Another "what car" ... First car?
Another "what car" ... First car?
Author
Discussion

911p

Original Poster:

2,361 posts

210 months

Monday 8th August 2011
quotequote all
Which first car? Any recommendations from recent new drivers? Struggling to decide on which car I should aim to get.

I did hear somewhere that a 1.6 MX5 is 'insurable' for a new driver... I'm finding this hard to believe?

cris654321

233 posts

190 months

Monday 8th August 2011
quotequote all
i dont know what sort of quotes your getting but i couldnt get anything below 2grand ended up getting a 1.1 saxo but with it being group 4 maybe try get some in group 1or2 as old light and slow with as few seets as possible. unless your rich, but i think you will struggle to get something rwd for a first car

DanB7290

5,535 posts

220 months

Monday 8th August 2011
quotequote all
I know it's not the most PH car around, but a 1.2 Fiat Panda is perfect for young drivers. I'm 21 and living smack in the centre of town, and my insurance quote this year was just £290. Drop me a PM if you like, as mine needs to get shifted soon!

Dalto123

3,205 posts

193 months

Monday 8th August 2011
quotequote all
Im afraid you havent been informed well about the MX5 for learners frown

Insurance is the biggest pain for leaners now (I passed last september), and getting a 'normal' car insured is a big cost. I 've had quotes in the region of £9000 for me on my 998cc micra.

My advice would be:

Get a car with as little engine as possible - under 1.4 - the lower the better.
Dont go for Third party. The insurance company will know that you are after the most basic policy so go for Third Party Fire and Theft instead or Fully Comp.
Stick your parents on the policy and have them as a main driver and you as the named driver.
Limit your miles to something low
Check out some specialist young driver websites, sometimes you may get a cheap quote but only if they will fit a black box to your car, meaning they will monitor your driving, they may also limit the hours you can drive too.
CALL the insurance company, they may say theydont insure under 25's on their webpage, but talk to them and you may be pleasantly surprised.

As it turns out with a bit of investigating I found out that Kit Car insurance and classic car insurance can be significantly lower than 'ordinary car' insurance smile

If you want to have something interesting, something a bit more sporty as a learner and fully lisenced driver, I would suggest talking to these guys: http://younggunsclassics.forumcircle.com/

I posted a similar thread to yours about insurance for an 18yr old. They came back to me saying their premiums are a lot lower as its a classic and also being part of a club gives you a fairly dhunky discount, I recall one member paying under £1000 on a Triumph spitfire 1500. He is part of a Triumph car club giving him a discount.

Be aware when your insurance comes to renewal for the first time after you have passed your premium is likely to be higher than it was when you were learning so dont be surprised.

Good luck, hope you can find a nice car to learn in, probably not the Porsche though (my dad didnt let me learn on his tongue out) and keep us posted smile

Phil

DanB7290

5,535 posts

220 months

Monday 8th August 2011
quotequote all
I wouldn't recommend being a named driver on a parent's policy, this is called fronting, which is illegal and gives the insurer another excuse not to pay out in the event of a smash. It is cheaper putting your folks on as named drivers than having just yourself on there, but only by about £100.

Vulgar LS2

1,785 posts

213 months

Tuesday 9th August 2011
quotequote all
If you can find a rot free one, ford Ka's (53 plate onwards are 70bhp) are a propper laugh, not the most macho though.

Dalto123

3,205 posts

193 months

Tuesday 9th August 2011
quotequote all
DanB7290 said:
I wouldn't recommend being a named driver on a parent's policy, this is called fronting, which is illegal and gives the insurer another excuse not to pay out in the event of a smash. It is cheaper putting your folks on as named drivers than having just yourself on there, but only by about £100.
I must have mixed my facts up on my post, we didnt front the insurance company tongue out

CanadianScot

1,916 posts

196 months

Tuesday 9th August 2011
quotequote all
Where you live and what you do are big factors for insurance. Mine was considerably cheaper than others because I live in the country, and while I'm at uni my cars just left there because I don't use it.

911p

Original Poster:

2,361 posts

210 months

Tuesday 9th August 2011
quotequote all
Dalto123 said:
Stuff
Cheers Phil, how old does the car have to be to be considered a classic?

cheesyblob

370 posts

205 months

Tuesday 9th August 2011
quotequote all
911p said:
Dalto123 said:
Stuff
Cheers Phil, how old does the car have to be to be considered a classic?
To get classic insurance, 25 years old normally. Try specialist insurers such as Adrian Flux, Footman James and Peter James and call them, as they are unlikely to give you a quote online.

sawman

5,168 posts

260 months

Tuesday 9th August 2011
quotequote all
cheesyblob said:
To get classic insurance, 25 years old normally. Try specialist insurers such as Adrian Flux, Footman James and Peter James and call them, as they are unlikely to give you a quote online.
A lot of classic policys do not accrue a no claims discount, check for this if you look at one.

