What Do Do When The Garage Can't Find The Fault
What Do Do When The Garage Can't Find The Fault
Author
Discussion

R500POP

Original Poster:

9,073 posts

239 months

Friday 15th July 2011
quotequote all
The little 500 is in the dealers at the moment with a misfire, they have driven it, and have said they can feel exactly what I'm describing to them "yes, there is a definate misfire". The car is under manufacturers warranty.

However, computer says no........

As the diagnostic system has no fault code etc, they cannot repair it because "we can't just replace things willy nilly".

Told them that I want it reapired as it's under warranty and by their admittance it has a fault, they are saying they can't do it.

At the moment I'm telling them that I'm not returning with their loan car until it's fixed.

Dracoro

9,026 posts

274 months

Friday 15th July 2011
quotequote all
Speak to Fiat.

Maybe try another dealer.

What you don't want, is the current dealer "hacking" away at it hoping to find the problem.

Utlimately though, it's a misfire, any competent mechanic should be able to diagnose it.

fueling? electrics? (sparks, leads, coils etc.) sensors? co2/maf/map etc.

I bet they plugged it in, didn't tell them much so gave up as they don't have any real mechanics there, just fitters ("technicians" biggrin) who need the computer to tell them everything.

LuS1fer

43,508 posts

274 months

Friday 15th July 2011
quotequote all
What engine is it. I had a Punto in 1995 and it suffred a duff O2 sensor and a cracked head which that engine was prone to (not sure what they use now TBH).

POORCARDEALER

8,663 posts

270 months

Friday 15th July 2011
quotequote all
Sometimes a fault needs to develop a bit further for a correct diagnosis....Misfire, I would stick to your guns.

mnkiboy

4,409 posts

195 months

Friday 15th July 2011
quotequote all
Sounds like they are hoping you'll say "Well it's only a minor issue, don't worry about it if it's too much hassle".

Keep pushing them. If they need to fit new parts to test then that's what they'll have to do. Plenty of other dealers go down this route when unable to trace a fault. Just make sure you don't get charged for it.

Maybe ask to speak to the dealer principle and ask him/her how they are planning on resolving this issue.

R500POP

Original Poster:

9,073 posts

239 months

Friday 15th July 2011
quotequote all
Dracoro said:
I bet they plugged it in, didn't tell them much so gave up as they don't have any real mechanics there, just fitters ("technicians" biggrin) who need the computer to tell them everything.
That's my thoughts, because the diagnostics say no fault they are stumped.

I asked if they have an OBDII logger to plug in when they drive the car to see what that throws up, "a what" was the answer.,

neiljohnson

11,298 posts

236 months

Friday 15th July 2011
quotequote all
Find a better garage any compentent tech should be able to trace a misfire.

If there is no code recorded it means the ecu doesnt know its missing therefore a mechanical fault is likely.

First thing i would look at is a fuelling problem as there is no fault relating to overfuelling but i would also do a compression check to eliminate a fault there.

Its not rocket science to do, normally its problems that bring lights on for random faults that are hard to find.

XDA

2,153 posts

214 months

Friday 15th July 2011
quotequote all
I suspect if it wasnt under warranty, they'd be more than happy to "investigate"...

R500POP

Original Poster:

9,073 posts

239 months

Friday 15th July 2011
quotequote all
It's not a permanent misfire, only at part throttle, under full load it's fine, and it's only when the engine is up to temp.

It's a 1.2 petrol by the way.

Dr Boxcat

705 posts

198 months

Friday 15th July 2011
quotequote all
had the same problem with my beemer, except it was really misfiring, like 3 out of 4 cylinders and the computer detected that one. Problem is, 3 new coil packs and an every now and then misfire. took it to the dealer on their advice - no problem detected by the computer, so they won't take any further action. I'm just waiting for the warranty to run out then a major fault to emerge. gotta love computers

R500POP

Original Poster:

9,073 posts

239 months

Friday 15th July 2011
quotequote all
The real bummer is they have given me a Pug 207 as a loan car & it's possibly the sttest car I have ever had the misfortune to have to drive, really, it's terrible.

anonymous-user

83 months

Friday 15th July 2011
quotequote all
Dracoro said:
Speak to Fiat.
This. Their tech department may know about the problem? They may send someone who knows what they are doing to look at it! (Ford used to do this).

R500POP

Original Poster:

9,073 posts

239 months

Friday 15th July 2011
quotequote all
Dave_ST220 said:
This. Their tech department may know about the problem? They may send someone who knows what they are doing to look at it! (Ford used to do this).
That's what I'm doing, waiting on the garage to call me back with any more information, then if it's not fixzed I'll be on the phone to Fiat.

sklar

1,491 posts

245 months

Friday 15th July 2011
quotequote all
R500POP said:
The real bummer is they have given me a Pug 207 as a loan car & it's possibly the sttest car I have ever had the misfortune to have to drive, really, it's terrible.
Not Dandos is it?

R500POP

Original Poster:

9,073 posts

239 months

Friday 15th July 2011
quotequote all
sklar said:
Not Dandos is it?
Now you know we are no supposed to name & shame..................


























might be

sklar

1,491 posts

245 months

Friday 15th July 2011
quotequote all
207 gave it away. I live in Sodbury myself and went in many times over the winter trying to get them to sort out the power steering light flash fault on the OHs 500.

Looking at fiatforum it seems that the tiny battery isn't that great in the cold so the PS ECU doesn't get the required voltage so throws a fault. They kept clearing the logs, but didn't have any clue how to fix it. It stopped when the warmer weather came along but I just know it'll return this winter.