Fatboy40 said:
For a long while I've been thinking about a diesel Octavia VRS, but there's just not enough rear leg room frown

Why can't there just be an Accord or A4 hatchback, then I'd be happy.

Regarding a Mondeo, I'm just not a Ford fan, I've never been happy with any I've owned.
If there is not enought rear leg room for you in the Octavia VRS then the A4 in any form is not any better. The A4 B5,B6 and B7 are pitiful on rear leg room and it's only the B8 (fourth gen 2008->) that really gives you the extra leg room in front and rear and that's because the chassis is a good 7 in longer.

A 2005 onwards Passat Estate is about the biggest in it's class for load space and rear leg room so I'd go for one of those if I were you. Get an Estate if you want something similar to a hatch for loading as the Saloon loading can be a pita.


Contigo

3,139 posts

238 months

Thursday 7th July 2011
quotequote all
Come on then Hora make some suggestions? The Passat is about as good as a family car gets and to be fair there are not many out there other than the one's already mentioned on here.


Nick3point2

3,920 posts

209 months

Thursday 7th July 2011
quotequote all
Ok I'll bite, why does it hVe to be a hatchback? Why not a saloon or estate?


I like my wife's seat altea. Well screwed together and my 6'5" friend (and since this is pistonheads, yes he is powerfully built, no he doesn't have a goatee) fits in the back with absolute ease.

Boot is pretty good too, fitted 2 suitcases and overnight bags perfectly well.

Minemapper

933 posts

185 months

Thursday 7th July 2011
quotequote all
Skoda Superb is a hatch, no?

ewenm

28,506 posts

274 months

Thursday 7th July 2011
quotequote all
What's your objection to an estate? It seems to fit the bill perfectly and is just a slightly longer hatchback.

Of course there are sportback options like an Impreza for example.

Fatboy40

Original Poster:

22 posts

182 months

Thursday 7th July 2011
quotequote all
Minemapper said:
Skoda Superb is a hatch, no?
Nope, it's a saloon.

Fatboy40

Original Poster:

22 posts

182 months

Thursday 7th July 2011
quotequote all
With a family, DIY, yadda yadda yadda a hatchback just suits me well.

A saloon's too restrictive for loading the car up, and I just don't need or want an estate.

I'm working from a very limited pool of cars I think ?.

ewenm

28,506 posts

274 months

Thursday 7th July 2011
quotequote all
Fatboy40 said:
Minemapper said:
Skoda Superb is a hatch, no?
Nope, it's a saloon.
Isn't it one of those dual-opening boots? So both saloon and hatch. Lagunas have them too IIRC.

ewenm

28,506 posts

274 months

Thursday 7th July 2011
quotequote all
Fatboy40 said:
I'm working from a very limited pool of cars I think ?.
Yes, you're deliberately severely restricting your choices by saying "no estates" :shrug:

Heathwood

3,032 posts

231 months

Thursday 7th July 2011
quotequote all
Are the Vauxhall Insignia things hatchbacks?

Fatboy40

Original Poster:

22 posts

182 months

Thursday 7th July 2011
quotequote all
Heathwood said:
Are the Vauxhall Insignia things hatchbacks?
Definately time for me to go to bed now, don't want to be having nightmares wink

Heathwood

3,032 posts

231 months

Thursday 7th July 2011
quotequote all
Fatboy40 said:
Definately time for me to go to bed now, don't want to be having nightmares wink
Fair point; and you did say 'quality'. wink

Contigo

3,139 posts

238 months

Thursday 7th July 2011
quotequote all
Problem is as soon as you say hatchback you are limiting the size of the car e.g Golf, Auris, Civic, Focus etc.... They are crap on legroom when compared to even the VRS which you mention as being lacking in the leg room department.

The saloon options are better than the small hatches mentioned above but still limit you to the likes of Mundano, Mazda 6, Insignia, Skoda Superb (split tailgate),Avensis, Accord etc....

I'd stick with what you've got biggrin