RE: PH heroes and villains of 2011
RE: PH heroes and villains of 2011
Thursday 29th December 2011

PH heroes and villains of 2011

PH salutes - with two fingers where appropriate - those who achieved the best and worst this year



Looking back on the last 12 months there are a few people deserving of hero and villain status and a few we still can't quite make our minds up about. Dany Bahar for instance. We'll give him another year perhaps and, by then, it'll probably be obvious which camp he belongs in. As compiled by Dan and Riggers here are a few to single out for special mention but we're sure you've got your suggestions too - let us know!

Heroes:


Dan Wheldon and Marco Simoncelli: Death used to be at the heart of motorsport but, bar events like the TT, is now rare enough in the mainstream to be of huge significance. And the four-wheeled and two-wheeled communities have had to deal with harsh reminders of exactly how high the stakes can still be, the dignified and heartfelt response to the very public deaths of Dan Wheldon and Marco Simoncellia credit to all in the business.

Andreas Preuninger: The bittersweet sense that this was the end of an era was clear when Porsche GT cars boss Andreas Preuninger talked us round the GT3 RS 4.0. Most pleasing was his shrugged "top speed is just a by-product" summary of what the improvements brought to the 4.0 and the implication that this wasn't a car for those obsessed with vmax bragging rights. Hurrah for that.


McLaren and Ferrari: We all remember the great supercar rivalries - Testarossa versus Countach, F40 versus 959 but 2011 saw the beginning of one that could eclipse them all - 458 Italia and MP4-12C. The ideological differences twixt McLaren and Ferrari have fascinated us on the track for years but now that fight is on the road too. And though the Italia may have taken first blood you can be sure the McLaren will come back stronger and this one is going to run and run. It's going to be great.

Derek Bell: As a man who has won Le Mans five times Derek Bell needs little to cement his 'hero' status. But after meeting him and his Porsche at Goodwood in November, the fact that he's a thoroughly nice bloke, a genuine car guy, and is in possession of a rather fine Porsche 924 Carrera GTS merely confirms what we knew already.


The ACO and the FIA: After a long history of not really working together, the ACO (which regulates Le Mans and its associated series) and the FIA (which, er, regulates most other global motorsport) have finally decided to unite the rules for global sports car racing. The result? Now there will be just two major series - the FIA World Endurance championship and the FIA GT World Championship. And we might just be about to see a new golden era of endurance motor racing. Here's hoping...

Villains:

General Motors: GM succeeded in tragically misunderstanding and mismanaging Saab for more than a decade during its ownership of the quirky Swedish brand. And then even when it had got shot of Saab it caused the axe to fall on the company by blocking its sale to Chinese investors. The loss of Saab and its broad and often-unsung engineering prowess should be a blow to car lovers everywhere. And the responsibility for its demise lies largely at The General's door.


The BBC and Sky: After more than two years of committed and impressive coverage of F1 - possibly the best coverage the sport has ever seen - the BBC backed away from the sport, making a deal with Sky for half the races to be broadcast on the satellite network from 2012 onwards. The result is that you'll no longer be able to watch an entire F1 season without having to pay for the privilege. Shame.

Japanese Ferrari drivers: For doing nothing for the reputation of Ferrari drivers or, indeed, car lovers anywhere the idiots who managed to turn a matey supercar run into an object| of international ridicule. Not to mention for wrecking a load of really nice cars too. Thanks guys.


The Nurburgring management: It's almost a year ago now that we reported on the troubles at the so-called NuroDisney leisure park that was built at the Nurburgring and it seems things aren't getting any better, with the management appealing for a reduction in the lease and job losses threatened. The Nordschleife is still there of course but the magic of the place has been corrupted by greed and incompetence - a sad state of affairs.



 

 

Author
Discussion

SmartVenom

Original Poster:

462 posts

186 months

Thursday 29th December 2011
quotequote all
Surely Bernie Ecclestone should be included in any villain list, whatever the year.

0a

24,046 posts

211 months

Thursday 29th December 2011
quotequote all
Villains - Audi for churning out mind-numbingly dull looking cars onto our roads (and too many similar looking SUVs)

Munich

1,071 posts

213 months

Thursday 29th December 2011
quotequote all
0a said:
Villains - Audi for churning out mind-numbingly dull looking cars onto our roads (and too many similar looking SUVs)
+1... hehe

GaryU

34 posts

192 months

Thursday 29th December 2011
quotequote all
Highwaymen !
Aston Martin for the Cygnet !
Anyone buying one has been robbed.

