Banger estates with biggest loading capacity and good mpg
Banger estates with biggest loading capacity and good mpg
Author
Discussion

philpalmer

Original Poster:

176 posts

237 months

Wednesday 28th March 2012
quotequote all
Looking for a banger estate - up to about £2500 to replace my aging Honda crv.
I love the Honda but fuel consumption is costing around £130 a month at the moment which is kinda scary.

So, we are now looking for a replacement estate. Ideally it needs a huge boot and good mpg.

So far, i'm looking at Octavia TDI Estate and possibly the Mondeo estate although I'm not a fan of Fords. I once had a 406 estate and that was good but the electrics not so!

Any other recommendations. Perhaps an Audi A4 estate.

Anyone know the biggest estate cars on the market for my kind of budget?
I'm finding info on Parkers/whatcar but they don't always say the loading capacity with seats down - only seats up which isn't much help.

I'd rather have a car than a van.. which is the other option.

Thanks

Rovinghawk

13,300 posts

178 months

Wednesday 28th March 2012
quotequote all
Beware the repair bills on older 'modern' diesels.

RH

KardioKate

1,584 posts

174 months

Wednesday 28th March 2012
quotequote all
Passat, surely?

philpalmer

Original Poster:

176 posts

237 months

Wednesday 28th March 2012
quotequote all
Just looking at Honda Accord estate aswell. Seems pretty massive!

matthias73

2,900 posts

170 months

Wednesday 28th March 2012
quotequote all
get another 406, and cross your fingers biggrin

Codswallop

5,256 posts

214 months

Wednesday 28th March 2012
quotequote all
The Audi A4 has a tiny boot. Omega estate is pretty roomy, and iirc, the Vectra C (along with the Accord) had one of the biggest loadbays in it's class. Doesn't look too bad either imo, and it should be cheap to buy/ run.


anonymous-user

74 months

Wednesday 28th March 2012
quotequote all
philpalmer said:
Just looking at Honda Accord estate aswell. Seems pretty massive!
They are huge! I had a bed in mine, saved me a fortune on airport hotels hehe

1981linley

937 posts

167 months

Wednesday 28th March 2012
quotequote all
The OP said BANGER! Surely any old Volvo estate will do.

eltax91

10,514 posts

226 months

Wednesday 28th March 2012
quotequote all
Try the Octavia is hatch form. Easily as big a boot as the estate, and in my experience a more 'useable' space. With the seats down in mine you can fit a huge amounts of stuff in. Only negative is the 'lip' that you don't get in an estate. Only an issue if you are always lifting very heavy and bulky items in and out.

Chris944_S2

2,053 posts

243 months

philpalmer

Original Poster:

176 posts

237 months

Wednesday 28th March 2012
quotequote all
Yep, another option is Volvo estate. I think Skoda Octavia still best bet at mo. Massive boot space and mpg.

philpalmer

Original Poster:

176 posts

237 months

Wednesday 28th March 2012
quotequote all
That Merc looks nice.
According to Parkers, the Skoda Octavia has 1700 litres when seats down but the Citroen Berlingo Multispace has 2800 litres.
Surely this is an error. The Skoda looks way bigger.


lost in espace

6,438 posts

227 months

Wednesday 28th March 2012
quotequote all
Galaxy!

rallycross

13,668 posts

257 months

Wednesday 28th March 2012
quotequote all
Galaxy/Sharan is a good shout, maybe a Mitsubishi spacewagon?

Those big Merc estates are rust buckets to be avoided.

Mondeo diesel a much better bet. But petrol an even safer bet. Huge inside, drive very well even at 150,000+ miles if looked after.

Volve 940 estate is as long as those big old mercs', sub £1k to buy, but they do feel like they are from the 70's when you climb inside (they drive ok being rwd).

No getting away from big fuel costs what ever choice you make.

philpalmer

Original Poster:

176 posts

237 months

Wednesday 28th March 2012
quotequote all
Can't be worse than 28mpg that I'm getting from the Honda!

Jw Vw

4,897 posts

183 months

Wednesday 28th March 2012
quotequote all
The VAG 1.9TDI is pretty bulletproof. A4 or Passat would be my vote.

SuperHangOn

3,486 posts

173 months

Wednesday 28th March 2012
quotequote all
rallycross said:
Those big Merc estates are rust buckets to be avoided.
You are joking right? Those are one of the most bulletproof, strongest cars ever built.

They don't even rust that bad. Front wings go (not structural) and you should give the rear jacking points a once over (not a nightmare to have welded if they are tbh).

If have a 2004 Mondeo tdci now, feels so very feeble after my W124 and the clutch/DMF just set me back a small fortune.

James_N

3,249 posts

254 months

Wednesday 28th March 2012
quotequote all
rallycross said:
Volve 940 estate is as long as those big old mercs', sub £1k to buy, but they do feel like they are from the 70's when you climb inside (they drive ok being rwd).

No getting away from big fuel costs what ever choice you make.
Volvo 940 is massive. I've had a 7/940 for years!

Buy a good one for £1k and save the other £2k for fuel costs. They also have bombproof reliability smile

Jw Vw

4,897 posts

183 months

Wednesday 28th March 2012
quotequote all
SuperHangOn said:
rallycross said:
Those big Merc estates are rust buckets to be avoided.
You are joking right? Those are one of the most bulletproof, strongest cars ever built.
This.

Merc's from that era are some of the best engineered cars of all time.

rallycross

13,668 posts

257 months

Wednesday 28th March 2012
quotequote all
SuperHangOn said:
rallycross said:
Those big Merc estates are rust buckets to be avoided.
You are joking right? Those are one of the most bulletproof, strongest cars ever built.

They don't even rust that bad. Front wings go (not structural) and you should give the rear jacking points a once over (not a nightmare to have welded if they are tbh).
Well the last one I had was a E230 97-P well looked after car with fsh but had rust coming from so many panels.

Wings, doors, tailgate, sills and worst of all the window frames, yes it drove fine and nice inside but a rust trap - which is not acceptible on a £2k purchase these days.

The late 90's merc's have some serious rust problems. I agree they drive well and feel like they are very solid but the cosmetic rust is simply not an issue with an equivalent budget passat/mondeo/galaxy but a late 90's Merc will be riddled with rust.