Can anyone recomend an insurer for a 17 year old?
Can anyone recomend an insurer for a 17 year old?
Author
Discussion

mat13

Original Poster:

1,977 posts

201 months

Thursday 10th November 2011
quotequote all
My brother will be insuring his first car soon (a 1999 1.2 vauxhall corsa im currently doing up) and ive just been having a quick look on insurance. Ive only looked on the basic sites (confused and compare the meerkat) but the cheapest i can get it is around 7000 on his own, 5000 with me or one of my parents as a named driver, or around 2000 with me as the main driver and him as the main.

I know that i will probably get a few cheaper quotes by calling specialists but i was wondering if the vast font of knowledge that is pistonheads had any recomendations?

chrisispringles

893 posts

185 months

Thursday 10th November 2011
quotequote all
By 'doing up', do you mean modifying? If so, insuring a 17 y/o male on a modified Corsa, no chance.

jdw1234

6,021 posts

235 months

Thursday 10th November 2011
quotequote all
2000 sounds quite good for a 17 year old in a barried corsa.


mat13

Original Poster:

1,977 posts

201 months

Thursday 10th November 2011
quotequote all
Sorry just to clarify by doing up i mean fitting a new engine and refreshing the brakes and suspension.

samsoon19

10 posts

169 months

Thursday 10th November 2011
quotequote all
That sounds really high, try Co-op, they did me a really good price and were great to deal with. Also they seem the only company that will still insure you 3rd party for other cars at that age which is useful.

It's definately worth him being in his own name because it really makes a difference having No Claims for the few years after that!

EDLT

15,421 posts

226 months

Thursday 10th November 2011
quotequote all
£2k sounds about right to me tbh. Insurance has really gone up recently.

SD1992

7,278 posts

178 months

Thursday 10th November 2011
quotequote all
Admiral, Aviva, Bell, Elephant, Tesco, and maybe Quinn are all good bets.

It will be killer in the first year, but once he gets some NCD under his belt it will be much easier.

McSam

6,753 posts

195 months

Friday 11th November 2011
quotequote all
To those saying £2k sounds about right, that is only via a fronting policy.. Which I really do not recommend.

Let him be the main driver, partly because it's the law to declare correctly and partly so he can earn his own NCB, but add two middle-aged women as named drivers. Really does not matter who, but two is the optimum number. Play around with where is most cost-effective to park the car and things like that. Someone in the Admiral Group would probably be your best bet, especially since they offer 10-month policies - reducing premium amount, and also giving a year's NCB quicker.

LukeSi

5,780 posts

181 months

Friday 11th November 2011
quotequote all
2k? How do you get it that cheap? Lowest I've been quoted for something recent is £3250. For a 14 year old volvo s60.

EDLT

15,421 posts

226 months

Friday 11th November 2011
quotequote all
LukeSi said:
2k? How do you get it that cheap? Lowest I've been quoted for something recent is £3250. For a 14 year old volvo s60.
Have you tried an S40, if a barge is what you want, the 1.6 is barely capable of moving so can't be that expensive to insure.

SD1992

7,278 posts

178 months

Friday 11th November 2011
quotequote all
LukeSi said:
2k? How do you get it that cheap? Lowest I've been quoted for something recent is £3250. For a 14 year old volvo s60.
A Volvo S60? Pretty sure all of them have a turbo, hence prices rofl

1.8 Mondeo is a better bet if that is what you are after, dirt cheap to buy and insure.

LukeSi

5,780 posts

181 months

Friday 11th November 2011
quotequote all
EDLT said:
Have you tried an S40, if a barge is what you want, the 1.6 is barely capable of moving so can't be that expensive to insure.
Yup, would much rather have a nice barge than some silly little hatchback (for a first car), (and then the year after the Panda will be mine hehe)

I shall have to find out how much one of those snatch landrovers the MOD are selling would cost to insure. How epic would that be rocking up at college in a bleedin military landrover.

MartyPubes

900 posts

179 months

Friday 11th November 2011
quotequote all
mat13 said:
Sorry just to clarify by doing up i mean fitting a new engine and refreshing the brakes and suspension.
All standard though? As others have said there's no 'secret' to it - just use the comparison sites and start from there. Although Elephant were always reasonable when I was younger. And Norwich Union funnily enough, who put me in my first Jag at 20.

vit4

3,507 posts

190 months

Friday 11th November 2011
quotequote all
samsoon19 said:
That sounds really high, try Co-op, they did me a really good price and were great to deal with. Also they seem the only company that will still insure you 3rd party for other cars at that age which is useful.

It's definately worth him being in his own name because it really makes a difference having No Claims for the few years after that!
My thoughts word-for-word. Although I've had one issue with them regarding them taking a payment which wasn't mentioned when I renewed my insurance (first year renewal though) which left me a couple of hundred quid overdrawn, their response was very good. Got onto the phone once I'd realised (10 days or so after it had been taken, my account charges me daily for any overdraft) and credit to the bloke, if I'd been dealing with me I think I'd have hung up hehe Managed to calm down a bit, and after talking a bit more they accepted that their adviser got the payment schedule wrong and gave me a refund equivalent to my overdraft charges. That mistake asides, all dealings with them have been very pleasant.

And as

samsoon19

10 posts

169 months

Friday 11th November 2011
quotequote all
vit4 said:
samsoon19 said:
That sounds really high, try Co-op, they did me a really good price and were great to deal with. Also they seem the only company that will still insure you 3rd party for other cars at that age which is useful.

It's definately worth him being in his own name because it really makes a difference having No Claims for the few years after that!
My thoughts word-for-word. Although I've had one issue with them regarding them taking a payment which wasn't mentioned when I renewed my insurance (first year renewal though) which left me a couple of hundred quid overdrawn, their response was very good. Got onto the phone once I'd realised (10 days or so after it had been taken, my account charges me daily for any overdraft) and credit to the bloke, if I'd been dealing with me I think I'd have hung up hehe Managed to calm down a bit, and after talking a bit more they accepted that their adviser got the payment schedule wrong and gave me a refund equivalent to my overdraft charges. That mistake asides, all dealings with them have been very pleasant.

And as
Yeah they were great with me when I forgot to cancel the insurance on my astra before I left for Canada (was drunk and at T in the Park) but cancelled the direct debit beforehand, trying to be organised... Actually phoned to say they owed me money because I had payed the first and last month upfront. I've never payed more than £1100 in my own name since 17, and £600 odd when I was 20, so keep at it, there are deals out there, phone direct and haggle, they often have discounts they don't advertise online, but do when you speak to them! I've been with Direct Line, Bell(end... they gave me a silly high renewal) Quinn Direct(in administration apparently now) and Co-op, they were by far the best. Now in Canada of course I have no driving record and pay loads, but "gas" is alot cheaper so I tolerate it!