Car Crash
Author
Discussion

JoPo1

Original Poster:

386 posts

177 months

Saturday 1st October 2011
quotequote all
My brother was in a car crash in 2008 where a girl suffered some sort of medical mishap and crashed into him on the wrong side of the road.
Now it's all been settled after her insurance dragging their heels about her medical condition.
The problem is, the insurance are trying to give my brother the Market value of his car at today's value, As opposed to it's value in 2008 when it was written off.

He disputed this and thankfully they have offered to pay him the value of the car in 2008. But they want written proof of it's value back then, so how can he get a written valuation of a car that's probably a can of coke now?

For what it's worth and if it helps, It was a 2004 Vauxhall Corsa, good condition with 38k miles. Again, I know it's near impossible to value a car without seeing it, which is the problem we face.

Ideas?

christofmccracke

881 posts

220 months

Saturday 1st October 2011
quotequote all
Guide book prices?

danyeates

7,248 posts

242 months

Saturday 1st October 2011
quotequote all
JoPo1 said:
My brother was in a car crash in 2008 where a girl suffered some sort of medical mishap and crashed into him on the wrong side of the road.
Now it's all been settled after her insurance dragging their heels about her medical condition.
The problem is, the insurance are trying to give my brother the Market value of his car at today's value, As opposed to it's value in 2008 when it was written off.

He disputed this and thankfully they have offered to pay him the value of the car in 2008. But they want written proof of it's value back then, so how can he get a written valuation of a car that's probably a can of coke now?

For what it's worth and if it helps, It was a 2004 Vauxhall Corsa, good condition with 38k miles. Again, I know it's near impossible to value a car without seeing it, which is the problem we face.

Ideas?
Just ask a dealer to give you a written valuation. I do it all the time for customers that have had their boats stolen. (I'm a boat dealer)

JoPo1

Original Poster:

386 posts

177 months

Saturday 1st October 2011
quotequote all
But can we get a price written for what it would have been worth in 2008? That seems hard to value?

Oh, I appreciate your replys, thanks.

cahami

1,248 posts

226 months

Saturday 1st October 2011
quotequote all
In 2008 the car would have been 4 years old, can you not base it on a similar model/ mileage 4 year old corsa now?

Matt UK

18,080 posts

220 months

Saturday 1st October 2011
quotequote all
Would there not a 2008 valuation book like glasses or whatever that could be referred to?

The Moose

23,498 posts

229 months

Saturday 1st October 2011
quotequote all
Glasses guide back to 2008? Don't see why this should be a problem to find. PM me full details (e.g. spec levels, 2/3/4/5 door etc) and month it happened.