mini cooper vrs cooper s
mini cooper vrs cooper s
Author
Discussion

jaedba2604

Original Poster:

3,815 posts

175 months

Monday 14th May 2012
quotequote all
apologies, the search function is down.

£6k budget, looking for a cooper s, and been to see a few which are a bit rough, eg:

scruffy interior / exterior
missing service history

it's for my partner, so i reluctantly considered 'downgrading' the search to a cooper, however they seem to be a similar price.

i know they're very popular, but is finding a decent one at this budget impossible, and, supercharger / bonnet vent / tailpipes aside, are there any other differences between the two?

kind of figured that insurance and mpg explains the cooper appearing relatively expensive compared to its s stablemate.

thanks v much.

RS133

2,201 posts

201 months

Monday 14th May 2012
quotequote all

Cooper


Cooper S

Spot the difference! smile

rb5er

11,657 posts

200 months

Monday 14th May 2012
quotequote all
The main difference is that one is a hatchback and the other is a hot hatchback.

jaedba2604

Original Poster:

3,815 posts

175 months

Monday 14th May 2012
quotequote all
i didn't know if the s had more options as basic etc.

and if the suspension etc was the same.

ambuletz

11,710 posts

209 months

Monday 14th May 2012
quotequote all
207 GTi?

Same engine, better value.

veevee

1,458 posts

179 months

Monday 14th May 2012
quotequote all
How about an MX-5? TVR?

Monaro VXR?

RS133

2,201 posts

201 months

Monday 14th May 2012
quotequote all
ambuletz said:
207 GTi?

Same engine, better value.
Isn't that an R56 engine though.

These certainly don't run the Chrysler s/c 1.6s

Fox-

13,568 posts

274 months

Monday 14th May 2012
quotequote all
ambuletz said:
207 GTi?

Same engine, better value.
The engine might be the same, shame about the rest of the car though.

hyperblue

2,898 posts

208 months

Monday 14th May 2012
quotequote all
RS133 said:
ambuletz said:
207 GTi?

Same engine, better value.
Isn't that an R56 engine though.

These certainly don't run the Chrysler s/c 1.6s
Correct. For £6k, and talk of superchargers, OP is looking at R53s. I'm surprised you can't find a tidy Cooper S for that price though OP, they've really dropped in value these days.

RS133

2,201 posts

201 months

Monday 14th May 2012
quotequote all
hyperblue said:
Correct. For £6k, and talk of superchargers, OP is looking at R53s. I'm surprised you can't find a tidy Cooper S for that price though OP, they've really dropped in value these days.
I'm biased. But I'd be looking for a decent Clio 197 Cup for this much. You'd get much more bang for your buck.

JD

3,117 posts

256 months

Monday 14th May 2012
quotequote all
I'm guessing you must be after the newer shape R56, for that budget?

My R53 is Mint, and forsale for nothing near that amount, and I have had no phone calls at all!

Defcon5

6,462 posts

219 months

Monday 14th May 2012
quotequote all
JD said:
I'm guessing you must be after the newer shape R56, for that budget?

My R53 is Mint, and forsale for nothing near that amount, and I have had no phone calls at all!
Yeah, that much is more that enough for a mint R53

s m

24,403 posts

231 months

Tuesday 15th May 2012
quotequote all
Defcon5 said:
JD said:
I'm guessing you must be after the newer shape R56, for that budget?

My R53 is Mint, and forsale for nothing near that amount, and I have had no phone calls at all!
Yeah, that much is more that enough for a mint R53
I wondered that but he mentions supercharger in his OP?

jaedba2604

Original Poster:

3,815 posts

175 months

Tuesday 15th May 2012
quotequote all
apologies, don't know what r53 / r56 is. smile

it's the hatchback cooper s i'm interested in..thanks for the same engine, diff car suggestion, but being a she, that's not really an option!

if someone does have a mint supercharged hatchback < 60k miles in budget a subtle nudge in the right direction would be appreciated....colour, price etc would narrow my search..

thanks.

Edited by jaedba2604 on Tuesday 15th May 09:59

Robb F

4,614 posts

199 months

Tuesday 15th May 2012
quotequote all
RS133 said:
I'm biased. But I'd be looking for a decent Clio 197 Cup for this much. You'd get much more bang for your buck.
As soon as the electrics go bang laugh

Corsair7

20,911 posts

275 months

Tuesday 15th May 2012
quotequote all
jaedba2604 said:
apologies, don't know what rf3 / rf6 is. smile

it's the hatchback cooper s i'm interested in..thanks for the same engine, diff car suggestion, but being a she, that's not really an option!

if someone does have a mint supercharged hatchback < 60k miles in budget a subtle nudge in the right direction would be appreciated....colour, price etc would narrow my search..

thanks.
R53 is the original BMW Cooper S with a supercharger. It has a Chrysler sourced engine thats easy to tune for power, but has a bit of a drink problem. Expect to pay 5-8k depending on options age and condition.

The R56 is the next generation BMW Cooper S, with the BMW/Peugot joint venture turbo engine. Great power/torque, pretty tuneable, but much better fuel consumption. Much newer car, expect to pay 10-15k.

jaedba2604

Original Poster:

3,815 posts

175 months

Tuesday 15th May 2012
quotequote all
bit of wikipedia research...

r53, nothing we've looked at is much newer than 04 reg.

most colours considered.
less than 60k miles preferred.
not tired condition, i'm realistic though, it's £5odd k after all.
full service history, due to the servicing pattern, lots seem to miss the insp 2, the more costly one.

thanks

ArsE92

21,332 posts

215 months

Tuesday 15th May 2012
quotequote all
jaedba2604 said:
bit of wikipedia research...

r53, nothing we've looked at is much newer than 04 reg.

most colours considered.
less than 60k miles preferred.
not tired condition, i'm realistic though, it's £5odd k after all.
full service history, due to the servicing pattern, lots seem to miss the insp 2, the more costly one.

thanks
We picked up a 2005 MCS with 28k miles last month for £6k. It's a bit light on options but has everything we need, and I spent £150 on a Pioneer head unit with Bluetooth and iPod connectivity. It's black with a silver roof and bonnet stripes, and nice spider spoke wheels.

Yes, the head gasket went on the journey home from picking it up but we don't talk about that. It's all sorted now. thumbup

You should be able to get a face-lifted (2005) R53 for your budget easily. I'm not sure of the specifics of the face-lift but they are 170bhp rather than 160bhp, better Xenon's, slightly better interior apparently.

Most importantly, they are a lot of fun.