I know, not another "what car" thread!
I know, not another "what car" thread!
Author
Discussion

Davie_GLA

Original Poster:

6,864 posts

222 months

Thursday 17th November 2011
quotequote all
Apologies first of all but i need the collective inspiration of you lot.

Currently I own a 2006 E60 525d (Mapped smile) - i absolutely love it but even with the 1 or 2 mpg increase from the map it's still really only averaging 34-35mpg. This is costing me around £90 a week in fuel just for commuting.

So i need something else, the catch is i don't want to lose the comfort of the E60.

I guess for it to be do-able i'll need something that will average closer to 45mpg.

Thoughts?

David.

FreeLitres

6,121 posts

200 months

Thursday 17th November 2011
quotequote all
£90 of juice will get me around 7000 miles.

biggrin

GreatGranny

9,519 posts

249 months

Thursday 17th November 2011
quotequote all
Budget?
Unless you are doing a straight swap it might not be worth it unless you get something that will do 50+ all day.
A passat would be just as comfortable imo and average 45+ but its a step down. What about a 320d?

Morba

621 posts

200 months

Thursday 17th November 2011
quotequote all
have you figured out how much you will be saving after purchase of a different car? Will it really be worth it?

Jayho

2,394 posts

193 months

Thursday 17th November 2011
quotequote all
A lighter pair of shoes or move your seat back a notch? wink

Volvo360

8,202 posts

174 months

Thursday 17th November 2011
quotequote all
Skoda Superb TDi 130.

Davie_GLA

Original Poster:

6,864 posts

222 months

Thursday 17th November 2011
quotequote all
Budget is around £10k but wouldn't be against a straight swap.

And i do drive it fairly sensibly, it gets the odd prod now and then but not much at all.

jagnet

4,373 posts

225 months

Thursday 17th November 2011
quotequote all
According to my quick calculations, you'd be looking at a £20 per week saving if you did manage to get a car that did 45mpg. I can't think of any barges that'll do that as an average across all driving conditions, and anything less than a barge isn't going to give you the comfort/equipment levels you currently enjoy.

An XJ 2.7 TDVi is a possibility, but you're probably not going to see more than 40mpg, so that's just a £10 per week saving.

Are you getting the most you can out of your existing car? Are you using the brakes more than necessary through lack of anticipation and use of acceleration sense, for example. You don't have to drive like Miss Daisy to see improvements.

Personally, I'd seek out some additional driver training first, before changing a car I like and know just for the sake of getting a few more mpg.

RoseyG21

1,596 posts

212 months

Thursday 17th November 2011
quotequote all
Volvo360 said:
Skoda Superb TDi 130.
This.

The estate is massive as well if you need to lug

Vladimir

6,917 posts

181 months

Thursday 17th November 2011
quotequote all
Changing cars to save a tiny bit of mpg rarely makes sense IMO.

Price to change is always hideous. Keep the BM and lighten the right foot!

Davie_GLA

Original Poster:

6,864 posts

222 months

Thursday 17th November 2011
quotequote all
I guess you're all right. Maybe i need to think about how i'm driving rather than a new car.


Willy Nilly

12,511 posts

190 months

Thursday 17th November 2011
quotequote all
Vladimir said:
Changing cars to save a tiny bit of mpg rarely makes sense IMO.

Price to change is always hideous. Keep the BM and lighten the right foot!
+1, or drive it less

Kevin VRs

13,676 posts

303 months

Thursday 17th November 2011
quotequote all
Left field here, but, move closer to work? By my basic calcs you are driving around 500 miles per week.

Davie_GLA

Original Poster:

6,864 posts

222 months

Thursday 17th November 2011
quotequote all
What would the savings be against selling the house?

mattnunn

14,041 posts

184 months

Thursday 17th November 2011
quotequote all
Volvo, V70, S60 D5

toon10

7,032 posts

180 months

Thursday 17th November 2011
quotequote all
Vladimir said:
Changing cars to save a tiny bit of mpg rarely makes sense IMO.

Price to change is always hideous. Keep the BM and lighten the right foot!
My mate just sold his Fiesta ST as it was expensive to run despite him wlaking to work, he lives that close. He had 15 months and it was paid off. He's just bought a nearly new Fiesta diesel and is saving about £30 a month on the loan and saving a bit on fuel given his lack of miles. I pointed out that he had 15 months to pay for his old car and now he has to pay over 5 years for the new! Where's the saving? Still to him, it's all about the monthly spend.

Vladimir

6,917 posts

181 months

Thursday 17th November 2011
quotequote all
toon10 said:
My mate just sold his Fiesta ST as it was expensive to run despite him wlaking to work, he lives that close. He had 15 months and it was paid off. He's just bought a nearly new Fiesta diesel and is saving about £30 a month on the loan and saving a bit on fuel given his lack of miles. I pointed out that he had 15 months to pay for his old car and now he has to pay over 5 years for the new! Where's the saving? Still to him, it's all about the monthly spend.
Sadly rather too many people think the same way!

Dalto123

3,203 posts

186 months

Thursday 17th November 2011
quotequote all
Good Comfort = Volvo
Good MPG = Volvo

No need to thank me coffee

Davie_GLA

Original Poster:

6,864 posts

222 months

Thursday 17th November 2011
quotequote all
But the wrong wheels are driven.

Vladimir

6,917 posts

181 months

Thursday 17th November 2011
quotequote all
Davie_GLA said:
But the wrong wheels are driven.
coffeewhistle