Donatello

1,035 posts

191 months

Tuesday 9th August 2011
quotequote all
The only way to give yourself a real chance of getting insurance under £1,500 would be to pick a car that not many young, first time drivers would drive.

Saxo, 106, Fiesta etc... are cars that will have been bought and crashed alot more often than say a Kia Picanto. That obviously means the cars are viewed in a higher risk catergory.

Someone I know bought a Perodua as their first car and his first year was under a grand (he was just turned 20)...

Look at rare and classic cars and you should be onto a winner!

Facefirst

1,412 posts

204 months

Tuesday 9th August 2011
quotequote all
If you can afford it, a Panda 100HP is only group 5 ins. They look alright, are honestly very good to drive, frugal, have quite a natty / well equipped interior (BT stereo, aircon, sports seats etc), plus they even sound pretty good.

If I were in the market for a first car and was looking for something reasonably nice, then I would be looking here.

Highway Star

3,615 posts

261 months

Tuesday 9th August 2011
quotequote all
Dalto123 said:
Stick your parents on the policy and have them as a main driver and you as the named driver.
If you are the main driver, is this not fronting? Don't insurance companies take a very dim view of this?

Facefirst

1,412 posts

204 months

Tuesday 9th August 2011
quotequote all
Highway Star said:
If you are the main driver, is this not fronting? Don't insurance companies take a very dim view of this?
Yep, that's fronting. Best to build up your own NCB and just accept driving a snotter for a few years. Harsh, but the stats say what the stats say.

eltax91

10,763 posts

236 months

Tuesday 9th August 2011
quotequote all
sawman said:
cheesyblob said:
To get classic insurance, 25 years old normally. Try specialist insurers such as Adrian Flux, Footman James and Peter James and call them, as they are unlikely to give you a quote online.
A lot of classic policys do not accrue a no claims discount, check for this if you look at one.
Also, don't most classic policies only permit drivers over a certain age too? As well as cars?

Aar0sc

279 posts

187 months

Tuesday 9th August 2011
quotequote all
Dalto123 said:
If you want to have something interesting, something a bit more sporty as a learner and fully lisenced driver, I would suggest talking to these guys: http://younggunsclassics.forumcircle.com/

I posted a similar thread to yours about insurance for an 18yr old. They came back to me saying their premiums are a lot lower as its a classic and also being part of a club gives you a fairly dhunky discount, I recall one member paying under £1000 on a Triumph spitfire 1500. He is part of a Triumph car club giving him a discount.
Yep; Young Guns is very good! wink

And I'm 17; and 3rd party F&T insurance on my '77 Spitfire 1500 is £951 a year; it's garaged; not agreed value; limited milage; and I'm a TSSC member; and they fight rather hard to get young members a rather sizable discount!

Aaron

cheesyblob

370 posts

205 months

Tuesday 9th August 2011
quotequote all
eltax91 said:
sawman said:
cheesyblob said:
To get classic insurance, 25 years old normally. Try specialist insurers such as Adrian Flux, Footman James and Peter James and call them, as they are unlikely to give you a quote online.
A lot of classic policys do not accrue a no claims discount, check for this if you look at one.
Also, don't most classic policies only permit drivers over a certain age too? As well as cars?
Hence why I said to give them a call, as they often will let people of any age be insured by them. It also helps to be a part of an owners club.

Dalto123

3,205 posts

193 months

Tuesday 9th August 2011
quotequote all
cheesyblob said:
911p said:
Dalto123 said:
Stuff
Cheers Phil, how old does the car have to be to be considered a classic?
To get classic insurance, 25 years old normally. Try specialist insurers such as Adrian Flux, Footman James and Peter James and call them, as they are unlikely to give you a quote online.
Actually I believe its 20 years, my dads 944 went on a classic policy in '09 as its an '89 car.

Wedg1e

27,038 posts

295 months

Tuesday 9th August 2011
quotequote all
Aar0sc said:
And I'm 17; and 3rd party F&T insurance on my '77 Spitfire 1500 is £951 a year; it's garaged; not agreed value; limited milage; and I'm a TSSC member; and they fight rather hard to get young members a rather sizable discount!

Aaron
Not too shabby: I had a '69 Mk 3 Spit when I was 18 (a loooong time ago) - it used to cost me £36 a month TPF&T - but my take-home pay (in banking!) was £150 a month... so equivalent I guess to paying £250 or so a month now? I have no idea what teens get paid, we're all old farts in our company.
Back then the Spit wasn't a 'classic', just an old car, but even then the loading was clear: the 1000cc Mini I had before the Triumph cost me £100 a year.