Munich

1,071 posts

213 months

Thursday 29th December 2011
quotequote all
Agree about the Nurburgring management.

Could we also include the oil companies and governments that insist on making the price of petrol ever more expensive so turning our enjoyment of driving into an expensive past time?

sinbaddio

2,632 posts

193 months

Thursday 29th December 2011
quotequote all
Guy Martin - hero of the highest order. Watching the TT dvd was a Christmas highlight!

VinceFox

20,566 posts

189 months

Thursday 29th December 2011
quotequote all
heroes: guy martin for raising the profile of road racing through personality alone.

Munich

1,071 posts

213 months

Thursday 29th December 2011
quotequote all
GaryU said:
Aston Martin for the Cygnet !
Anyone buying one has been robbed.
My mum is thinking of buying one of these to replace her Smart car. When she first mentioned this I thought it wasn't that bad of an idea, but having subsequently seen a Cygnet in the flesh and read all the hate and condemnation of them on this website, I'm now thinking it might be one of the worst car related decisions my family could make.... getmecoat

M666 EVO

1,129 posts

179 months

Thursday 29th December 2011
quotequote all
Villians - BBC, agreed. Such a shame as the last season was awesome and coverage was a real joy to watch.

Heroes - Top Gear team, as per usual...

s31tof

851 posts

176 months

Thursday 29th December 2011
quotequote all
Hero:

Mark Higgins 'Holding on' to the Subaru averaging 113 mph round the TT course?

Gixer_fan

290 posts

215 months

Thursday 29th December 2011
quotequote all
What about Tommy Hill and John Hopkins for the most incredible closing 5 laps of any championship ever (at least since Hamilton's '08 win)...

Matt Harper

6,858 posts

218 months

Thursday 29th December 2011
quotequote all
Can't agree that ACO/FIA unification is heroic given that the utterly fantastic and hugely popular Petit Le Mans at Road Atlanta gets shoved out of the WEC schedule and is replaced by a 6 hour sand-pit race in Bahrain that neither the teams or any fans will want to attend. Total bks of the highest order.

goron59

397 posts

188 months

Thursday 29th December 2011
quotequote all
Villains - BMW for churning out mind-numbingly dull looking cars onto our roads

Garlick

40,601 posts

257 months

Thursday 29th December 2011
quotequote all
s31tof said:
Hero:

Mark Higgins 'Holding on' to the Subaru averaging 113 mph round the TT course?
Ooh, that's a good one!

AngryPartsBloke

1,438 posts

168 months

Thursday 29th December 2011
quotequote all
Munich said:
Agree about the Nurburgring management.

Could we also include the oil companies and governments that insist on making the price of petrol ever more expensive so turning our enjoyment of driving into an expensive past time?
The "High" price at the pump has almost nothing to do with oil companies or the price of oil.

Wouldnt class GM has being villans anyway, lets face it saab is going down because nobody buys them! They already sell cars in the chinese market anyway so why would they let a potential rival buy a company basd around thier technology. Anyone who moans that "GM doesnt have any interlectual property worth protecting blah blah cry" is talking out of thier backside. You can all moan that saab is going, but how many of you rushed out to buy new saabs to help the company you seem to love so much?

Church of Noise

1,566 posts

254 months

Thursday 29th December 2011
quotequote all
How about Victor Muller, for screwing up what was left of SAAB?

Stuart

11,638 posts

268 months

Thursday 29th December 2011
quotequote all
GaryU said:
Highwaymen !
Aston Martin for the Cygnet !
Anyone buying one has been robbed.
Just don't get this attitude towards the cygnet at all. Nobody is forced into buying one, it helps A-M lower their group emissions levels, thus facilitating more of the stuff which does appeal here, and I think it actually looks quite good in the flesh. I'd never, ever spend my money on one, but such apparent opprobrium for merely existing I find baffling.

Dagnut

3,515 posts

210 months

Thursday 29th December 2011
quotequote all
Chris Harris..
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
both categories ....He's neither to me but has anyone divided opinion so much this year??..that thread just kept running and running

0a

24,046 posts

211 months

Thursday 29th December 2011
quotequote all
goron59 said:
Villains - BMW for churning out mind-numbingly dull looking cars onto our roads
Yes, you can't accuse their SUVs (X6) of looking dull, just unpleasant to look upon.

will261058

1,115 posts

209 months

Thursday 29th December 2011
quotequote all
GaryU said:
Highwaymen !
Aston Martin for the Cygnet !
Anyone buying one has been robbed.
Anyone buying a Cygnet deserves to be robbed!